Florida scientist makes case for upgrading Pluto to planet status again


A scientist at the University of Central Florida is making a case to put Pluto back in the big leagues. 

>> Read more trending news 

Planetary science professor Philip Metzger loves rocks--particularly the one that is 4.6 billion miles away from Earth. 

“It's the most geologically active planet besides the Earth. There are flowing glaciers (and) moving mountains. It is possible, at least possible, that Pluto might have life,” Metzger said. 

Read: Pluto explorer spots next destination billion miles beyond

But little Pluto was reduced to a “dwarf planet” in 2006 when the International Astronomical Union voted that it wasn't big enough to clear debris from its orbit.

"I think, unfortunately, the textbooks have short-changed Pluto and the entire solar system,” Metzger said. 

Metzger and his team of researchers from Johns Hopkins and the Planetary Science Institute researched 200 years of data analyzing the “clearing of orbit” criteria for a planet, and found only one study in 1802 used that definition and it was later disproved.

"They didn't bother to explain what they mean by clearing orbit, and taking it literally, it's true. No planet clears its orbit, so therefore there are no planets,” Metzger said. 

>> Related: Dunes on Pluto made of tiny frozen grains of methane

For scientists, icy Pluto is a hot debate.

Thousands have chimed in on both sides on social media about Metzger’s research.

For Metzger though, the problem isn't Pluto, it's that defining it came down to a vote based on opinions. 

"When we published this paper, the outpouring of public interest was amazing, everybody is saying, ‘Yeah, save Pluto! We want our Pluto back!’” he said. 

Metzger’s work was peer-reviewed and will be published in the scientific journal Icarus.

>> Related: Dunes on Pluto made of tiny frozen grains of methane

Meanwhile, the two scientists who self-claim they "killed Pluto" as a planet continue to stand by their research.

The IAU has not received a motion for changing Pluto's definition, but said it is good and healthy to debate.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Police warn parents after finding drugs designed to look like candy
Police warn parents after finding drugs designed to look like candy

Police are warning parents after confiscating drugs stamped to look like candy in the shape of animated characters. >> Read more trending news  Hapeville police recovered two guns, one of which was stolen, cash and drugs in a raid Friday.  “The pills and lollipops are designed to look like candy,” officials said in...
Tiger Woods: Some fun facts to know
Tiger Woods: Some fun facts to know

Tiger Woods ended a five-year victory drought when he won the Tour Championship on Sunday. >> Read more trending news  By finishing two shots ahead of Billy Horschel with a 1-over-par 71 and an 11-under-par 269 for the tournament, Woods earned his 80th career win on the PGA Tour, second only behind Sam Snead’s 82. It was Woods&rsquo...
Tour Championship: Woods by a whisker
Tour Championship: Woods by a whisker

Tiger Woods clawed his way to the Tour Championship, clinging to the lead all day and surviving a couple of rattling back-nine bogies. >> Read more trending news  Woods led by as many as five strokes on the final round but saw his lead cut to two strokes. He ended the day two shots over Billy Horschel. The throng cheered him up the fairway...
Kettering abortion provider appeals ruling that would force closure
Kettering abortion provider appeals ruling that would force closure

The Dayton-area’s lone abortion provider has appealed a Montgomery County judge’s decision in late August to uphold a state ruling that would force its closure. The clinic is expected to remain open during the appeal process, lawyers for Women’s Med said. MORE: These local fire departments are looking for more full-timers, matching...
Kettering facility hoping legislation can provide financial boost
Kettering facility hoping legislation can provide financial boost

A local facility that specializes in the treatment of babies experiencing withdrawal could get a financial boost from legislation that passed in the U.S. Senate this week. Brigid’s Path, which recently celebrated its one-year anniversary at 3601 S Dixie Dr., is not eligible to receive Medicaid reimbursement. It relies heavily on donations from...
More Stories