breaking news

Police: Urbana man beat cat nearly to death, claimed it was a raccoon

Privacy concerns raised as UAVs become more common


Fears of unmanned aerial vehicles equipped with electronic sensors and cameras intruding on personal privacy created turbulence that led the Federal Aviation Administration to postpone plans to test drones in civilian airspace until Congress stepped in and reversed the agency’s course.

But a growing number of states and communities across the nation have introduced legislation to tackle the issue of privacy and UAVs. At least four states have enacted laws and lawmakers in 30 or so have submitted bills for consideration. Some areas require law enforcement agencies to have a warrant to fly a UAV for surveillance.

“The technology is getting to the point where they will be able to conduct surveillance for much longer periods of times at very efficient and cheap cost,” said Amie Stepanovich, a lawyer with the Electronic Privacy Information Center in Washington, D.C. “We see drones representing a very unique threat to privacy.”

Advocates for unmanned flight say while privacy should be addressed, the message that UAVs will be the next revolution in flight capable of a wide swath of useful technology in weather forecasting to cargo hauling to search and rescue missions has been lost.

The Association of Unmanned Vehicle Systems International believes UAVs “should be treated like any other system that can take a picture or collect data,” said Ben Gielow, an AUVSI lawyer and government relations manager in Washington, D.C.

“The issue shouldn’t be about the vehicle,” he said. “The issue should be about the data collection.”

Nick Worner, an American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio spokesman, said rules must be in place before drones take flight in civilian air space.

“The chief concern with drones, because of the newness of the technology, is that there are appropriate guidelines and protections in place when these technologies hit the skies,” he said.

In April, the city of Dayton dumped plans to use a manned aircraft for police surveillance after a public outcry despite city leaders creating policies to limit how the technology would be used.

In the midst of the latest debate, states driven by the promise of a future industry bringing jobs and high-tech growth have forged ahead in a fierce contest to land one of six FAA-designated UAV test sites by the end of the year. Ohio and Indiana submitted a joint proposal to the FAA.

Concerned with the public view and media coverage of UAVs, the Aerospace Industries Association released a report late last week hoping to change the way drones are perceived by many familiar with military uses of flying unmanned vehicles, such as finding and killing terrorism suspects.

The Hollywood idea of drones as “hunter-killers,” which influences public perceptions, gives a negative picture of UAVs, an aerospace industry spokesman said.

“That’s not really what unmanned systems are all about,” said Dan Stohr, an AIA spokesman. “There’s a great deal of untapped potential.”

But proponents may have a long way to go to persuade some. Google executive chairman Eric Schmidt has gone on record saying private drones pose a privacy threat, according to NBC News.

UAV proponents say people are under surveillance every day. We walk or drive within range of cameras in stores and restaurants, or workplaces, on street corners, when they withdraw money from ATM machines, or when they are near someone with a smart phone with a video recorder.

“While we are here on the ground, we are imaged so many multiple times a day, I think privacy concerns should be lodged in that direction as well,” said Rick Scudder, director of the Center for UAS Exploitation at the University of Dayton Research Institute.

Most UAVs in commercial use won’t be flying to gather personal data on someone, said Donald L. Smith, owner of UAV maker UA Vision in Dayton, who said privacy needs to be addressed, but concerns have been “overblown.”

“If you’re spending $500 to $1,000 an hour to do your jobs, whatever that may be, then your interest in looking at other things is going to be minimal,” he said.

He said legislation in one state to criminalize possession of a UAV with a camera was shortsighted.

“That kind of mindset is kind of scary,” he said. “I think there’s a middle ground somewhere between outlawing them entirely and laissez faire.

“The salient point is not to restrict the gathering of the data,” he said. “It’s to restrict the storage and dissemination of the data.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Military

Trump to reinstate military ban on transgender people
Trump to reinstate military ban on transgender people

President Donald Trump said Wednesday he wants transgender people barred from serving in the U.S. military “in any capacity,” citing “tremendous medical costs and disruption.” Trump’s announcement on Twitter would reverse the effort under President Barack Obama to open the armed services to transgender people. He did not...
69 years ago today, Truman ordered 'right and just' desegregation of US armed forces
69 years ago today, Truman ordered 'right and just' desegregation of US armed forces

Sixty-nine years ago on July 26, 1948, President Harry Truman issued an executive order abolishing racial discrimination in the United States armed forces. “It is hereby declared to be the policy of the President that there shall be equality of treatment and opportunity for all persons in the armed services without regard to race, color...
Report: Transgender health care would cost fraction of what military spends on Viagra, similar drugs
Report: Transgender health care would cost fraction of what military spends on Viagra, similar drugs

President Donald Trump said Wednesday that “tremendous medical costs” were partially behind his decision to bar transgender Americans from serving in the military. However, a report from The Washington Post showed that estimates for the cost of caring for transgender service members amount to just a fraction of what the military currently...
Memphis Belle gets its guns seven decades after WWII
Memphis Belle gets its guns seven decades after WWII

Piece by piece, Air Force restorers are assembling the B-17F Memphis Belle decades since the plane dodged flak and Nazi fighter planes over the skies of Germany and France in World War II. The bomber got a double-barrelled addition Wednesday when a tail gunner’s turret with two machine guns was bolted back onto the end of the iconic plane in...
Navy sailor found hiding on ship after week-long disappearance could face discharge
Navy sailor found hiding on ship after week-long disappearance could face discharge

A sailor whose disappearance from a U.S. Navy vessel last month launched a days-long search amid fears he had fallen overboard could face discharge after he was found hiding in the ship’s engine room, according to multiple reports. Gas Turbine Systems Technician (Mechanical) 3rd Class Peter Mims, 23, appeared to have vanished June 8 from the...
More Stories