You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

New Carlisle raises water rates

Officials projected deficit and other problems if ordinance failed.

Residents here will see their water rates increase for the first time since 2008, avoiding a worst-case scenario water fund deficit of about $98,750 at the end of next year and possible cuts to the department.

All but Councilman Ethan Reynolds were in favor of the increase that city officials say will initially help pay for leak detection and fixes on the city’s water mains, as well as increased maintenance of water infrastructure.

Residents will pay $6.78 per 1,000 gallons beginning in April through March 2014 and $7.28 from April 2014 to March 2015. The rate is currently $5.78.

Council approved the measure after a more than 45-minute discussion between council and staff — and a brief debate between Reynolds and Councilman Bill McIntire — over whether residents’ wallets or the city’s infrastructure would experience a greater loss as a result.

Reynolds said he felt an increase would harm the 33 percent who are on fixed incomes and the 15.5 percent of its population considered below poverty level. And he said a suggested plan of contracting out leak detection services, then possibly buying the same equipment, would be a waste of money.

“It kinda seems silly to pay for somebody to do it and then buy the same thing off of them later,” Reynolds said.

But City Service Director Howard Kitko and Finance Director Richard Sexton argued that the cost of doing nothing would be even higher.

The water department has hemorrhaged money the last several years through leaks, declining revenues and increases in the cost of doing business, they said.

“Over the last three years, we have been averaging a decrease in our revenues in our water fund of approximately $10,000 to $11,000 annually, or 1 to 1¼ percent annually, the last three years,” Sexton said. “At the same time, we’ve seen our expenses increase on average $30,000 per year. So, we’re actually losing about $40,000 a year.”

“We pump about 204 million (gallons) and bill for about 129 million (gallons each year),” Kitko said.

About 30 percent of water loss is to leaks and another 19 percent is through water services that aren’t metered, he said.

The cost to produce 1,000 gallons of water is $3.78.

Kitko said lessening revenues and increased costs have led the water department to do only about 50 percent of the proper upkeep to its aging wells, 7-year-old water treatment plant and its nearly 80-year-old water lines.

At the end of last year, council approved a $30,000 transfer to the water department fund from the city’s contingency fund to keep the water department out of the red, Sexton reminded council.

After leaks are found and fixed, the department would then be able to focus extra revenues on upkeep and maintenance of city wells and the water treatment plant, according to Kitko.

He said regular cleaning of a well costs about $18,000 to $20,000 every 5 years, according to the Ohio EPA, and that if one well goes down, the cost to drill a new one would cost between $140,000 to $180,000.

He was also concerned about the health of two wells, one that’s been high in iron and another that’s had a decrease in production.

Councilman Mike Lowrey asked what would happen if the city waited to pass a rate increase until after Tecumseh’s levy goes to voters.

“If my well breaks down, I don’t know what we’re going to do then,” Kitko responded.

More revenue would also allow for installation of automated meters that would be able to read remotely and help customers keep track of their water usage on an hourly basis, Kitko said. That would help customers pinpoint reasons for heavy water usage and detect leaks earlier rather than on the current 30-day cycle.

Those meters would also decrease the department’s man hours spent to read them by hand. It currently takes the three employees a week to read customers meters, he said.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Community News

Watch: Massive gator spotted at Florida reserve
Watch: Massive gator spotted at Florida reserve

The police department in Lakeland, Florida, posted a video to Facebook Monday morning showing a giant gator taking a stroll at a nature reserve.  As a group of people spot the gator, you can see the massive reptile crossing a grass pathway before it walks back into a bunch of bushes.  The Lakeland Police Department said in their Facebook...
Advocates: New law could improve blight, including in Springfield
Advocates: New law could improve blight, including in Springfield

Ohio has enacted the nation’s first statewide ban on mortgage lenders using plywood to board up vacant structures, which some local officials hope will help disguise and stop the spread of abandoned homes and blight. Plywood covers the doors and windows of thousands of empty structures across southwest Ohio — including in Springfield &mdash...
Politicians, celebs honor Martin Luther King Jr.
Politicians, celebs honor Martin Luther King Jr.

Civil rights activist Martin Luther King Jr. is celebrated each year on MLK Jr. Day and throughout February for Black History Month.  >> Read more trending stories   The Atlanta-born Baptist minister encouraged equality, desegregation and civil disobedience as a way to stand for change. Each year, Americans remember him and...
Winter to take a break?
Winter to take a break?

You have to admit, it seemed winter was going to get off to a brutal start when we received 3 to 6 inches of snow about 10 days before Christmas. Since then, we’ve had a couple of one to two inch snowfalls but nothing major. Over the weekend, we had to deal with some ice. But it seems this January has been known to cause a little “weather...
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump

Actress Nicole Kidman clarified her comments on President-elect Donald Trump and the 2016 election results after coming under fire for suggesting that the nation should unify behind the incoming president. “I just say, [Trump's] now elected, and we as a country need to support whoever’s the president because that’s what...
More Stories