You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Champaign County wind firm argues project should proceed


Officials from the Ohio Power Siting Board and Everpower Renewables argued a Champaign County wind project has been extensively reviewed, and that the state’s highest court should allow it to move forward.

The legal arguments filed Tuesday with the Ohio Supreme Court were in response to concerns raised earlier this year by Champaign County prosecutors and members of Union Neighbors United, a group of area residents opposed to the project. The county and UNU have raised concerns ranging from the safety of the project to the process by which the second phase of the wind farm was approved.

Combined with an earlier first phase, the project would install about 100 turbines throughout Champaign County. Developers of the project said it could create more than 100 temporary construction jobs and could generate between $1.2 and $1.8 million in additional revenue for the county.

Officials from Everpower could not be reached for comment Wednesday.

But county officials have raised concerns that the OPSB did not allow both sides of the debate equal opportunity to present evidence, and did not take many of the county’s concerns into account. Members of UNU have raised concerns about the safety of the project, and argued a state renewable energy mandate that helped create demand for the wind farm might violate the U.S. Commerce Clause by discriminating against companies from outside of Ohio.

However, attorneys for the OPSB disagreed that the mandate violated the Commerce Clause, and argued that even without the renewable mandate, the board likely would have approved the project because it serves the public interest by delivering energy to the state’s bulk transmission system.

“The Board specifically stated that the in-state renewable energy requirement merely ‘adds support’ to a finding that the project is in the public interest, convenience and necessity,” the OPSB brief argues.

County prosecutors had also raised concerns that the OPSB allowed company officials from Everpower to testify as experts about the project, although in some cases they could not answer specific questions about information in the initial application.

Attorneys for the OPSB argued the approval process included almost three weeks of hearings and hundreds of pages of testimony from almost three dozen witnesses. For example, county officials had raised concerns that a witness who testified about a transportation study in the application could not explain how much of the information was gathered, and was not directly involved in developing many parts of the study.

But OPSB attorneys argued the transportation study was conducted under his direction, and argued his testimony was appropriate with his job description. The OPSB also argued it has a long-standing practice to allow a company’s officer or an experienced employee to sponsor an application.

But because the experts sometimes were not able to answer questions about the application, the process placed an undue burden on the county to find out whether studies about the project were accurate, said Jane Napier, assistant Champaign County prosecutor.

“I just don’t think we can say ‘That’s how we’ve done it in the past’ is legally sufficient,” Napier said.

In a separate brief, attorneys for Everpower argued many of the issues being debated had already been resolved when the first phase of the project was approved.

“As they did in Buckeye Wind, UNU and the county want this court to revisit the Board’s procedural rulings, reweigh the evidence and remand the matter for further hearing,” Everpower’s brief states. “And like Buckeye Wind, it is difficult to understand what additional hearings might accomplish.”

Attorneys from UNU and Champaign County will have about 20 days to respond to the briefs filed this week, said Jack Van Kley, an attorney for UNU. But UNU might seek an extension for additional time to prepare the reply, he said.

Both sides would then be allowed to make arguments in person before the Ohio Supreme Court.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Elephant ranch lets visitors bathe, feed, ride elephants
Elephant ranch lets visitors bathe, feed, ride elephants

A private central Florida elephant preserve offers a unique, hands-on experience to visitors. The Elephant Ranch allows tourists to get up close and personal with the majestic animals. >> Read more trending news The Two Tails Ranch located near Gainesville lets people feed, bathe and even ride the eight elephants living at the ranch. The nonprofit...
International applicants dramatically down at area universities
International applicants dramatically down at area universities

U.S. college applications from international students are dramatically down, including requests received by area universities that rely on the tuition revenue generated by the foreign applicants. Around 39 percent of U.S. universities are reporting a decline in international applications for the fall semester while 26 percent saw no change and 35 percent...
Idaho woman blames car crash on deer-chasing Bigfoot
Idaho woman blames car crash on deer-chasing Bigfoot

A northern Idaho woman blamed a car crash with a deer on a Sasquatch sighting last week. >> Read more trending news The woman told police she collided with the deer after spotting a Bigfoot on a highway near Potlatch near the Washington border, according to NBC Montana. The woman said the Sasquatch was chasing the deer Wednesday night along the...
World War 1 exhibit opening at Clark County Heritage Center
World War 1 exhibit opening at Clark County Heritage Center

A local historical Society next month will be hosting a World War 1 themed exhibit featuring artifacts from Springfield residents. The Clark County Historical Society will be debuting their two-year exhibit Global Conflict, Local Experience: Clark County Joins the Great War at their museum at the Heritage Center, 117 S. Fountain Ave, on April 6th....
Trump now blames conservative Republicans for healthcare failure
Trump now blames conservative Republicans for healthcare failure

  President Donald Trump is now pointing the finger at an ultra-conservative Republican faction in the House for the GOP failure to rally a vote on House speaker Paul Ryan’s American Healthcare Act, scuttling the bill on Friday. >> Read more trending news But on Friday, it wasn’t the far-right Freedom Caucus, but the Democrats...
More Stories