US lawsuit: Venezuela cheated of billions by rigged oil bids

A trust linked to Venezuelan state oil company PDVSA has filed a lawsuit against Glencore, Lukoil and other energy trading firms for their alleged role funneling bribes to corrupt company officials in exchange for rigged oil purchase and sale contracts.

The civil complaint was unsealed Thursday by a federal judge in Miami and alleges the ongoing scheme cheated the socialist-run company of billions in lost revenue since 2004.

The lawsuit comes as the U.S. expands its own criminal investigation into corruption at PDVSA. At least $11 billion is believed to have gone missing from the company in the past decade, according to a 2016 report by the opposition-led National Assembly, and among those prosecutors believe took bribes is the country's former oil czar Rafael Ramirez, who was not named in the new lawsuit.

The scheme to fix prices, rig bids and eliminate competition, as well as steal highly-confidential information by cloning the company's servers, was allegedly started by two former PDVSA traders, Francisco Morillo and Leonardo Baquero. Swiss-based Glencore and Russia's Lukoil are named as among more than 40 defendants including rogue traders at multinational traders, shell companies, mid-level PDVSA officials and a Florida bank.

In 2004, the two Venezuelan men established in Panama a consulting firm, Helsinge Inc., which also had offices in Miami, Geneva and the British channel island of Jersey. The company was the conduit by which some of PDVSA's biggest clients and supplier allegedly obtained insider information on PDVSA's tenders for the sale of its oil exports as well as the purchase of the light crude with which Venezuela refines its heavy crude.

Among other illicit activities, a "clone server" was allegedly installed at Helsinge's Miami offices by a PDVSA IT administrator nicknamed "the Nerd" to give the middleman and their clients real-time access to information on competing bids and future tenders.

In exchange for the sneak peak and other unfair advantages, Helsinge — which was not authorized to transact directly with PDVSA — allegedly charged monthly retainers from the international oil companies of $15,000 to $150,000 plus added compensation of up to $0.22 per barrel of oil product bought or sold. Some of that money was paid out from Panamanian shell companies in the form of bribes to four PDVSA managers, one of whom, Ysmael Serrano, currently heads the company's commercial and supply department, according to the lawsuit.

An email sent through the website of Helsinge, which does not list a phone number or address for the company, went unanswered.

Glencore and Lukoil did not immediately comment. There is no evidence the companies encouraged the corrupt dealings, except for communications between Helsinge and traders for the oil companies discussing wire transfers and ways to change the terms of future tenders before they are released to the general market.

PDVSA also did not comment.

Last month, prosecutors in Houston unsealed charges against five former senior officials, including a deputy oil minister, for bribe-taking. The indictment alleges Ramirez was one of the recipients of the illegal payments. Ramirez left the U.S. for an undisclosed location after resigning as ambassador to the United Nations in December and has since been targeted by a separate corruption probe in Venezuela.

The evidence in the lawsuit was partly collected by a former Scotland Yard investigator hired by the trust who had access to PDVSA's servers in Caracas last year. It's also based on damaging emails, banking records and instant messages provided by Morillo's estranged wife — some of which are included in the complaint — detailing how the alleged conspiracy was carried out.

The trust is represented by attorneys from Boies Schiller Flexner, the same New York law firm defending Venezuelan First Lady Cilia Flores' nephews in a federal drug-trafficking case.


AP Writer Scott Smith contributed to this report.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Nation World

Soaring health costs prompt employer-hospital surgery deals
Soaring health costs prompt employer-hospital surgery deals

As the cost of health care continues to rise, large employers seeking to hold down health care costs are starting to negotiate fixed-price deals for common surgeries. Companies that self fund their health insurance benefits can pay as much for health care as they pay some of their large suppliers. But with suppliers, employers can compare costs and...
MMA fighter wins bout when opponent knocks himself out
MMA fighter wins bout when opponent knocks himself out

Caleb Williams did not have exert too much energy during his MMA match against Matt McCook on Saturday. McCook did all the work, inadvertently knocking himself out with a face plant after a hip toss went awry, Bleacher Report reported. The two fighters were competing at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino in Hollywood, Florida. Williams...
United, Delta partnerships making Dayton hub for aviation education
United, Delta partnerships making Dayton hub for aviation education

New partnerships between major airlines and local schools and organizations are aimed at growing the pool of STEM-educated graduates for the aviation job market. United Airlines is making significant donations to support Air Camp Inc., a Dayton-area not-for-profit that has grown substantially since its first camp in 2010. In addition to flying in students...
Excellence in Teaching: Enon Primary teacher loves community
Excellence in Teaching: Enon Primary teacher loves community

Enon Primary School teacher Carrie Hall has known she was going to be a teacher her entire life. “It’s never really even been a choice,” Hall said. “I have known since I was probably 3 that it was what I was going to do. I know that is unusual but it’s a blessing.” MORE: Excellence in Teaching: Springfield CTC teacher...
Medical marijuana troubles Ohio doctors: ‘Although it’s natural, (it’s) not like a vitamin’
Medical marijuana troubles Ohio doctors: ‘Although it’s natural, (it’s) not like a vitamin’

Almost daily, Dr. Gogi Kumar is questioned at Dayton Children’s Hospital about medical marijuana by concerned parents of children who suffer from seizures. Kumar is not alone in the curiosity she receives from patients about Ohio’s confusing medical marijuana program that is expected to begin in September. Doctors told this newspaper they...
More Stories