Drone warfare target of Witt talk

Panelists oppose Springfield base’s mission, commercialization efforts.


A recent think-tank report authored by an Air Force colonel to address the military’s projected shortage of drone pilots suggests that recruiting efforts should emphasize that “this weapon system is achieving more strategic level effects in the fight against terrorism than any manned aircraft.”

That, panelists at Wittenberg University argued Wednesday, is a myth.

“Drones have not been able to reduce the capacity of these terrorist groups at all,” said Rafia Zakaria, the first Pakistani-American woman to serve as a director for Amnesty International USA.

As part of a panel discussion at Wittenberg about the effectiveness of drone warfare — or, in this case, the alleged lack thereof — Zakaria painted a bleak picture of how her native Pakistan has been torn asunder by America’s undeclared war against militants there using drones, or what the Pentagon calls remotely piloted aircraft.

The CIA is believed to be the sole operator of U.S. drones in Pakistan, with the Pentagon now tasked with carrying out missions elsewhere, in places such as Afghanistan, Yemen and North Africa.

The Springfield-based 178th Fighter Wing of the Ohio Air National Guard is right in the thick of it, flying Predator drones abroad from inside a building at the local Air Guard base.

Despite the federal government shutdown that has furloughed hundreds of Springfield Guardsmen this week, the Predator mission continues 24 hours a day.

Zakaria, who’s also a lawyer and a doctoral candidate at Indiana University, focused her argument Wednesday mostly on her homeland and what she deemed “the myth of precision.”

It’s been well-argued that drone strikes also claim civilian lives.

“The U.S. says there are no civilian casualties because they define combatants as everyone within a target zone,” she said.

Panelist Steve Fryburg, a member of the group Veterans for Peace and a former police officer, brought the issue back home.

“We’ve created a combat zone right here in Springfield,” he said, referencing the Predator mission at the Springfield base. “If we’re pulling the trigger on Pakistan and Afghanistan right here from Springfield, what’s the difference if they pull the trigger on us? They’ve made us enemy combatants.

“You can’t kill life like that without ramifications.”

Zakaria presented statistics showing that since the start of President Obama’s drone war in 2009, terrorist attacks have spread from an isolated region in northwest Pakistan to the entire country.

For the 53 U.S. drone strikes in 2009, there were 500 terrorist attacks in Pakistan, she said. Two years later, in 2011, there were 673 terrorist attacks, followed by 632 attacks in 2012.

“It has severely traumatized the country,” Zakaria said.

Furthermore, drone strikes have sent people scurrying out of remote locations of the country, she said, heightening ethnic conflict.

“For what is a remote war in the U.S. is a very real and palpable war for millions of people in Pakistan,” she said.

Fryburg — who also took aim at efforts by the Dayton-Springfield region to become a hub of commercial drone technology, saying it won’t create near the number of jobs touted by politicians — batted down claims by the military that drones make U.S. troops safer.

“How is this supposed to keep our soldiers safer if all we’re doing is creating more enemies for our troops to fight against?” he asked. “It’s making us one of the most hated countries in the world.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Numbers have been drawn for 2nd-largest jackpot in Powerball history
Numbers have been drawn for 2nd-largest jackpot in Powerball history

The Powerball jackpot for Wednesday’s drawing was an estimated $700 million, the second-largest jackpot in Powerball history! The winning numbers are 6, 7, 16, 23 and 26, and the Powerball number is 4. The jackpot began rolling June 14 and has rolled 20 times. Although there were no jackpot winners in Saturday’s Powerball drawing...
COMMENTARY: Some ways to strengthen our democracy

Many observers believe our democracy is in trouble. This is supported by polls showing a large majority of Americans think the country is “headed in the wrong direction,” and only 26 percent believe the national government is making effective progress. Scholars of democracy warn of what they call “democratic deconsolidation&rdquo...
Tattoo parlor offers to remove gang and hate-related tattoos at no charge
Tattoo parlor offers to remove gang and hate-related tattoos at no charge

The Parlour Hair and Ink in Sand Springs, Oklahoma, is hosting an event to cover up any gang or hate-related tattoos for free. Store owner Jamy Magee said individual political beliefs don't matter to them and they will help anyone with their heart in the right place. "I think this is a great way to move forward. We can help cover up the past and...
15-month-old girl found dead in hot car in Ohio, parents being interviewed by police
15-month-old girl found dead in hot car in Ohio, parents being interviewed by police

An autopsy is planned Thursday for a 15-month-old girl found dead in the back seat of her mother's car, which was in the employee parking lot of the Procter & Gamble Mason Business Center in Mason, Ohio.  “She was left unattended in the car by an employee who worked there,” Doyle Burke, Warren County Coroner’s Office investigator...
Brazen liquor thief caught on camera
Brazen liquor thief caught on camera

Police are looking for a suspect who stole at least nine bottles of liquor Friday from a Thrifty Liquor in Shreveport, Louisiana. An unidentified woman can be seen on surveillance video hiding bottles in her purse and under her clothes. "She's just loading liquor up like she's stockpiling this liquor. I think she paid for one bottle of liquor...
More Stories