Health law’s sign-up deadline meaningless to some

With some exceptions, the open enrollment period for most Ohioans to obtain health coverage under the Affordable Care Act will end at midnight today. But like millions of Americans, some local residents will simply ignore the deadline and pay the tax penalty for not abiding by the health law’s individual mandate to enroll.

After weighing the costs, 37-year-old Amy Peck of Middletown said she will pay the penalty rather than fork out $260 a month — the lowest premium she could find for a private health plan in Ohio’s health care marketplace, the online insurance exchange created by the ACA.

“I get sick maybe once or twice a year, and I’d still have to pay an office visit, plus the premium,” Peck said. “For my situation, it will cost less (to pay the fine) than the premiums for crappy coverage.”

Pete Schmidt of Kettering found it hard to palate rising health insurance premiums even before Congress passed the health law in 2010, and the tax penalty has given him little incentive to buy health coverage now.

“I am planning on dropping out of the system,” Schmidt said. “I will put the money I save into a bank account and pay for medical costs in cash. For a $95-a-year penalty, it is a no-brainer.”

Schmidt was referring to the first-year penalty of $95 per adult, and $47.50 per child under age 18 — money that will be held back from tax refunds beginning next year.

The penalty will be capped at a maximum of $285 per family, or 1 percent of modified adjusted gross income, and does not apply to people who are exempt from the health law.

That includes people whose income is below the tax-filing threshold, those for whom the lowest-priced coverage available to them would cost more than 8 percent of their household income and members of most American Indian tribes.

While ignoring the law may seem like a frugal alternative for some people who are not exempt, over the long-term, they could end up paying tens, or even hundreds, of thousands of dollars in tax penalties, according to a new study from, a financial-services information website.

Under the health law, minimum penalties will increase to $325 in 2015 and $695 in 2016. After 2016, the penalty will be adjusted based on annual Social Security cost of living adjustments.

From age 27 to 64 — the period when most adults are no longer eligible for dependent coverage from their parents or Medicare coverage for the elderly — an individual who never purchased health insurance would pay $42,077 in tax penalties, on average, while a family of four would pay $126,231, based on NerdWallet’s calculations, which assume a 2.78 percent annual increase in the cost of living.

Still, the Congressional Budget Office estimates that about 6 million people will opt to pay the fine instead of purchasing health coverage this year.

That’s same number of Americans who had signed up for coverage through the middle of last week, including nearly 80,000 Ohioans who had signed up through the end of last month, according to the latest updates from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

Those figures are expected to continue to grow even after today’s deadline because of the Obama administration’s decision to extend the sign-up period for consumers with special circumstances, including trouble accessing — the federal website for enrollment in health care marketplaces in 36 states, including Ohio.

The website has been plagued by computer problems, and health officials have expressed concerned that the anticipated surge in demand for new policies as the open-enrollment period draws to a close may block people from signing up.

That happened last year when traffic swamped just before the deadline for signing up for coverage beginning Jan. 1. A surge of more than 1 million applicants forced the feds to shutdown the website for retooling and extend the deadline for coverage from Dec. 15 to Dec. 23 and then Christmas Eve.

To qualify for the latest two-week extension, applicants ostensibly must have at least attempted to log on to the website before the enrollment deadline. But HHS said it will not attempt to verify the status of those seeking coverage even after the deadline has past, potentially opening the doors to throngs of new applicants.

“We have no idea what kind of demand there is going to be, but we’ve been busy these last three weeks or so, and people still have a lot of questions,” said Deborah Ferguson, director of outreach and social services at Community Action Partnership of Dayton.

Ferguson said her organization has asked volunteers assisting with sign-ups to stay on until April 15 in anticipation of continued demand.

Greg Lawson of the Buckeye Institute for Public Policy solutions, which advocates repealing and replacing the health law, described the latest delay as a “legislative fiat.”

“It’s not even clear that they (Obama administration) really have the legal standing to make some of these extensions in the first place,” Lawson said. “If you have to do all of these things to get the law to work, you out to be considering modifying the underlying legislation instead of trying to whistle past the graveyard. That’s why you have laws. That’s why you have Congress.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in News

Man warns ‘don’t take a chance with your eyes’ after eclipse-watching burned a hole in his retina
Man warns ‘don’t take a chance with your eyes’ after eclipse-watching burned a hole in his retina

If you’re thinking of watching the solar eclipse without the necessary eye gear, think again. One 71-year-old man is issuing a warning after burning one of his eyes more than 50 years ago. In 1962, Lou Tomososki was excited to witness the eclipse after learning about it from his science teacher.  That afternoon, he stood outside, and looked...
More charges for Ohio suspect in Charlottesville attack
More charges for Ohio suspect in Charlottesville attack

Five more felony charges were filed today against James Alex Fields Jr., the suspect in the Charlottesville car-ramming that killed one and injured more than 30. The Charlottesville Police Department said the new charges include three counts of aggravated malicious wounding and two counts of malicious wounding, CBS affiliate reported....
Florida hunters capture 12-foot gator days after 11-foot catch
Florida hunters capture 12-foot gator days after 11-foot catch

Four Florida hunters struggled to take down an 11-foot, 375-pound gator after a three-hour fight. Nick Naylor, John Booker, Kenny Way and Casey Shields began battling the massive gator beginning late Tuesday night and ended up with it under their control by Wednesday morning, according to the Pensacola News Journal. They used a 40-pound test from...
Mother flees with child after carjacker tries to pull her from her car
Mother flees with child after carjacker tries to pull her from her car

A mother, fearing for her and her daughter’s life, jumped a curb while fleeing from a carjacker. The victim said she was getting gas from a Texaco station when a small red Toyota pulled onto the parking lot. Officers said the man in the red Toyota approached her truck and asked for a ride down the street. The victim said no, because she had...
Man fatally shoots AAA worker over long response time, police say
Man fatally shoots AAA worker over long response time, police say

Surveillance video recently released by police captures the moment a Miami man shot and killed a AAA contract worker in July.  Jesus Esquivel, 63, confessed to fatally shooting the man over the amount of time it took for AAA to get him assistance, the Miami Herald reports.  In a video taken across the street from his Kendall home...
More Stories