Federal judges urge Congress to lift sequestration cuts

The Chief Judge of the Southern District of Ohio was one of 87 U.S. District Court judges across the country to send a letter to Congressional leaders saying that sequestration cuts threaten the core of the judicial branch’s duty. The cautionary tale about public safety being at risk is a rare foray into public policy for independent judges.

“We really feel that the integrity of the court is threatened,” said Cincinnati-based Chief Judge Susan J. Dlott. “We will not be able to conduct business the way we should, the way we’re constitutionally mandated to do.”

The letter details part of the impact the sequestration’s $350 million cut has and will have on the federal court system.

“As the boots on the ground in our nation’s federal trial courts, we have experienced firsthand the effect of those constraints and funding reductions,” the August letter said. “They have forced us to slash our operations to the bone, and we believe that our constitutional duties, public safety and the quality of the justice system will be profoundly compromised by any further cuts.”

The letter was sent to Congressional leaders including Vice President Joseph Biden, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio), House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.).

The judges make the argument that the judiciary — the third branch of the U.S. government — already is a bargain at .2 percent of the federal budget. Ohio Southern District Clerk of Court John Hehman said that two-thirds of the courts’ appropriation are fixed costs, so a 20-percent budget reduction has to come from personnel.

“About 15 percent of our workforce is having to be reduced so we can stay within the budget parameters that are necessary for next year,” Hehman said. “In any organization, that’s a big and dramatic thing.”

The letter states:

  • Clerks of court, probation and pretrial services offices will downsize by as many as 1,000 staff during fiscal year 2013.
  • Staffing in those same offices has been reduced by nearly 2,1000 staff between July 2011 and July 2013, the lowest since 1999.
  • Courts have incurred 4,500 furlough days as of June 2013, slowing civil and bankruptcy cases.
  • The number of convicted offenders under the supervision of federal probation officers hit a record 187,311 in 2012 and is on pace to top 191,000 by 2014, while staffing is down in that office by 7 percent.
  • Cuts have been made affecting the monitoring of criminal defendants, courthouse security and law enforcement allotments that fund drug, mental health and sex offender treatment, testing and treatment for offenders, GPS monitoring and defender services.


Greg Lawson, a policy analyst at Buckeye Institute, said legislators haven’t taken on the huge budgets of what he called entitlement/mandatory spending categories like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, so some other percentage cuts are political “cop-outs” that don’t really help end the federal deficit.

“I’m not going to say that the court system doesn’t have areas where they could cut,” Lawson said. “But it would make sense for the cuts to be calibrated better than they were with this strict, across-the-board type operation of the sequester… . The truth probably is that the cut is overly draconian but not that there shouldn’t be any cut at all.”

Dlott said any cost savings may be wiped out by the ripple effect of slower operations:

“If you put off criminal trials, all you do is you keep the people — if they’re not out on bond — you’re spending more money keeping them in jail before you can try them and you’re violating their civil rights,” she said.

In Ohio’s Southern District Courts in Dayton, Cincinnati and Columbus, the staff has been reduced from 80 to 67 — five from early retirements and eight layoffs.

Hehman said any such letter to Congress is precedent-setting.

“It’s fair to say that chief judges are highly independent, and averse to public lobbying,” Hehman said. “Nothing like this has happened in decades, if ever, so beyond the letter’s content, the very fact that this type of letter has been drafted and so widely signed underscores the urgency being felt within the judiciary.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Crime

Illinois town taking center stage for eclipse
Illinois town taking center stage for eclipse

A small town in Illinois will be the focal point Monday when a total solar eclipse crosses North America for the first time in 99 years. In Makanda, located in the southern part of the state, the eclipse will be visible for more than two minutes, CBS News reported. Residents are approaching the event with a party atmosphere. "I do feel...
Brent Spence Bridge lane closures coming to an end
Brent Spence Bridge lane closures coming to an end

Round-the-clock lane closures for Brent Spence Bridge maintenance are coming to an end on Monday morning for southbound lanes and on Aug. 25 for northbound lanes. All four northbound lanes on the bridge will be reopened by 5 a.m. Aug. 25. MORE: Majority support for Brent Spence tolls Crews will begin restoring the northbound (lower) deck of the Brent...
Comedy genius Jerry Lewis has died at 91
Comedy genius Jerry Lewis has died at 91

Legendary comedian, brash entertainer,  zany actor and dedicated humanitarian Jerry Lewis has died in Las Vegas at the age of 91. He died at his home at 9:15 a.m. , according to the Las Vegas Review-Journal and confirmed by his agent, Variety reported. Lewis was born Joseph Levitch in 1926 in Newark, New Jersey to show business parents...
Man, 51, killed in Clark County crash
Man, 51, killed in Clark County crash

A 51-year-old Catawba man was killed in a crash on Redmond Road south of Old Columbus Road Saturday night, according to the Ohio Highway Patrol. Gary Jacks was driving a 2011 Chevrolet Traverse south on Redmond when he drove off the left side of the road and struck a tree, troopers said.  He was not wearing a seat belt and troopers do not suspect...
Madonna celebrates turning 59, posting first family pic with all six kids
Madonna celebrates turning 59, posting first family pic with all six kids

Photographed for the very first time! Pop star Madonna shared a debut family portrait Friday that featured her and all six of her children. The Material Girl posted the photo on Instagram following her 59th birthday party at a two-day, gypsy-themed celebration in Italy. From top left Rocco, 17,  David, 11, and Mercy James, 11, to the right of...
More Stories