Judge dismisses lawsuit against Penn National


A judge in Columbus has dismissed a lawsuit that sought to prevent Penn National Gaming from relocating live horse racing to Dayton from Toledo.

The former owners of Lebanon Raceway filed an administrative appeal against the Ohio State Racing Commission for permitting Penn National to transfer its horse racing license from Raceway Park in Toledo to the new Hollywood Gaming at Dayton Raceway.

The former owners argued the transfer violated a law prohibiting the commission from allowing racing programs to take place at the same time at any two tracks located within 50 miles of each another.

But Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Colleen O’Donnell ruled the litigants have no standing to appeal the commission’s decision. She dismissed the lawsuit for lack of jurisdiction.

Dennis Concilla, an attorney representing the former owners, said there are other legal avenues his clients could pursue, but it is unclear whether they will take further action.

“We need to sit down, talk to our clients and see how they want to proceed,” he said.

Penn National, which was a co-defendant in the case, praised the court’s ruling.

“We have no way of knowing whether or not Lebanon will appeal, but if it does, we will continue to make what we believe is a very strong legal case,” said spokesman Bob Tenenbaum.

In 2012, the former owners of Lebanon Raceway — Lebanon Trotting Club and Miami Valley Trotting Inc. — sold their horse track and racing permits to Miami Valley Gaming, which relocated the track and operations to Turtlecreek Twp.

The same year, Penn National filed an application to relocate its track to Dayton from Toledo. The Dayton racino, which plans to open next month, is about 26 miles from the Warren County track.

In May 2013, the former owners filed an appeal challenging the legality of the racing commission’s decision allowing for the relocation to Dayton.

The group said the transfer cost them about $10 million, because that amount of their $70 million purchase agreement with Miami Valley Gaming was contingent upon no track relocating within the restricted geography for five years.

But Judge O’Donnell ruled the trotting groups were not a party to the commission’s action and had no legal right to appeal. O’Donnell noted in her ruling the relocation to Dayton hinges upon the facility complying with the rules forbidding racing programs taking place at the same time.

The racing commission has made it clear it will not authorize overlapping racing dates for Miami Valley Gaming, Scioto Downs in Columbus and Hollywood Dayton Raceway, a Penn National spokesman said.

Harness racing at Dayton Raceway is scheduled to begin Oct. 3.

The three tracks are in discussions to coordinate race dates to create a racing circuit for 2015 prior to applying for next year’s racing dates with the commission, officials said.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Hundreds flock to Springfield vigil to stand against hate, racism
Hundreds flock to Springfield vigil to stand against hate, racism

More than 250 people attended a vigil in downtown Springfield in light of recent events in Charlottesville, Virginia, that saw three people die amid violent protests. RELATED: Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence Several local leaders from different backgrounds spoke out about the hatred seen during the protest — and stressed...
Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence
Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence

Springfield Mayor Warren Copeland spoke out about the violence in Charlottesville, Va., last weekend and also said the city will enforce its anti-discrimination ordinance if similar actions were to occur here. A Unite the Right rally was held Saturday morning in the Virginia city where a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee has long been a point...
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts

An initiative petition filed with the Clark County Board of Elections could potentially devastate New Carlisle’s finances, city leaders say, but the woman behind it says residents shouldn’t have to pay income taxes twice. Residents can be taxed both by the city where they work and, if it’s a different, where they live. Many cities...
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post

Rodney Parker and Liberty Beach, a country band from Sylvania, was booted from Northwest Ohio Rib Off and an opening slot for Nashville star Lee Brice after complaints over a Facebook post. Singer Rodney Parker, on his personal Facebook page, posted Tuesday about the Charlottesville, Va., protests. The Toledo Blade, which sponsors the Rib Off...
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare

A Park Layne mom said she won’t bring her kids to Raynor Park because she believes its unsafe but Bethel Twp. trustees said they rarely get complaints about it. Raynor Park off Fyffe Drive is a popular spot, said Bethel Twp. Trustee Nancy Brown, especially during the fall for sports such as soccer and football. “It’s clean, it&rsquo...
More Stories