You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Springfield loses red light camera lawsuit appeal

City of Springfield likely to appeal to Ohio Supreme Court.


The city of Springfield lost its appeal challenging new state restrictions on the use of red light cameras, but it will likely ask the Ohio Supreme Court to hear its case later this year.

Springfield Law Director Jerry Strozdas said he will probably file an appeal within the next week.

State lawmakers approved regulations last year that require a police officer to be present at an intersection with the automated cameras in order to issue traffic tickets.

Springfield filed a lawsuit against the state last year challenging those restrictions, arguing it’s unconstitutional because it violates its ability to enforce local traffic laws. A Clark County judge disagreed last August and upheld the state law. The city appealed that decision.

The Second District Court of Appeals in Dayton also upheld that law late last week.

“The Ohio constitution clearly gives cities the right to make these kinds of decisions,” Strozdas said. “I regret I wasn’t able to persuade the Court of Appeals of that.”

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office was pleased the court agreed with their argument, Spokesman Dan Tierney said.

“We have a duty to defend the laws that are passed by the legislature and signed by the governor,” Tierney said. “They’re presumed to be constitutional until a court rules otherwise. It’s our duty as an office to defend the constitutionality of laws that are challenged in court.”

The court handled the case quickly, Strozdas said, allowing Springfield to be considered for the Ohio Supreme Court’s docket this year.

The city of Springfield could ask to join its appeal with a similar case from the city of Dayton, which the Ohio Supreme Court recently agreed to hear.

“We may ask to join in that appeal, consolidating them, essentially,” Strozdas said.

Akron and Toledo have filed similar appeals at their regional district court of appeals but have yet to receive a ruling.

Springfield suspended its red light camera program a year ago after the new law went into effect. The city has issued about 77,000 citations since the program started. It has 17 cameras at 10 intersections.

Springfield has collected about $3.4 million in fines from red light cameras since they were installed in 2006. It stands to lose about $250,000 annually if the cameras are shelved for good but city leaders have long argued the automated ticket program is about safety, not money.

In 2007, 90 crashes occurred at the intersections with red light cameras. In 2014, that number fell to 44 crashes, a 51 percent reduction.

Red light cameras have had a “measurable, significant impact in improving traffic” in Springfield, Strozdas said.

“I’m sure other cities saw the same effects,” he said.

The lawsuit is worth pursuing to the supreme court, Springfield Mayor Warren Copeland said, not because of the cameras themselves, but because of the principle.

“We have a right to decide how we’re going to police our community, unless we do something illegal,” Copeland said. “They’re trying to decide how we get to do our police work. I think it’s wrong.”

Later this month, the city commission will vote whether to renew its five-year contract with its photo enforcement provider, RedFlex Traffic Systems. The Arizona-based company has served in that role since 2006.

Last year a former RedFlex chief executive officer pleaded guilty to participating in an eight-year bribery and fraud scheme in Columbus and Cincinnati. The case didn’t included any mention of links to Springfield and city leaders here denied receiving bribes.

If approved, the city won’t be able to search for another photo enforcement provider until after the RedFlex contract expires, City Manager Jim Bodenmiller said. However, the city won’t reinstate its red light camera program until its current court case is finalized, he said.

“It just continues our current agreement from the last five-year renewal period,” he said. “It will only come into play if, in fact, we reinstate the program.”

The red-light program isn’t fair and is an invasion of privacy, Springfield resident Cheryl Cox said. She once got a ticket on Troy Road.

“All it is is government wanting more money … Every time it’s something different to pull more money out of people’s pockets,” Cox said. “And it’s hard right now because of the job situation and people living on fixed incomes.”

Springfield resident Ronnie Moss sees it differently. He was recently hit while riding his bicycle by a man who ran a red light on Limestone Street, he said. Moss was injured but thankful to have survived.

“I could’ve gotten killed,” he said.

If the red light cameras were functional, Moss said it may have kept the man from speeding through the intersection.

“When that light’s yellow, he’s going to stop,” Moss said. “There are lives that are saved by that camera.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Springfield asks voters for tax increase to fix roads, fight drugs
Springfield asks voters for tax increase to fix roads, fight drugs

Springfield city leaders want to increase local income taxes to maintain services, fix roads and hire more police officers, but opponents believe it will make the city less attractive for prospective residents and businesses. Residents will vote May 2 whether to raise the city’s income tax for 5½ years from 2 percent to 2.4 percent. &ldquo...
Springfield won’t follow Dayton, plans to keep red light cameras off
Springfield won’t follow Dayton, plans to keep red light cameras off

The city of Springfield won’t be resuming its red light camera program any time soon, despite Dayton’s proposal to turn its red-light and speed-detection cameras back on later this month to improve safety at intersections. Springfield leaders have said they won’t turn the city’s cameras back on until the issue is settled statewide...
Jon Husted takes steps toward run for Ohio governor
Jon Husted takes steps toward run for Ohio governor

Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted’s as-yet-unannounced bid for governor moved forward today with the announcement that his office’s press secretary would join the Husted for Ohio campaign. Josh Eck said his last day in the office was today and he will become a spokesman for the campaign. “I have been a fan of Jon Husted’s since...
Supreme Court orders refunds for people whose criminal convictions are overturned
Supreme Court orders refunds for people whose criminal convictions are overturned

People who are freed from prison when their convictions are reversed deserve a refund of what they paid in fees, court costs and restitution, the Supreme Court ruled Wednesday.  "They are entitled to be presumed innocent" once their convictions are thrown out, said Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and the state "has zero claim"...
Turner, state lawmakers upset state declined money for Wright-Patt
Turner, state lawmakers upset state declined money for Wright-Patt

Area lawmakers are upset Wright-Patterson Air Force Base was shut out of a share of $5 million in state aid vowed changes Thursday to a state panel that decided to split the money for projects at two Ohio Air National Guard bases. U.S. Rep. Mike Turner and state Reps. Niraj Antani and Rick Perales spoke at a Thursday press conference about their frustrations...
More Stories