Her case garnered national attention, sparking conversations about black women and girls and the criminal justice system.
About the case
On July 28, 2016, Meadows shot her father Jonathan Meadows in the head while he was sleeping at their home, according to a police report. Her mother Brandi Meadows called 911, and the police arrived shortly and arrested Bresha. Jonathan's death was ruled a homicide.
The teenager, along with her two siblings and mother, said her father was physically and verbally abusive and often threatened the family with the same gun Bresha used to shoot him. Her mother called her a hero.
"She helped me; she helped all of us so we could have a better life," Brandi told Cleveland's WJW at the time.
Family reaction
“From day one, she was born into a nightmare,” Martina Latessa, a Cleveland officer and Bresha’s aunt on her mother’s side, told WJW. “She was begging me for help. She was very, very scared for her mother and sisters.”
Sheri Latessa, another aunt, also alleged that Jonathan was abusive and said Bresha had once run away from home, according to WKBN.
Jonathan's siblings, however, called Bresha a murderer, according to WFMJ.
“She had ran away from home because she was doing things that a 14-year-old should not be doing. So she’s not a hero. She’s a murderer. She killed my brother. This was cold, calculated. He was killed in his sleep, and the family is doing everything they can to discredit my brother, and it’s not fair,” Lena Cooper, Jonathan’s sister, told WFMJ.
How did the legal system handle the case?
Prosecutors charged Bresha with aggravated murder and attempted to try her as an adult. If convicted as an adult, she could have faced life in prison without parole. She was ultimately tried as a child, and in May, she pleaded true to a charge of involuntary manslaughter, which is the equivalent of guilty in juvenile court.
She was ordered to serve one year in a juvenile detention center and six months at a mental health facility. She also received two years of probation. Earlier this year, she was released to her family’s care. When she becomes 21, her record will be sealed and expunged.
Activists respond
Organizers raised more than $150,000 for Bresha and her family on a GoFundMe page. The hashtag #FreeBresha was also created to advocate for her. Many wrote letters and started petitions, demanding Bresha's release.
"Bresha should never have been incarcerated, but it is a win nonetheless," organizers Mariame Kaba and Colby Lenz wrote in a Teen Vogue op-ed published after Bresha returned home. "Bresha's case also reminds us why we all must work to develop and practice transformative solutions to violence that do not rely on carceral systems, including policing, prosecution, and prisons."
About the Author