Experts, Ohio lawmakers weigh in on options in Iraq


President Barack Obama faces a menu of difficult alternatives as his administration struggles to save Iraq’s government from a virulent Sunni insurgency, according to analysts and lawmakers.

Not only are large formations of the U.S.-trained Iraqi Army disintegrating under the onslaught of the Sunni militants of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, Congress and the American voters appear to have little appetite for backing the type of aggressive U.S. military action that might prevent Iraq from splintering into two or three separate entities.

Obama, who withdrew the last U.S. combat forces from Iraq in 2011, ruled out Friday “sending U.S. troops back into combat.” But Obama made clear that unless the Shiite-dominated Iraqi government of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki adopts a major reconciliation effort with Sunnis and Kurds, no U.S. military action will be successful.

“Before we have a knee-jerk decision to support the Iraqi government against terrorists, we need to demand it be a government worth supporting,” said retired Lt. Colonel Peter Mansoor, a professor of military science at Ohio State University and who served in 2007 and 2008 as the executive officer in Iraq to General David Petraeus.

“We should make it clear if the Iraqi government wants U.S. military assistance, it needs to be a government of a national unity, stop the persecution of Maliki’s political enemies and form a government all Iraqis can support — and that may mean Maliki will no longer be the prime minister,” said Mansoor, author of the book, “Surge – My Journey with General David Petraeus and the Re-Making of the Iraq War.”

Loren Thompson, chief operating officer of the defense think-tank Lexington Institute in Washington, said “the basic problem in Iraq can’t be solved by U.S. air power and not even by boots on the ground. There is a divide in Iraq between the Sunnis in the North and the Shiaa in the south and the bottom line probably is this place probably shouldn’t be a country. It should be two countries.”

But if the United States fails to back the Iraqi government, large swaths of northern Iraq and Syria will fall under the control the ISIS, a fundamentalist group whose violence is unmatched in the Middle East. Analysts fear that areas dominated by the ISIS would literally become training havens for terrorists, who might launch attacks in Europe and perhaps the United States.

“I hate to see us do nothing,” said Richard Herrmann, a professor of political science at Ohio State and a State Department official under former President George H.W. Bush. “We don’t have a lot of options. I don’t think the president and others could mobilize enough domestic support to send in forces.”

Rep. Brad Wenstrup, R-Cincinnati, a surgeon at Abu Ghraib prison from 2005 to 2006, said ISIS is “so violent, so horrible even al-Qaida keeps their distance from them.”

Even among Republican critics of Obama there seemed little interest in dispatching U.S. forces to Iraq. Columbus-area Rep. Steve Stivers, R-Upper Arlington, said “we should give them some air cover as they fight a force that could really destabilize the country and more importantly destabilize the worldwide energy markets.”

House Speaker John Boehner, R-West Chester Twp., said “it’s long past time for the president to lay out a plan for how we can reverse the momentum and spread of terrorism in Iraq,” but did not say what plan he might support.

Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, said Americans cannot “afford to turn our backs on this problem, and I do not think it is wise to be taking options off the table at this point.” But he assailed the Obama administration for failing to adopt a strategy to save Iraq and the Middle East.

“Saying you ‘ended the Iraq war’ or the White House’s latest, ‘don’t do stupid stuff’ are not strategies,” Portman said.

Democrats appeared no more eager for a new fight in Iraq. Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, who as a House member in 2002 voted against using force in Iraq, said that “instead of committing American troops, we should work with the international community – and the Iraqi government – to help it resolve this situation.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Woman used dating site to bilk man out of $300,000, police say
Woman used dating site to bilk man out of $300,000, police say

A Florida man was looking for companionship, but now he’s a lot lighter in the wallet after being tricked out of $300,000, police said.  An 85-year-old Pembroke Pines man started dating Nancy Guy, 45, after meeting her on a dating site. Guy claimed to be a dress maker who needed money, according to the Miami Herald.  Guy promised...
Linkin Park's Chester Bennington died on late rocker friend Chris Cornell's birthday
Linkin Park's Chester Bennington died on late rocker friend Chris Cornell's birthday

After the death of rocker Chris Cornell was announced in May, Chester Bennington was one of the many high profile names that paid tribute to the Soundgarden singer. >> Read more trending news Bennington, best known as the lead singer of the band Linkin Park, died by suicide this week. He was found hanging in a private residence in California...
Report: Ryan Seacrest to make more than $10 million for 'American Idol' return
Report: Ryan Seacrest to make more than $10 million for 'American Idol' return

Ryan Seacrest announced Thursday that he will return as the host of the upcoming “American Idol” reboot on ABC. >> Read more trending news “It’s genuinely hard to put into words what ‘American Idol’ means to me,” Seacrest said in a statement of the news. “I’m so grateful for the show...
Veteran allowed to keep ducks that help with PTSD
Veteran allowed to keep ducks that help with PTSD

A veteran suffering from PTSD will be allowed to keep his ducks, which he said are therapeutic to him. Darin Welker was convicted in 2014 of a misdemeanor for violating a town ban on owning farm animals, according to the Coshocton Tribune. A state appeals court upheld his conviction, and the Ohio Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal. However...
Camp keeps Springfield kids learning to stop summer slide
Camp keeps Springfield kids learning to stop summer slide

Learning didn’t stop this summer for 72 Lincoln Elementary School students. The Bobcat Summer Adventure Camp, a six-week enrichment program for kindergarten through sixth grade sponsored by the Springfield Promise Neighborhood, supplemented what the students learned in summer school with reading and writing activities with themes on the natural...
More Stories