Black box could shed light on plane mystery

Some say no known signal from device suggests it was deliberately disabled.


Satellite images of what could be the remains of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 in the Southern Indian Ocean set off renewed speculation among local experts about the sequence of events that led up to the jet’s disappearance.

While everything from terrorism to black holes have come up in round-the-clock discussions, some angles are taking on greater prominence as the search continues.

Ken Curell, a veteran commercial and military pilot with decades of experience flying large passenger jets and fighter aircraft, is focused on the fate of the nearly-indestructible black box that should have been aboard. If the plane had crashed either in the ocean or on land, it’s likely the box would survive. The black box contains a digital recording of the aircraft’s flight and transmits a locating signal.

If a crash happened in the water, it should also be transmitting now and providing a signal for searchers. The fact that there is no known signal from the device is additional reason for thinking something beyond the ordinary occurred.

Was the box disabled by pilots in the cockpit or before the flight by someone on the ground? Did a technical problem cause it to malfunction? Could the plane have plunged into a deep ocean trench that prevented the signal from being located because radio transmission limitations?

The box should have been checked for functionality before the plane left the ground, Curell said, and is capable of signaling a malfunction. There are also two detachable emergency transmitters on board and no signal has been reportedly heard from those devices either.

One speculated scenario is that the crew was overcome by smoke and fumes in the cockpit before they were able to turn the jet around. In that sequence of events, the plane’s autopilot would take over and keep the craft flying until the fuel was exhausted.

Curell said it would take considerable activity in the crew compartment of the jet to shut down or compromise the data reporting system and the plane’s transponder. Assuming there were no technical failures, shutdowns of that equipment on similar aircraft would require some very deliberate circuit-breaker pulling, Curell said.

If the aircraft broke up in flight, the black box would most likely remain intact; once the device hit the water, the signal is water-activated and would start sending out a location beacon over an emergency frequency. Satellites monitor those signals to pinpoint locations of crashed aircraft.

“Again, we’ve heard no reports of such a signal being heard,” Curell said.

Donna Schalagheck, chair of political science at Wright State University, said although there has been a decline in the number of international hijackings since Sept. 11, in part because of all the safety precautions that have been implemented, modern terrorism has shown it is adaptable.

Screening passengers and crew, locking cockpit doors, and other security methods would have to be circumvented.

“Terrorism does not cease to surprise or adapt,” she said.

Schalagheck wonders what evidence government officials in the Peoples Republic of China have about the plane’s disappearance.

“China has been very quiet,” she said. “Half of those on board were from there. What is going on behind the scenes there?”

If the plane landed in some remote area as part of some terrorist plot, it would still need jet fuel to take off again, a very difficult logistical problem, she said.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

‘I’ll never forget the sounds,’ says woman hit in Charlottesville car attack
‘I’ll never forget the sounds,’ says woman hit in Charlottesville car attack

On Tuesday night, Van Jones spoke to Constance -- a woman who survived being hit in the infamous car attack in Charlottesville -- during his “We Rise Against Hate” tour. As she moved onto the stage, still on crutches, she received continuous applause, and Jones asked the audience, “You ever met a hero? You ever seen a hero in real...
County settles lawsuit brought by pepper-sprayed inmate
County settles lawsuit brought by pepper-sprayed inmate

A woman who was pepper sprayed by a corrections officer while strapped into a restraint chair at the Montgomery County jail has settled her lawsuit against the county, according to federal court records. Amber Swink, 25, filed suit in September 2016 alleging civil rights violations, violations of departmental policy and claiming an attempted cover-up...
CNN criticized for labeling white supremacist Richard Spencer a ‘white rights activist’ in headline
CNN criticized for labeling white supremacist Richard Spencer a ‘white rights activist’ in headline

A headline on the website cnn.com this morning called white nationalist Richard Spencer a ‘white rights activist’, wording that led to criticism across social media. Spencer, who has referred to himself as a “white supremacist,” was scheduled to speak at the University of Florida. The university cited safety concerns and canceled...
Research group finds 2-headed turtle 
Research group finds 2-headed turtle 

The University of Central Florida’s Marine Turtle Research Group found a two-headed turtle in Brevard County during its research Thursday. >> Read more trending news  The group excavates nests three days after the turtles hatch to determine how many eggs were laid and how many hatchlings emerged.  Any straggler turtles...
Timeline: The wild 24 hours of Franklin’s Robert E. Lee Confederate monument 
Timeline: The wild 24 hours of Franklin’s Robert E. Lee Confederate monument 

A Confederate memorial in Warren County was removed in the early morning of Thursday, Aug. 17. Franklin officials determined the Robert E. Lee monument was in a public right of way for Dixie Highway and wanted it to be moved before a Dayton racial justice group’s planned demonstration on Aug. 19. The marker was on a rock at the corner of Hamilton...
More Stories