Condemned killer gets no mercy

Ohio Parole Board votes 11-0 to put Preble County man to death.


After hearing about his childhood filled with abuse and malnutrition, the Ohio Parole Board voted 11-0 against clemency for condemned killer and former Preble County resident Dennis McGuire, who raped and murdered Joy Stewart in February 1989.

McGuire’s attorneys last week argued before the Parole Board that McGuire should be spared execution, in part, because he finally admitted his guilt in the crime and his abusive childhood was not thoroughly detailed during the sentencing phase of his trial.

Stewart, who was seven months pregnant, disappeared Feb. 11, 1989, after she was last seen with McGuire. Her body was found in the woods by hikers the next day. Her throat had been slashed and evidence showed she was raped.

McGuire, 53, is scheduled to be executed Jan. 16 for the crime.

Gov. John Kasich has the constitutional power to grant clemency to McGuire. His decision is expected in early January.

The Ohio Parole Board noted that McGuire tried to evade responsibility for the crime for decades and his eleventh hour admission seemed “disingenuous and contrite.” Evidence of McGuire’s horrible childhood does not explain nor mitigate to such a degree that the jury would have come to a different sentencing conclusion, the board said in its report to Kasich.

Stewart’s family is firmly in favor of McGuire’s execution, according to the parole board report. Her sister, Carol Avery, told the board that her parents both died knowing that their daughter’s killer was still alive. McGuire should pay with his life for killing Stewart, she told the board.

McGuire is the second in his family to face the death penalty. His older brother, Genis McGuire Jr., who is imprisoned at Chillicothe Correctional Institution, had faced the death penalty in his case but received 20 years to life for stabbing a convenience store clerk more than 60 times in Warren County in 1995.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Gradual weekend warm-up; Possible light showers to cause slick roads
Gradual weekend warm-up; Possible light showers to cause slick roads

Gradual warm-up this weekend Wet Sunday into Monday Colder with snow showers Tuesday TODAY: Increasing clouds and breezy for the day with temperatures climbing to the lower 40s. However, winds will make it feel like the upper 20s to lower 30s during the afternoon. Areas of light drizzle and mist will develop tonight as temperatures dip into the mid...
Autopsy report: Roy Halladay had drugs in system when plane crashed
Autopsy report: Roy Halladay had drugs in system when plane crashed

An autopsy on former major-leaguer Roy Halladay showed that he had amphetamines, morphine and a sleep aid in his system when he died in a plane crash off the west coast of Florida, The Tampa Bay Times reported Friday. Halladay, 40, died Nov. 7 from blunt force trauma with drowning as a contributing factor, according to the Pinellas-Pasco Medical...
Massachusetts couple accidentally donates savings hidden in a soup can
Massachusetts couple accidentally donates savings hidden in a soup can

Amanda Mattuchio said her parents use a fake can of Campbell's Tomato Soup to hide their cash. Unfortunately, they stored it alongside real soup cans in their kitchen. “The bottom would unscrew and it had $2,500 in it and it was a combination of $100 and $50 bills,” she said. “The neighbor upstairs asked them if they had any canned...
70 years of focusing on diplomacy, global affairs
70 years of focusing on diplomacy, global affairs

For 70 years, the Dayton Council on World Affairs has been working to engage and educate in our region on the intricacies and importance of global events. As the group readies for its anniversary celebration, we spoke with Monica Schultz, its board president, and board member Carolyn Rice about the history and mission of the council. To learn more...
Senate fails to pass budget; government shutdown now official 
Senate fails to pass budget; government shutdown now official 

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Latest on the budget battle in Congress (all times local): 12:00 a.m. The government shutdown is now official, as the deadline has been reached with no deal in place. The White House released a statement on what they are calling the ‘Schumer Shutdown:’ “Senate Democrats own the Schumer Shutdown. Tonight...
More Stories