Michigan football: Jim McElwain isn’t a good fit for Wolverines

During the week, Land of 10 reporters following the Wolverines answer questions on the minds of Michigan fans. Submit a question or suggest a topic by sending a tweet here to Rachel Lenzi. Check back Monday through Friday as we answer the Michigan Question of the Day. Go here to see our previous answers. 

Jim McElwain, the former Florida coach, will join the Michigan coaching staff. I’m not a fan of this potential hire. McElwain needs this job more than Michigan needs McElwain.

FootballScoop.com reported Wednesday evening that Michigan will offer McElwain a job as an assistant, and that McElwain is expected to accept the position.

If McElwain takes this job, he fills the slot that Dan Enos vacated when he left the Wolverines to join Nick Saban’s staff at Alabama. McElwain’s background is coaching quarterbacks, wide receivers and special teams.

That only adds to the problem that the Wolverines’ offense has: There are too many voices in the conversation. If he joins the offensive staff, McElwain would just be another sound that reverberates in the echo chamber.

McElwain was Alabama’s offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach from 2008 to 2011. He became coach at Colorado State in 2012, then took over at Florida in December 2014. But he couldn’t transform Florida with a much different set of personnel, and with Doug Nussmeier (remember him?) as Florida’s offensive coordinator, either. In McElwain’s 2½ seasons at Florida, the Gators finished no higher than 12th in total offense in the SEC. Somehow, Florida won the SEC East in 2015 and 2016 … but lost twice to Michigan.

The mark of a quality coach is what he can do with his athletes and their skill set. Florida’s players didn’t have the same skill set as those at Alabama. The Gators couldn’t produce, so it’s puzzling why the Wolverines targeted McElwain for an opening.

Hiring McElwain would be a move that comes out of convenience, rather than making a smart fit. There are better fits for the Wolverines.

Here’s a different option. Instead of simply plugging a hole with a coach such as McElwain, Michigan needs to make a hire where it needs help the most: on the offensive line. The most practical move is to give Ed Warinner, who recently  was  hired at Michigan as an analyst, the job of coaching the offensive line.

Read more answers to questions about the Michigan Wolverines here

The post Michigan football: Jim McElwain isn’t a good fit for Wolverines appeared first on Land of 10.

Thank you for reading the Springfield News-Sun and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to your daily ePaper and premium newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Springfield News-Sun. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.

X