You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Ex-officer ask high court to hear case

Adams says she was fired by Enon after claiming injuries from a fall.Village has won two earlier rounds of the case.


The former Enon police officer who alleged wrongful termination by the village in a court case dismissed by a Clark County judge has requested an appeal before the Supreme Court of Ohio.

Clark County Common Pleas Judge Douglas Rastatter rejected the case on jurisdictional grounds, and his decision was upheld by the county court of appeals.

“By refusing jurisdiction over this case, the Ohio Supreme Court will be sanctioning activity which runs afoul of language promulgated by the Ohio legislature,” Vikki Adams’ attorney Erica Ann Probst wrote.

Village attorneys oppose Adams’ request.

“A memorandum opposing Ms. Adams’ request to have the Ohio Supreme Court hear her case was sent to the court today,” Village Attorney Lynnette Dinkler told the Springfield News-Sun via email Thursday. “Regardless of whether the court accepts Ms. Adams appeal on what is a jurisdictional question, the village of Enon will continue to aggressively defend this matter.”

Adams’ initial suit alleged the village owed her damages in excess of $25,000 due to a retaliatory termination for filing workers’ compensation claims after a fall in the police department’s parking lot in early 2009, according to court documents.

She later amended her complaint to include disability and age discrimination, which were considered moot due to the dismissal.

The village asked to dismiss on the basis that Adams failed to comply with the state’s written notice requirements and because it was not in the court’s jurisdiction, and Rastatter agreed.

“Defendant’s failure to provide written notice deprives this court of jurisdiction,” Rastatter wrote in the May 2012 order.

Adams appealed Rastatter’s decision in June, saying the village “received notice of the claims (it) had against it for worker’s compensation retaliation within 90 days of her termination and a complaint was filed within 180 days of her termination.” The judge’s decision was upheld last month by the Court of Appeals of Clark County.

Presiding Appeals Judge P.J. Grady in his opinion wrote that Adams failed to file a written notice of violation to the village prior to her filing the lawsuit, as required by the Ohio Revised Code.

“Adams contends that nothing in (the ORC) indicates a legislative intent that the notice must be received by the employer prior to filing a complaint alleging the violation (in court),” Grady wrote. “We do not agree. (The ORC) expressly states that ‘no action may be instituted … unless the employer has received written notice of a claimed violation of this paragraph within the 90 days immediately following the (termination).”

The fall left Adams “severely injured including a broken rib, torn rotator cuffs and additional injuries to her shoulder, neck and elbow,” according to court documents.

Her appeal before the state court hasn’t yet been accepted. A spokesman with the Ohio Supreme Court said it generally takes two to four months for a decision on whether the court will hear the case after the appellee has filed a response.

“I am hopeful that the Supreme Court will accept review and eventually adopt the reasoning of the dissent set forth in the opinion issued by the Court of Appeals,” Probst told the News-Sun.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Winter to take a break?
Winter to take a break?

You have to admit, it seemed winter was going to get off to a brutal start when we received 3 to 6 inches of snow about 10 days before Christmas. Since then, we’ve had a couple of one to two inch snowfalls but nothing major. Over the weekend, we had to deal with some ice. But it seems this January has been known to cause a little “weather...
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump

Actress Nicole Kidman clarified her comments on President-elect Donald Trump and the 2016 election results after coming under fire for suggesting that the nation should unify behind the incoming president. “I just say, [Trump's] now elected, and we as a country need to support whoever’s the president because that’s what...
Trump slams 'Saturday Night Live' after press conference sketch
Trump slams 'Saturday Night Live' after press conference sketch

It's not the first time Trump has criticized "SNL." Last month, he called the show "unwatchable" and "biased," slamming Baldwin's portrayal of him. He also previously called the show "boring and unfunny" and "totally one-sided."
Scattered showers ahead tonight
Scattered showers ahead tonight

Patchy fog developed in spots overnight with drizzle possible during the early morning. Drivers may see a few slick spots, especially in the far northern Miami Valley where temperatures have been at or below freezing much of the night. Patchy fog and drizzle early Monday morning Rain chances increase Monday through Tuesday ...
Superbug resistant to all U.S. antibiotics kills Nevada woman
Superbug resistant to all U.S. antibiotics kills Nevada woman

The victim, who is unnamed, was in her 70s. She was initially hospitalized in August 2016 after returning from a trip to India. There, she had sought treatment for a broken hip several times in recent years, most recently in June 2016. Her most recent hospitalization, according to a postmortem CDC report, was in June 2016. The victim died of septic...
More Stories