You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Decision on 4th Widmer trial expected


Convicted bathtub killer Ryan Widmer should find out today whether he will be granted a fourth trial in Warren County.

The 12th District Court of Appeals is expected to release its opinion in Widmer’s second appeal at 9 a.m. The appeals court denied Widmer’s first appeal, which focused heavily on what the defense claimed was an illegal seizure of the infamous bathtub.

The second appeal in the case centers on former lead detective Jeff Braley, but Widmer’s attorney Michele Berry-Godsey touched on Braley’s dishonesty in the first appeal as well. The judges said Judge Neal Bronson was not wrong to disallow evidence that Braley lied on a 14-year-old job application.

“Whether Braley authored the 14-year-old fabricated application was an issue collateral to Widmer’s murder trial,” Judge Robert Hendrickson wrote. “Exploration of this issue was likely to ‘bog down’ the criminal trial and lead to confusion of the jury and misleading of the jury.”

Berry-Godsey has asked the Ohio Supreme Court to reverse the 12th District decision. The high court has not decided whether to accept the case.

Braley resigned last year after an investigation revealed he lied on his job application about his educational and employment experience. Berry-Godsey said Braley lied about his service in the “ultra-elite” Special Forces unit of the U.S. Air Force — which helped him get promoted —and jurors should have been told that.

Prosecutors say Braley was a bit-player in the Widmer case.

The three-judge panel during oral arguments last August seemed focused on rules of evidence. Berry-Godsey argued Widmer’s constitutional rights were trampled when he wasn’t allowed to unveil Braley’s apparent shortcomings.

The 32-year-old is serving 15 years to life for drowning his wife Sarah in the bathtub in August 2008. In Widmer’s first trial, he was found guilty of murder but that verdict was thrown out after jurors admitted to conducting at-home experiments and discussed their results during deliberations. They admitted to bathing and timing how long it took to dry. Only Sarah’s hair was damp when first responders arrived and no wet towels or rags could be found.

The second trial ended with a hung jury after jurors said they could not make a decision after 2 1/2 days. The third verdict came after 13 days of testimony from 44 witnesses and a dozen hours of deliberations.

Widmer’s father, Gary Widmer, has said he isn’t counting on getting a fourth trial at the state level, but is pinning his hope on the federal courts. Legal expert Ian Friedman, a former president of the Ohio Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, said Widmer might be right.

“In the event that the state court decision affirms the conviction, Mr. Widmer will spend the coming years seeking review of his case in the federal courts. The process is called habeas corpus review. Mr. Widmer as the petitioner will be asking the federal court to overturn his conviction on the basis that their was some constitutional violation during the state proceedings,” Friedman said. “Some hold out more hope in the federal system because they believe that these judges, who are appointed for life, need not worry about public opinion and can just focus on the substantive issues. This battle can go on for decades.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Will Donald Trump be ‘restrained’ as tweeter in chief?
Will Donald Trump be ‘restrained’ as tweeter in chief?
Donald Trump ranting before dawn on Twitter about a former Miss Universe might not bring to mind Franklin Roosevelt reassuring Depression-battered radio listeners or Richard Nixon salvaging his 1952 vice presidential bid through his televised Checkers speech.
Fisher-Price 'happy hour' playset is fake, company says
Fisher-Price 'happy hour' playset is fake, company says
It's another reminder not to believe everything you see on the internet. A photo of an alcohol-themed Fisher-Price playset has been circulating online and drawing attention.
Bill Murray serenades 94-year-old grandmother for her birthday
Bill Murray serenades 94-year-old grandmother for her birthday
If comedian Bill Murray sings to you for your birthday, you must be doing something right. Maryellen Hook Wible was celebrating her 94th birthday at the Xavier vs.
Facebook glitch leads to old photos being posted without user permission
Facebook glitch leads to old photos being posted without user permission
Facebook's annual "Year In Review" feature recaps moments that users shared on the social media site during the past year, but PC Magazine reported Friday that a glitch that might be related to the feature is concerning to some.
Pedestrian, hit by vehicle in Clark County, is seriously injured
Pedestrian, hit by vehicle in Clark County, is seriously injured
More Stories