Florida scientist makes case for upgrading Pluto to planet status again


A scientist at the University of Central Florida is making a case to put Pluto back in the big leagues. 

>> Read more trending news 

Planetary science professor Philip Metzger loves rocks--particularly the one that is 4.6 billion miles away from Earth. 

“It's the most geologically active planet besides the Earth. There are flowing glaciers (and) moving mountains. It is possible, at least possible, that Pluto might have life,” Metzger said. 

Read: Pluto explorer spots next destination billion miles beyond

But little Pluto was reduced to a “dwarf planet” in 2006 when the International Astronomical Union voted that it wasn't big enough to clear debris from its orbit.

"I think, unfortunately, the textbooks have short-changed Pluto and the entire solar system,” Metzger said. 

Metzger and his team of researchers from Johns Hopkins and the Planetary Science Institute researched 200 years of data analyzing the “clearing of orbit” criteria for a planet, and found only one study in 1802 used that definition and it was later disproved.

"They didn't bother to explain what they mean by clearing orbit, and taking it literally, it's true. No planet clears its orbit, so therefore there are no planets,” Metzger said. 

>> Related: Dunes on Pluto made of tiny frozen grains of methane

For scientists, icy Pluto is a hot debate.

Thousands have chimed in on both sides on social media about Metzger’s research.

For Metzger though, the problem isn't Pluto, it's that defining it came down to a vote based on opinions. 

"When we published this paper, the outpouring of public interest was amazing, everybody is saying, ‘Yeah, save Pluto! We want our Pluto back!’” he said. 

Metzger’s work was peer-reviewed and will be published in the scientific journal Icarus.

>> Related: Dunes on Pluto made of tiny frozen grains of methane

Meanwhile, the two scientists who self-claim they "killed Pluto" as a planet continue to stand by their research.

The IAU has not received a motion for changing Pluto's definition, but said it is good and healthy to debate.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Nearly 100,000 pounds ground beef recalled over E. coli fears just before Thanksgiving
Nearly 100,000 pounds ground beef recalled over E. coli fears just before Thanksgiving

Utah-based Swift Beef Co. is recalling 99,260 pounds of raw ground beef products over possible E. coli contamination just in time for Thanksgiving, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. >> Read more trending news  The meat products were produced late last month and the potential contamination was confirmed last week. The products...
Which grocery stores are open on Thanksgiving Day 2018?
Which grocery stores are open on Thanksgiving Day 2018?

Even the best of cooks can end up missing an ingredient on Thanksgiving morning.  If you find yourself short on nutmeg or minus a few potatoes, there is a good chance a grocery store near you will be open on Thanksgiving for at least for part of the day. Here is a list of Thanksgiving Day openings, closings and store hours for national grocery...
Body of missing North Carolina teacher recovered in Mexico
Body of missing North Carolina teacher recovered in Mexico

The body of a missing North Carolina teacher, who disappeared while hiking in Mexico, has been recovered, according to a Facebook page that was dedicated to the search for Patrick Braxton-Andrew. >> Read more trending news  "It is with a sense of relief that we are able to confirm that Patrick's body has been recovered and we will be...
Train derailment forces town to evacuate, damages state highway
Train derailment forces town to evacuate, damages state highway

A train derailed south of Macon, Georgia, forcing residents in one town to evacuate.  >> Read more trending news  The train went of the CSX line and onto Georgia 90 near Byromville around 7:00 a.m. Saturday morning. Residents within a half mile of the crash were evacuated because some of the cars were pressurized propane cars. ...
In rare admission, Trump says he regrets missing Veterans Day services at Arlington
In rare admission, Trump says he regrets missing Veterans Day services at Arlington

In a rare admission of fault, President Donald Trump said on “Fox News Sunday” that he made a mistake and regretted missing the Veterans Day services at Arlington National Cemetery last week. >> Read more trending news    “I should have done that. I was extremely busy on calls for the country. We did a lot of...
More Stories