Wittenberg student sentenced to treatment


A Wittenberg student on trial for aggravated burglary was found not guilty by reason of insanity Wednesday morning.

Clark County Judge Douglas Rastatter followed the recommendation of a clinical psychologist who said Belule Ayele, 21, suffered a "severe mental disease at the time of the offense and therefore he did not know the wrongfulness of his offense at the time," according to the mental evaluation read aloud in court.

Ayele was ordered to undergo the least restrictive form of treatment by the court and will be treated for his mental disease at the Summit Behavioral Healthcare Hospital in Cincinnati. Once doctors determine he is competent, he will return to court and for the court to make their own determination for his release back into society, said Anthony VanNoy, Ayele's defense attorney.

Ayele was charged with the attempted rape and aggravated burglary after a January 16 incident involving a female Wittenberg student who told police she was sleeping when someone came into her bedroom, ripped the covers off her bed and climbed into bed with her nude. The woman said she was able escape unharmed from the suspect, later identified as Ayele, and went into a roommate's bedroom, where they called police, police said.

The woman's roommate told police she told the suspect to get out of the apartment, at which point he replied, "Satan, sit down; I'm talking to you," according to the arrest report. Ayele was taken into custody by Wittenberg police when they arrived at the apartment, police said.

The prosecutor's office dropped the attempted rape charge before Ayele's trial began Wednesday morning.

Because of his mental state at the time of the incident, Ayele did not understand the consequences of his actions the night of the incident, VanNoy said. During the past few months that he has received treatment in the county jail and is taking medications for his mental illness, Ayele is "heartbroken that he was even in this position" due to the illness, VanNoy added.

It is very rare that a defendent is found guilty by reason of insanity, said Assistant Prosecutor Brian Driscoll, who could only recall two other similar instances in his more than 10 years of work in the county prosecutor's office.

As a defense attorney for more than 20 years, VanNoy said he has had his "fair share" of clients who suffer a mental illness at the time of their crime and that in Ayele's case, like the majority of times, the legal system accounts for mental disease.

"It goes pretty smoothly just like this and the court recognizes that these individuals have an illness and we don't want to criminalize illness — instead they need help," VanNoy said.

Ayele will return to a Clark County courtroom after doctors at Summit Behavioral Healthcare Hospital determine he is no longer required to be hospitalized.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Massachusetts couple accidentally donates savings hidden in a soup can
Massachusetts couple accidentally donates savings hidden in a soup can

Amanda Mattuchio said her parents use a fake can of Campbell's Tomato Soup to hide their cash. Unfortunately, they stored it alongside real soup cans in their kitchen. “The bottom would unscrew and it had $2,500 in it and it was a combination of $100 and $50 bills,” she said. “The neighbor upstairs asked them if they had any canned...
70 years of focusing on diplomacy, global affairs
70 years of focusing on diplomacy, global affairs

For 70 years, the Dayton Council on World Affairs has been working to engage and educate in our region on the intricacies and importance of global events. As the group readies for its anniversary celebration, we spoke with Monica Schultz, its board president, and board member Carolyn Rice about the history and mission of the council. To learn more...
Senate fails to pass budget; government shutdown now official 
Senate fails to pass budget; government shutdown now official 

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Latest on the budget battle in Congress (all times local): 12:00 a.m. The government shutdown is now official, as the deadline has been reached with no deal in place. The White House released a statement on what they are calling the ‘Schumer Shutdown:’ “Senate Democrats own the Schumer Shutdown. Tonight...
Drake makes surprise appearance at Memphis nightclub
Drake makes surprise appearance at Memphis nightclub

He may have started from the bottom, but rapper Drake is making headlines after doing one dance that started in the Bluff City. According to party promoter Curtis Givens, the Grammy winner called him wanting to have a private party at In LOVE Memphis, a popular nightclub. Givens said it was a last minute call, but he and his business partner were up...
Woman dies after falling from balcony of Carnival cruise ship
Woman dies after falling from balcony of Carnival cruise ship

A woman died Friday after falling from the balcony of a room on the Jacksonville-based Carnival Elation cruise ship. The woman fell from the balcony to several decks below, Carnival said in a statement. Carnival Elation departed Jacksonville on Thursday for a four-day cruise to the Bahamas. Carnival sent the following statement to Action News Jax:"...
More Stories