You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

EPA to test hazardous barrel site

Residents concerned by sampling, unsure what it means for site with 1.5M gallons of hazardous waste.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency will conduct tests at a Tremont City site containing buried barrels filled with 1.5 million gallons of hazardous waste.

The U.S. EPA Region 5 office will sample surface water, soil and sediment in and around the Tremont City Barrel Fill Superfund Alternative Site this month.

The decision has a local water protection group worried the site’s status could change after local officials and health groups have fought for decades to have it cleaned up.

People for Safe Water, a new group determined to fight the U.S. EPA’s plans to remediate the barrel fill, began meeting last May after a previous group, Citizens for Wise Action Toward Environmental Resources, known as CF/WATER, decided to disband.

“We can’t figure out what this sampling means and this delay,” said Marilyn Welker, the group’s president.

The U.S. EPA didn’t return multiple phone calls from the Springfield News-Sun seeking comment.

According to an e-mail obtained by the News-Sun, Region 5 told the group’s members they are “sampling to evaluate current conditions” at the site and may use the data “to assess” whether the site will be considered for the National Priorities List, which is commonly referred to as the Superfund program.

The U.S. EPA’s website describes the NPL as “a list of national priorities among the known releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances, pollutants, or contaminants throughout the United States and its territories.” The list guides the EPA in determining which sites warrant further investigation.

Clark County Health Commissioner Charles Patterson is also unclear on what the new testing means for the site, but knows the battle must continue to preserve water for future generations.

“We’re trying to prevent a problem 50 to 100 years from now,” Patterson said.

Area politicians and health leaders have been fighting for years to have the barrel fill —an 8.5-acre section of a closed landfill for industrial waste barrels that sits near the area’s drinking water aquifer — remediated.

Last June, the U.S. EPA announced it was preparing a negotiation package for the U.S. Department of Justice, which serves as the representative for potentially responsible parties that might have contributed to the barrel fill. The U.S. EPA will send notice to potentially responsible parties on the cleanup plans and why it believes they’re liable.

According to most recent update to the U.S. EPA’s barrel fill website, the negotiating process is still ongoing.

People for Safe Water and community leaders believe that if left in its current state, the site could be a hazard to public health. Rainwater draining through the unlined barrel fill and containment pools could eventually contaminate the area’s sole source aquifer, which serves 85,000 customers in Clark and Montgomery counties, according to U.S. EPA reports.

In September 2011, the U.S. EPA released its plan to dig up the barrels and then rebury them on site in a lined landfill, rather than removing all of the waste as recommended by the Ohio EPA and civic leaders.

The U.S. EPA plan’s estimated cost is $28 million; the estimated cost of the more extensive clean-up plan, Alternative 4a, is $56 million.

Local leaders and environmental groups have been fighting to have the more extensive plan restored.

“The plan has been proposed, it was acceptable,” Welker said. “We want that plan.”

Welker said EPA officials told her in an e-mail that the upcoming sampling is part of the initial Hazardous Ranking System scoring for the site, but it wouldn’t release the rankings of sites being assessed for proposal as a Superfund site.

“Our first thought was, OK, more delays, which is OK,” Welker said. “But the second one is ‘What’s going on behind the scenes that they won’t tell us. Who’s challenging this plan?’ … Our concern is that the sampling that is to be done this month still does not reach into the (sand and gravel or carbonate) aquifer. It’s still a superficial sampling.”

Extremely low levels of contaminants have been found in aquifers underneath the site, according to U.S. EPA records, but can’t be traced back to the barrels and aren’t considered harmful to public health. Safe Water members, however, believe the barrels are dangerous to the aquifers underneath the site.

The group has asked for letters of support from both Speaker of the House John Boehner and U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown. Ohio Rep. Bob Hackett and Ohio Sen. Chris Widener both have said they’d sign a letter of support.

They also plan to send questions to the U.S. EPA in Washington, D.C.

“We need to shake the tree higher up,” Welker said.

Area political and health leaders delivered a letter to President Barack Obama’s aides during his stop here Nov. 2 in an attempt to reverse the decision on how to clean up the site. It states area leaders are concerned about the “lack of due process in the ongoing Superfund proceedings” and implores the president’s help and guidance.

They are still waiting for a response, and plan to meet to discuss the next steps this week. The environmental group also plans to attend Springfield City Commission meetings, beginning today.

“We want to support the city and raise the importance of this issue,” Welker said.

CF/WATER, which at one time had as many as 500 members, helped stop the construction of another landfill in the same area in 1999, raising $800,000 for the cause.

However Chairman Jeff Briner said membership has waned in recent years, and they plan to disband the group later this year.

Briner said he’s “disgusted” with the clean up process.

“It was settled in 2010,” Briner said. “They need to finish it and do what needs to be done.”

Patterson credited CF/WATER for its efforts, and said it’s important another group like PFSW to continue the fight.

“Citizens groups carry a lot of weight (with the U.S. EPA),” Patterson said.

Anyone interested in joining People for Safe Water can e-mail

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Community News

Unseasonable warm weekend, rain chances increasing
Unseasonable warm weekend, rain chances increasing

Some patchy fog in spots early Saturday morning Highs near 60 degrees this weekend Rain chances increase Sunday into Monday The end to spring-like temperatures mid-week TODAY: Patchy fog early with temperatures falling into the 40s. Mostly cloudy skies with peaks of sunshine. Breezy and mild. Highs near 60 degrees. TONIGHT: Chance of passing showers...
4 more rescued from snowed-in Italian hotel
4 more rescued from snowed-in Italian hotel

The two men and two women were freed from the Hotel Rigopiano overnight after hours of digging by firemen, who were having to move cautiously for fear the buried air pockets might collapse. Cari said that rescue teams would continue to work night and day until everyone was accounted for.
George W. Bush struggles with poncho
George W. Bush struggles with poncho

However, the event at the U.S. Capitol on Friday did have some levity, as former President George W. Bush struggled with a poncho as rain began to fall during Trump’s inaugural speech.
Florida art exhibit features Trump punching bag
Florida art exhibit features Trump punching bag

If you’re frustrated by the ascension Friday of Donald Trump as the 45th President of the United States, ArtPalmBeach has the answer for you: A Trump punching bag. The red bag, with a scowling Trump face, is part of the exhibit “Left To Right,” by Cuban-born multimedia artist Antuan Rodriguez. Trump’s face is one of...
Thousands descend on nation’s capital for Women’s March
Thousands descend on nation’s capital for Women’s March

 A day after Donald Trump was sworn in as the nation’s 45th president, hundreds of thousands of people are descending upon Washington, D.C., to participate in Saturday’s Women’s March. The march — which will begin with a rally at 10 a.m. featuring speakers and musical acts — is based on a mission that the rhetoric...
More Stories