According to deputies, Bilotta and McClurg believed Barnes, their recently evicted former roommate, returned to the home to steal a PlayStation console. The suspects lured him to the home by telling him they were having a party and stabbed him to death, deputies said.
>> Read more trending news
As the two were about to wrap the victim in plastic bags to dispose of the body, deputies said the pair's new roommate returned with a Tinder date and discovered what happened. That roommate fled and called 911, deputies said.
Previous coverage: Men lured former roommate to kill him over stolen PlayStation, deputies say
The newly filed paperwork seeking the death penalty against Bilotta said prosecutors believe that Bilotta alone stabbed Barnes, while McClurg "abandoned the plan and did not participate."
McClurg is charged with conspiracy to commit capital murder, tampering with evidence and accessory after the fact to first-degree murder.
Prosecutors said the murder was "especially heinous, atrocious, or cruel," and that it was "committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner," according to the notice that seeks the death penalty for Bilotta.
In January, the Seminole County Sheriff's Office said it was asking Facebook to provide access to Instagram Direct messages sent between Bilotta, McClurg and Barnes.
Bilotta and McClurg remain in the Seminole County Jail. The next time they are scheduled to appear in court is March 6.