breaking news

Clark County continue massive clean up of new park, gorge

Dayton in costly lawsuit with airport rental car companies


The city of Dayton is nearly eight months into an expensive legal battle with two rental car companies who sued the city about ongoing use of the parking garage at Dayton International Airport.

Dayton City Commission already has approved up to $600,000 in legal fees for Freund, Freeze & Arnold’s work on the case, anticipating more costs as the lawsuit goes forward in U.S. District Court.

The rental car companies, Avis and Budget, accuse the city of “bad faith repudiation of its contractual obligations.” In their complaint, they say the city signed agreements in 2008 and 2009 that created a 20-year, rent-free lease of first-floor space in the three-level parking garage, which was completed in 2010.

The rental car companies say that lease was created in part because they agreed to charge their customers a facility charge that helped to pay for construction of the garage.

But in November 2012, the city notified the rental car companies that their concession agreements would expire on Dec. 31, making other agreements automatically terminate on that date.

The city of Dayton, in its answer to the rental car companies’ lawsuit, “admits that part of the Agreement states that the Agreement expires 20 years from the garage completion date … but denies that is the only expiration date of the Agreement.”

The rental car companies originally asked for a restraining order so the city could not implement a new system, but the city agreed to maintain the status quo until the legal questions are resolved.

Since the original filing in November, the parties have fought over numerous legal issues, filing two dozen motions, responses and replies over expert witnesses, the validity of subpoenas and other issues. Both sides have filed motions for summary judgment, backed by hundreds of pages of exhibits.

U.S. District Judge Walter H. Rice has scheduled a trial in the case for July 30. The rental car companies filed an amended complaint Monday, asking the court to protect them from retaliation, such as unfairly increased fees or being deprived of using necessary airport premises.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

4-year-old accidentally shoots, kills himself with gun, father charged
4-year-old accidentally shoots, kills himself with gun, father charged

A four-year-old boy is dead after accidentally shooting and killing himself Saturday at a residence in Memphis, Tenn. The child’s father is facing a number of charges, including reckless homicide. Police said the incident happened around 6:30 p.m. on the city’s southeast side. When police arrived, they found the child on a walkway, according...
Great American Eclipse: More clearing than clouds
Great American Eclipse: More clearing than clouds

Monday is the Great American Eclipse, and all eyes are on the forecast.  The good news, it looks like we'll have a pretty good chance to see the eclipse, according to Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Brett Collar. We'll see daytime clouds develop during the heating of the day. These clouds will pass overhead at times, but there will be gaps between...
Clark County continue massive clean up of new park, gorge
Clark County continue massive clean up of new park, gorge

A recently developed park and nature preserve will get a visit next month from an organization devoted to showing visitors how to enjoy nature while leaving the area in pristine condition. From Sept. 25 to Oct. 1, Leave No Trace will host activities at the Mad River Gorge and Nature Preserve. The Clark County Park District won a roughly $800,000 grant...
Solar eclipse 2017: If you can’t get glasses, here’s what to do to watch Monday’s eclipse
Solar eclipse 2017: If you can’t get glasses, here’s what to do to watch Monday’s eclipse

If you have not gotten a pair of glasses to view Monday’s solar eclipse, you are not alone.Retail stores and online outlets across the country have reported that supplies are low or nonexistent in the hours before the 2017 solar eclipse.If you haven’t secured a pair, there are a few things you can do to safely watch the eclipse.Here are...
Mar-a-Lago dumped, more event cancellations after Trump’s Charlottesville remarks
Mar-a-Lago dumped, more event cancellations after Trump’s Charlottesville remarks

The Preservation Foundation of Palm Beach and an ovarian cancer group are the latest nonprofits to cancel charity events at President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Club. The Preservation Foundation, which celebrates and protects the architectural and cultural heritage of Palm Beach, planned to host a dance in March at the club, which has long...
More Stories