Judge rules in favor of former Greene County worker

Woman challenged layoff decision.


A Franklin County Common Pleas Court judge recently affirmed an Ohio State Personnel Board of Review decision that a former Greene County Children Services employee who was laid off should have been allowed to displace another worker.

The county judge’s ruling upheld an Oct. 9 decision by the three-member state board, which unanimously ordered Greene County commissioners to allow Victoria Phillips, a former executive secretary, to bump a county worker from a secretarial position and take that individual’s job.

“If this is the answer, I’m glad it’s working out for her,” said Greene County Commissioner Tom Koogler.

County commissioners have 30 days to file an appeal with the Ohio Court of Appeals. Koogler said he did not know if commissioners would do so.

Phillips, 57, a children services executive secretary at the time, received a letter dated Dec. 2, 2012 signed by two county commissioners indicating her job would be eliminated a month later as a result of the agency’s merger with the county jobs and family services department. The letter said she had no displacement rights — the ability to take over a similar position held by someone with less seniority.

In his written decision, Judge Richard Sheward found evidence contrary to the county’s claim that Phillips held the only executive secretary position that existed in the county and no similar position existed for her to move into.

Sheward’s decision is the most recent ruling in Phillips’ favor. In August, an Ohio State Personnel Board of Review administrative judge determined the county should have allowed Phillips to displace, or bump, into another job. County commissioners appealed the decision with the state board, which upheld the administrative law judge’s decision.

“I think justice is prevailing in all of these instances,” Phillips said. “I’m very happy with the judgments so far.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Confederate monument in Hollywood Forever Cemetery in Los Angeles removed
Confederate monument in Hollywood Forever Cemetery in Los Angeles removed

The Long Beach chapter of the United Daughters of the Confederacy has removed a monument to the Confederacy at Hollywood Forever Cemetery. KABC reported that many were unaware that the Confederate memorial was in the cemetery. It was installed in 1925. “The Daughters said we are a benevolent organization. We didn’t seek this attention....
2 Antioch students witness car attack in Charlottesville
2 Antioch students witness car attack in Charlottesville

Two Antioch College students in Charlottesville said they never will forget what they saw when protests turned deadly. “People were running in every direction. It was like a bomb had gone off. It was chaos, it was pandemonium,” said Spencer Glazer, a photojournalism major who wanted to document Saturday’s event. Glazer and Daniel...
Man shoots himself in heart with nail gun, drives to hospital
Man shoots himself in heart with nail gun, drives to hospital

Doug Bergeson is your typical construction worker, except he’s got a story that would make even the most hardened roofer shudder. The Peshtigo, Wisconsin man was working on a fireplace when his nail gun accidentally fired and a 3.5-inch nail sunk dangerously close to his heart. A graphic photo of the image shows just how disturbing the situation...
1 hit by vehicle and killed on U.S. 40, east of Springfield
1 hit by vehicle and killed on U.S. 40, east of Springfield

UPDATE @ 9:55 p.m.:  A woman is dead after she stepped out of her car, which was parked along the shoulder of westbound U.S. 40 east of Springfield, and was struck by a passing vehicle.  That passing vehicle also sideswiped the victim's car, and the driver of the passing vehicle stopped a short distance after the impact.  Investigators...
Woman’s long-lost engagement ring found on carrot
Woman’s long-lost engagement ring found on carrot

A Canadian woman was reunited with a long-lost engagement ring that she believed she’d never see again. Our news partners at WPTV report that Mary Grams, 84, believed that she had lost the  ring while pulling weeds in her garden in 2004. After losing the ring, she had it replaced. She received the ring in 1951 from her husband, the...
More Stories