Knee-jerk reactions to the NCAA tournament field


We can’t overanalyze the NCAA tournament until we start analyzing it, so here are a few random thoughts on the field upon its initial unveiling: 

1. Ohio State got about as bad a draw as could have been expected

That is not to say the Buckeyes were treated unfairly. A five seed is fine. 

But they ended up with one of the tougher mid-majors in South Dakota State, a team that  (unlike Ohio State) is already used to the NCAA tournament experience.

The Jackrabbits shouldn’t be intimidated by the stage, and Ohio State coach Chris Holtmann told CBS Sports Network on Sunday night SDSU forward Mike Daum is an NBA-caliber player.  

If the Buckeyes win that one, they will probably get a rematch with a Gonzaga team that is eighth in KenPom ratings and already crushed them (so maybe the revenge factor works in OSU’s favor? I always love the revenge factor…), then I believe Xavier is pretty legit. 

But that’s why they play the games (#BTWTPTG)! 

2. Perhaps the opposite is true of Wright State. 

In Tennessee, the Raiders get another defense-first team and one that hasn’t been in the NCAA tournament since going to the Sweet 16 in 2014

With a couple of big guys in the starting lineup, including imposing redshirt freshman Loudon Love, Wright State could present a unique challenge to a Tennessee team that isn’t overly big. 

» RELATED: Wright State to play Tennessee in first roundOhio State headed to BoiseSt. Bonaventure coming to First Four

Plus the Volunteers are coached by former Ohio State assistant Rick Barnes, whose Texas teams had a habit of leaving the NCAA tournament early in the second half of his tenure in Austin. 

3. The Atlantic 10 regular season champion didn’t get screwed this year. 

Rhode Island got a seven seed and a matchup with the least-deserving at-large team to receive a bid, Oklahoma. 

The deep, experienced Rams should take care of the young Sooners, who limped down the stretch then could give Duke some fits at least in the second round. 

Last year, Dayton received a seven seed, too, but had to play ridiculously under-seeded Wichita State in the first round. The Shockers won a classic. 

4. Mid-major on mid-major crime should be limited. 

This is another departure from last year, although Wichita State is again involved in a game we’d have rather seen later in the tournament. 

The fourth-seeded Shockers will take on Marshall, a feel-good story after breaking a long tournament drought under new coach Dan D’Antoni. 

I guess this WSU isn’t a Cinderella candidate anymore anyway after moving to the AAC. 

5. Maybe Gonzaga passes the torch on to Xavier. 

Gonzaga making its first Final Four last year left some to dub Xavier as the best program yet to achieve that feat. 

To do so, the top-seeded Musketeers just might have to go through the Bulldogs. That would be fitting. 

They will probably also have to beat North Carolina to get to San Antonio, and a rematch of the UNC-Gonzaga national championship game of a year ago is possible in the regional final. 

6. Can Cincinnati break through? 

The Bearcats have had a hard time earning national respect because of little success in March recently. 

With a No. 2 seed, the path should be clear for them to make the Elite Eight without doing anything out of the ordinary. 

Then if the seedings hold, they will get another defense-minded team in Virginia. That might actually be preferable to facing a group of Wildcats from Arizona or Kentucky with more raw talent. 


Reader Comments


Next Up in Sports

Greater Western Ohio Conference votes Trotwood-Madison out
Greater Western Ohio Conference votes Trotwood-Madison out

The Greater Western Ohio Conference on Wednesday voted to “dismiss” Trotwood-Madison from the area’s largest affiliation. GWOC Commissioner Eric Spahr cited schedule concerns, a disparity in enrollment and Trotwood’s inability to field teams below the varsity levels in some sports. The eight remaining GWOC members eventually...
Girls Basketball: Tecumseh gears up for league title chase, postseason
Girls Basketball: Tecumseh gears up for league title chase, postseason

The Tecumseh High School girls basketball program has lofty goals this season. After winning their third straight Central Buckeye Conference Kenton Trail Division title, the Arrows upset top-seeded Lebanon in the Division I postseason tournament, but were bounced by Fairmont in the next round. Tecumseh (2-2, 2-0 CBC Kenton Trail) has loaded its schedule...
Ohio State football season review: Defense a major disappointment
Ohio State football season review: Defense a major disappointment

What was expected In short, another dominating unit.  Ohio State ranked fifth in defensive S&P+ (an advanced metric that combines play-by-play efficiency and explosiveness, much like OPS in baseball) in 2016 and eighth in 2017.  Despite the loss of seven starters, SBNation/Football Outsiders numbers projected a third-straight top 10 unit...
COMMENTARY: Big Ten realignment a solution for a problem that does not exist
COMMENTARY: Big Ten realignment a solution for a problem that does not exist

Jim Delany said last week the Big Ten has had discussions about realigning or eliminating its divisions.  Let’s be clear: Neither should happen.  Concerns about imbalance existed since the (welcome) switch to geographical divisions in 2014, but they ignored the possible positive outcome that has come to pass in four of the five...
HS Scores 12/11: Herbert leads Beavercreek in win

Alter 56, LaSalle 49: Uhl (A) 23; Lemons (L) 16 Carlisle 66, Milton Union 44: Gay (C) 19, Stone (MU) 12. Beavercreek 60, Fairborn 57: Herbert (B) 18; Monore (F) 32 Catholic Central 55, Greeneview 34: Doolittle (S) 20; Caudill (G) 14. Fairbanks 85, Triad 56: Hackathorne (F) 15; Bundy (T) 11. Fort Loramie 47, Houston 40: Brandewie (F) 13; Leist (H) 11...
More Stories