Sports Today: The Pete Rose-John Dowd lawsuit defies belief


Today’s top headline is a reminder spite can be a very dangerous thing. 

If you know literally the first thing about defamation suits involving public figures, the fact a judge could agree someone might have defamed Pete Rose is stunning. 

This someone went to law school, no less. 

It borders on unbelievable this could happen. 

RELATED: Judge rules Pete Rose lawsuit against John Dowd may continue

That is because in the case of public figures (such as Rose), the requirement for proving defamation is not just a negative impact on their reputation but also that the statements at hand were known to be false. 

Winning a defamation case, especially for someone who has had a lot of his dirty laundry aired publicly over the years, is nearly impossible for a public figure. 

Filing such a suit also opens up both sides to potentially damaging discovery (when they can legally force each other to give up all sorts of information to be used in the trial), or you would see many more lawsuits filed by famous people when someone says something about them they don’t like. 

RELATED: MLB keeps jerking around Pete Rose

But it turns out Rose investigator John Dowd’s assertion on a radio show two years ago that Rose had repeatedly committed statutory rape in the 1980s has opened him up to legal action

Dowd’s recklessness here is frankly stunning, especially considering his accusation were not even based on personal knowledge but rather second-hand information. 

This becomes problematic when the middle man disavows statements attributed to him. 

RELATED: Does new Pete Rose statue remind you of anyone? 

And yet maybe this shouldn’t be entirely surprising because Dowd has been running down Pete Rose ever since he completed his report that got Rose thrown out of baseball nearly 30 years ago. 

The Hit King’s banishment was not “the sad end of a sorry episode,” as commissioner Bart Giamatti said at the time, but only because both sides have continued to talk about it ever since. 

Rose has done plenty to bring trouble on himself, but Dowd’s conduct has always looked unseemly. 

Perhaps this time he went too far...  

Meanwhile, the action on the field continues to disappoint. 

The Reds were pounded again last night, this time an 11-2 loss to the Arizona Diamondbacks

Cincinnati is 0-5 since the All-Star break, and the team just put another pitcher on the disabled list

RELATED: Feldman 7th Reds starter to go on DL

They don’t know for sure who will take his spot in the rotation even though there are multiple top prospects in Triple-A who throw the ball from the mound for a living. 

HAL MCCOY: Finding a rotation challenge for Reds

That should tell you a lot about the state of pitching not just in the majors but throughout the upper reaches of the organization... 

In other news, football season continues to inch closer. 

I stopped by Chaminade Julienne yesterday to check out some of the Eagles’ 7 on 7 passing camp with Trotwood-Madison

On top of that, Marc Pendleton’s look at the best players from area high schools continued with Fairmont East, the alma mater of a certain former Michigan football coach and the current chairman of the College Football Playoff committee... 

Another area athlete, Greeneview’s Evan Bradds, was dealt a bad break this spring when he was injured working out for the NBA draft, but he seems to be making the most of it... 

Speaking of basketball, Dayton director of athletics Neil Sullivan is bullish on the changes coming to the NCAA tournament selection process. So am I


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Middletown’s Kyle Schwarber falls in finals of Home Run Derby
Middletown’s Kyle Schwarber falls in finals of Home Run Derby

Kyle Schwarber’s Chicago Cubs teammate, Javier Baez, watched him compete in the Home Run Derby from ESPN’s broadcast booth on the field Monday at Nationals Park in Washington, D.C.. “We’re going to have a great show from Schwarber,” Baez said. Schwarber, a Middletown High School graduate seeded fifth, delivered by advancing...
Former Ohio State football player passes away
Former Ohio State football player passes away

Highland Local Schools announced Monday afternoon the passing of former Ohio State football player Mike Kudla.  No cause of death was released, but Kudla was only 34.  After graduating from Highland in 2002, Kudla played linebacker and defensive end for the Buckeyes from 2002-05.  He was an All-Big Ten first-team pick in 2005 and had...
Cougars thump Dragons in series finale, 13-4
Cougars thump Dragons in series finale, 13-4

Dragons starting pitcher Adrian Rodriguez has a tough assignment: show he’s fully recovered from Tommy John reconstructive elbow surgery. From Mexico and acquired by the parent-club Cincinnati Reds as a free agent in 2014, Rodriguez missed the last half of the 2016 season after being injured and all of last season. He had hoped to finish off...
Votto: Riggleman brings ‘good energy’ to Reds
Votto: Riggleman brings ‘good energy’ to Reds

The Cincinnati Reds shared a press conference with Joey Votto on Facebook Live on Monday, one day before the 89th All-Star Game in Washington, D.C. Votto, a six-time All-Star, answered all manners of questions from reporters. Here are a few highlights of the session: On former teammate Shin-Soo Choo being a first-time All-Star: “I was stunned...
Pro Football Focus pessimistic about Bengals offensive line progress
Pro Football Focus pessimistic about Bengals offensive line progress

Pro Football Focus still thinks the Cincinnati Bengals offensive line will be bad this season.  This seems to be predicated on two things: Ohio State rookie Billy Price being no better than last year’s center and Trey Hopkins both being the starting right guard and being no better than he was a year ago.  I’m not sure I agree...
More Stories