Why some people care more about dogs than humans


To most dog owners, Fido isn’t just a four-legged roommate − he’s family. But do people love their pets more than other people?

>> Read more trending news

According to new research from Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts and the University of Colorado in Boulder, Colorado, some people really do feel more for dogs, at least in some cases.

The research, recently published in the journal Society and Animals, includes survey data from 256 mostly white undergraduate students, who read fake news stories with police reports of either a brutally beaten dog, puppy, human, child, infant or human adult.

>> Related: Research shows why kids feel the loss of a pet so deeply

In one experiment, students read reports of a victim (either a one-year-old baby, 30-year-old adult, a puppy or a six-year-old dog) left unconscious with a broken leg and multiple lacerations after being attacked with a baseball bat by an unknown assailant.

The students were then asked to answer questions that measured their empathy toward the victims.

>> Related: Is your dog trying to manipulate you with those adorable puppy dog eyes?

The findings showed that people have more empathy for battered and hurt puppies and full-grown dogs than they do for human adults.

“Subjects did not view their dogs as animals, but rather as 'fur babies,' or family members alongside human children,” the researchers concluded.

But empathy levels for human children, the researchers found, were similar to those for puppies and adult dogs.

Female participants were more likely to be empathetic toward all of the victims compared to their male counterparts.

>> Related: This Texas woman’s heart literally broke when her dog died, doctors say

“Contrary to popular thinking, we are not necessarily more disturbed by animal rather than human suffering,” study author Jack Levin said in a news release. “Our results indicate a much more complex situation with respect to the age and species of victims, with age being the more important component.”

Additionally, Levin said, the students viewed adult humans as “capable of protecting themselves,” but full-grown dogs were just considered larger puppies.

Limitations

The study had a small, homogeneous sample of mostly white undergraduate students, which Levin said is common practice for his studies that center around an experiment. 

>> Related: Ever wonder why dogs are so darn friendly? Science says it’s in their genes

“Unlike survey research, experiments usually employ a homogenous sample in order to establish a cause and effect relationship rather than to generalize a large population,” he said. “However, there is really no reason to believe that our results would differ very much nationally, particularly among college students.”

Homogenous sampling is normally used when the research goal is to understand and describe a particular group, according to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

>> Related: 7 dog hacks for pet parents in the city 

But homogeneous samples can potentially “eliminate noise due to variation in one or more sociodemographic factors,” research from the National Institutes of Health found.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Junk food linked to higher risk of cancer, study says
Junk food linked to higher risk of cancer, study says

It’s no secret junk food is bad for your health. In fact, too much of it can increase your risk of several diseases, including cancer, according to a new report. >> Read more trending news  Researchers from health institutions in France recently conducted a study, published in the PLOS journal, to explore the link between cancer...
Trooper on I-70 Fatal Crash: ‘You have no chance against a car like that’
Trooper on I-70 Fatal Crash: ‘You have no chance against a car like that’

The Ohio State Highway Patrol is asking anyone who has information about the fatal pedestrian strike on I-70 near South Vienna — to come forward. The accident killed a 51-year-old Columbus man, identified as Bradley Liebling. OSP Springfield Post Commander Lt. Brian Aller, said they do not have a description of the suspect or a description of...
Jury awards boy $30 million in botched circumcision; award could increase
Jury awards boy $30 million in botched circumcision; award could increase

A jury in Clayton County, Georgia has awarded a boy $30 million for a botched circumcision, and the award could rise even higher as deliberations continue. >> Read more trending news  The verdict came down in the first phase of deliberations Friday, and the jury is expected to deliberate over whether to grant punitive damages, according...
Man suspected of threatening President Trump arrested after 3-month manhunt
Man suspected of threatening President Trump arrested after 3-month manhunt

A fugitive suspected of threatening President Trump has been arrested by police after a three-month manhunt. Shawn Christy, 26, was taken into custody Friday afternoon, the U.S. Marshals Service told WPXI. The federal agency said Christy was arrested in Mifflin Township, near Columbus, by marshals and task force members from Ohio and Pennsylvania...
Springfield CultureFest: Festival’s foods offer taste of the world
Springfield CultureFest: Festival’s foods offer taste of the world

CultureFest offers a slice of more than 20 cultures in one location. To really experience it, just take a bite. Hot dogs, Hungarian cabbage rolls and mango lassi are just a sample of the diverse foods available at the 22nd annual CultureFest, 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Saturday, Sept. 22 at City Hall Plaza. “Food is very much a part of CultureFest,&rdquo...
More Stories