McGuire estate sues to halt executions in Ohio


The estate of Dennis McGuire, the convicted murderer executed last week by a controversial new two-drug mixture, filed a lawsuit Friday in federal court demanding that Ohio halt further executions.

The suit also pins liability on Hospira, Inc., which attorneys Jon Paul Rion and Richard Schulte said is the manufacturer of the drugs used to kill McGuire.

The 38-page lawsuit electronically filed in United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio alleges that McGuire's 25-minute execution — Ohio's longest since reinstating executions in 1999 — was "cruel and unusual" punishment.

"The first cause of action deals with the constitutional violation where the state of Ohio caused a substantial amount of pain and suffering and it rose to the level that the Constitution itself is at issue," Rion said. "We know that for 25 minutes, Dennis McGuire was gasping for air, trying to raise off the gurney, clenching his fists and arching his back in an attempt to find oxygen.

"Initial reports from anesthesiologists and neurologists indicate that the actions of the clenching of the firsts and the arching of the back are clear indications of consciousness and suffering. One would be hard pressed to imagine a more inhumane form of execution than to than bind somebody to a table and deprive them of oxygen and allow them to slowly die in the presence of their family."

McGuire, 53 when he was pronounced dead Jan. 16 at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility near Lucasville, was convicted in Preble County for the 1989 murder of Joy Stewart of West Alexandria, who was nearly eight months pregnant when he raped her, cut her throat and left her by the side of the road near Eaton.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Single mother, actress Jennifer Garner says she
Single mother, actress Jennifer Garner says she "would not have chosen this life"

Actress Jennifer Garner ended her relationship with husband Ben Affleck in 2015, but the actress said she’s still “not interested in dating” other men. “I would not have chosen this life for myself or for my kids,” Garner told Australia’s News.com.au. “I would not choose to be single or be in this position...
Armed man records Facebook Live during police pursuit
Armed man records Facebook Live during police pursuit

A man arrested after a Dayton police pursuit and crash recorded himself on Facebook, pointing a gun as he was being pursued by Dayton police.  A citizen who claims to have seen the Facebook Live of the chase before the post was taken down sent the Facebook video to WHIO.com Tuesday morning.  In the video, King Turner, 19, of Trotwood, Ohio...
Cottrel: Cleaning up to host holidays leads to discoveries
Cottrel: Cleaning up to host holidays leads to discoveries

This is the calm before the storm, the day before we dive head first into Thanksgiving and officially enter the Christmas holiday season. Note: This may be the last time you will be able to sit down until 2018. Months ago when the spinning wheel of responsibility pointed to my name, I bravely began preparing to host the huge family Thanksgiving Dinner...
'Saturday Night Live' women defend Sen. Al Franken after groping allegations
'Saturday Night Live' women defend Sen. Al Franken after groping allegations

More than 30 women who worked with Sen. Al Franken on “Saturday Night Live,” defended the embattled lawmaker in an open later Tuesday, writing that while working with him “not one of us ever experienced any inappropriate behavior.” The women, including former SNL cast members Jane Curtin and Laraine Newman, writers and producers...
The Eagles announce 2018 tour with Jimmy Buffett, James Taylor, Chris Stapleton
The Eagles announce 2018 tour with Jimmy Buffett, James Taylor, Chris Stapleton

The Eagles are going on tour two years after the death of co-founder Glenn Frey. The Los Angeles Times reported that the band has announced stadium tour dates for 2018, beginning with a Chicago stop March 14. Jimmy Buffett and the Coral Reefer Band will join The Eagles for four of the eight announced dates so far, Rolling Stone reported. Chris Stapleton...
More Stories