You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

County debates next step for 911 tower

Urbana board rejects request, cites too many variances and too little information.


Some local officials are questioning a recent decision by Urbana’s Board of Zoning Appeals to reject a proposed 911 tower that would be placed on the city municipal building, saying the decision could kill the project.

But at least one member of the zoning board countered that the proposal, while potentially beneficial, was poorly presented and contained too few details. Last week, members of the BZA voted against waiving five variances that would have been necessary to allow a 70-foot tall wireless telecommunications tower to be placed on the city’s municipal building. Those variances included the proximity of the tower to residences and roads, the height of the tower above the roof, and the design of the tower.

If it had been approved, the tower would have allowed the creation of a backup 911 center in the municipal building, said Craig Evans, director of the Champaign County Emergency Management Agency. Currently, the city and county use a joint 911 center at the county office complex on U.S. 68 to handle emergency calls and dispatch first responders. But if an emergency such as a tornado or fire would damage that center, the county does not have a backup in place and would likely have to route emergency calls through another county, risking dropped calls or delays, Evans said.

“Not a single person showed up to object to putting it on the building,” Evans said of the tower.

Evans said the project had been developed with the help of local first responders, and Urbana’s administration had signed off on the agreement. It would be paid for with an $18,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. But moving the project to another site would make it unaffordable.

“They’re effectively killing it if we need to move it,” Evans said.

But some members of the BZA argued they did not have enough information.

“I think we were all looking for reasons to grant the variances,” said Tom Gates, a member of the BZA. “I just think they took our approval for granted and didn’t do their due diligence.”

Gates said the BZA has never allowed that many variances for a project in the past. But he also said proposed drawings of how the tower might look were inaccurate, and some engineering details were missing.

Other BZA members raised other issues with the proposal as well. There were concerns that if the project proved more costly than expected, the city may not have enough in the budget to pick up the rest, said Marty Hess, a member of the BZA. He said some questions about the cost of the project were not adequately answered.

“We want the best bang for our buck because bucks are hard to come by,” Hess said.

County and city officials have tried to devise a plan for a backup tower for two years, said Mark Keller, chief of the Urbana Fire Division. He pointed out that a full engineering study was not completed only because it was determined it would be too costly to pay for a full study, which still could have been turned down by the BZA.

Keller said the backup tower is needed because in recent years, there has been a bomb threat and a smoke scare at the county’s current facility.

“If that dispatch center would be destroyed, basically the 911 system is down,” Keller said.

City administrators supported the proposal, said Kerry Brugger, director of administration for Urbana. But he said if the BZA is not satisfied, other options would include seeking another location, drafting a new application or appealing the issue in court.

It’s not an option to let the issue die, Evans said. A group of county and city officials are trying to determine whether it makes more sense to appeal the decision to the Champaign County Common Pleas Court or create a new application to the BZA.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

‘I thought it would be easier’: What they are saying about President Trump’s comment
‘I thought it would be easier’: What they are saying about President Trump’s comment

President Donald Trump told reporters on the eve of his 100th day in office that the job of leader of the free world is harder than he imagined it would be. Trump, speaking to reporters from Reuters and The Washington Post said he misses the things he could do before becoming president, like driving himself and having private time. “I love my...
ODNR grants extension to comment on Clark County gravel pit request
ODNR grants extension to comment on Clark County gravel pit request

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources is giving citizens another month to comment on Enon Sand and Gravel pit plans to expand its mining operation. “Due to public interest, the date for public comments to be accepted was changed from April 21 to Monday, May 22, according to ODNR. Enon Sand and Gravel wants to mine about 60 feet deeper on parts...
Clark County health commissioner: Get screened — and save your life
Clark County health commissioner: Get screened — and save your life

I saved my life today. Well, not all by myself. I had help from many people. Dr. Alan Gabbard, his staff, and the helpful staff at the Springfield Regional Outpatient Center made my thoughts into reality. Let me start at the beginning. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends: “Regular screening, beginning at age 50, is the key...
Clark County: Beyond the first 100 days
Clark County: Beyond the first 100 days

It’s hard to believe that Commissioners Richard L. Lohnes, Lowell R. McGlothin and I have been serving together as Clark County Commissioners for 100 days. It can be easy to get caught up in the day-to-day management, such as contracts, copies and budget approvals, but — while we have to assure those things are done responsibly —...
Clark County Municipal Court cases
Clark County Municipal Court cases

CASES CALLED WEDNESDAY INCLUDED: Lakesha L. Bradford, 35, of 1901 Michigan Ave., wrongful entrustment, guilty, six months driver’s license suspension, fined $100. Shawnda Lee Cochran, 27, of 1126 Rodgers Dr., assault, dismissed. Leonard Crank, 23, of New Carlisle, OVI amended to physical control, guilty, 180 days jail with 170 days suspended...
More Stories