Doctor in starvation case involving teen girl sentenced to jail


The doctor of a 14-year-old, 28-pound girl with cerebral palsy who died of starvation was sentenced Tuesday to 4½ months in jail.

Montgomery County Juvenile Court Judge Nick Kuntz ordered Dr. Margaret Edwards, 51, to report to jail Sept. 9 for a six-month jail sentence with 45 days suspended after he found Edwards guilty of three misdemeanors stemming from her role in the death of Makayla Norman, who one prosecutor said was “left to rot.”

Edwards had pleaded no contest to three first-degree misdemeanor counts of failure to report child abuse or neglect of a functionally impaired person. Kuntz also ordered Edwards to pay court costs, surrender her passport and required her to do one year of probation after she completes her sentence. Kuntz could have sentenced Edwards to up to 18 months behind bars. Earlier, Edwards agreed to permanently surrender her medical license.

“We’re pleased that this defendant was held accountable and she received jail time as part of that sentence,” said Montgomery County assistant prosecutor Tracey Ballard Tangeman. “She was, what I would describe, similar to what you would see if you were viewing a movie about World War II and seeing concentration camp victims.”

Norman could not speak, move, or feed herself when she died March 1, 2011. When Norman died, her body was covered with filth and open bedsores, her hair and eyebrows were infested with lice, and her diaper and colon filled with feces, according to Dayton police.

Prosecutors have said Edwards was required to provide care and treatment for Norman and to inspect the living conditions of her home. Edwards’ last documented visit to Norman’s home was Oct. 29, 2010.

“There was a breakdown in the system and I’m very sorry for my role in that,” Edwards said as she started to cry. “I must also apologize to Makayla’s family for this tragic outcome because it did not have to happen.”

Edwards’ attorney, Todd Long, asked Kuntz to give Edwards probation. “The court feels required to impose a sentence,” Kuntz said.

Edwards, of Trotwood, is the last of five people to be criminally prosecuted in the 14-year-old’s death. Norman’s mother, Angela, and her nurse Mollie Parsons are already serving prison terms, Norman for nine years and Parsons for 10 years. Two other nurses, Kathryn Williams and Mary Kilby, who were to supervise Norman’s care have been convicted of felonies but received five years’ community control. There are two pending appeals involving Kilby and Williams. Federal charges are possible.

“The state is very pleased that all of these people who failed Makayla Norman have been held accountable in one way or another,” prosecutor Erin Claypoole said, saying that legislation has gone forward to clear up what doctors are required to do in such situations.

Norman’s family members declined to make a victim impact statement. A civil case involving Norman’s estate has been scheduled for trial in April 2014.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Rain showers start the week, possible snow flurries Tuesday 
Rain showers start the week, possible snow flurries Tuesday 

A few showers expected today More rain likely Monday Colder with the chance for snow Tuesday TODAY: A few showers are expected throughout the day today. While it won’t be a wash-out, you’ll want to make sure you have an umbrella handy if you have plans to be out. Temperatures will be on the mild side in the mid to upper 40s. ...
Trump campaign ad calls Democrats 'complicit' in killings by undocumented immigrants
Trump campaign ad calls Democrats 'complicit' in killings by undocumented immigrants

A new ad released by President Donald Trump's campaign is claiming that Democrats are “complicit” in killings by undocumented immigrants. The ad was released after Senate Democrats opposed a short-term spending bill to keep the government from shutting down. “President Trump is right — build the wall, deport criminals...
Michael Phelps reveals he considered suicide after 2012 Olympics
Michael Phelps reveals he considered suicide after 2012 Olympics

Swimmer Michael Phelps has revealed that after the 2012 Olympics, he considered suicide. “Really, after every Olympics I think I fell into a major state of depression,” he told David Axelrod at the fourth annual conference of the Kennedy Forum, an organization for mental health advocacy, according to CNN. Phelps revealed that...
Dogs found in perfect condition in home where 13 siblings held captive
Dogs found in perfect condition in home where 13 siblings held captive

A pair of well-kept dogs were taken from the Perris, California, house where 13 children were found shackled and severely malnourished last week. David Turpin, 57, and Louise Turpin, 49, are facing a minimum of 94 years for charges including child neglect and torture after police said their children, ranging from ages 2 to 29, were discovered in their...
COMMENTARY: You can’t go wrong with Ben Franklin’s wisdom

When I used to teach American literature as part of our sophomore curriculum, I always looked forward to teaching the Ben Franklin excerpts from “Poor Richard’s Almanac.” Why? First of all, these proverbs and aphorisms reflect a way of thinking that gives great insight into the American psyche and identity of a certain age &mdash...
More Stories