National Geographic confronts its past: 'For Decades, Our Coverage Was Racist'

Months ago, when National Geographic set out to make race the sole focus of its April 2018 issue, it decided to engage in some soul-searching.

For much of its 130-year history, the magazine depicted people of color in crude stereotypes. Its archives are loaded with pictures of brown-skinned "natives" gazing in apparent awe at Western technology, articles referring to tribal peoples as "savages," and of course many, many photos of bare-breasted Pacific island women striking vaguely seductive poses. Those glossy Geographics, stacked up in attics and basements, were favorites of more than a few curious young boys — with little interest in New Guinea or Polynesia.

So in preparation for its examination of race, National Geographic editor in chief Susan Goldberg tapped John Edwin Mason, a University of Virginia professor specializing in the history of photography and the history of Africa, to dive into the magazine's past. On Monday, she discussed his findings in an editor's note.

"What Mason found in short was that until the 1970s National Geographic all but ignored people of color who lived in the United States, rarely acknowledging them beyond laborers or domestic workers," Goldberg wrote. "Meanwhile it pictured 'natives' elsewhere as exotics, famously and frequently unclothed, happy hunters, noble savages — every type of cliche."

The title of Goldberg's piece put it more bluntly: "For Decades, Our Coverage Was Racist. To Rise Above Our Past, We Must Acknowledge It."

It was an extraordinary concession from the magazine. Renowned for its photography and its coverage of science, history, anthropology and the environment, National Geographic has also faced criticism over the years for reporting on the world through a narrow white, Western lens.

Breanna Edwards of the African American-focused news and culture site The Root called the move "the first step to righting a long-overlooked and perhaps even taken-for-granted wrong."

"Bluntly acknowledging its own past in this way is indeed powerful, but it is not necessarily something, I think, that we should applaud, as much as we should expect," Edwards wrote, "especially at this time in our lives when race and discussions of racism and even general cultural insensitivity can be volatile, tense and perhaps even deadly."

Others were more critical, including Vox's Kainaz Amaria, who tweeted that the magazine's "colonial visual legacy" had, in effect, trained nonwhite, non-Western people to allow themselves to be "exploited and otherized."

Mason, the professor, touched on a similar point in an interview with NPR on Monday. He said a number of African photographers were drawn into photography by what they saw in National Geographic's pages, even though it was racially and culturally insensitive.

"They knew that there were problems with the way that they and their people were being represented," Mason told NPR. "And yet the photography was often spectacularly good, it was really inviting, and it carried this power. And as young people, these men and women said, I want to do that. I want to make pictures like that."

Goldberg noted that she is the first woman and the first Jewish person to serve as editor in chief, so she's sensitive, she said, to the magazine's legacy of discrimination.

"It hurts to share the appalling stories from the magazine's past," she wrote. "But when we decided to devote our April magazine to the topic of race, we thought we should examine our own history before turning our reportorial gaze on others."

She highlighted several examples of racist content the magazine published over the course of several decades. In one instance, National Geographic in 1916 ran an article that called Aboriginal Australians "blackfellows" who "rank lowest in intelligence of all human beings." A 1941 piece used a racial slur to describe black California cotton workers. And a 1962 photo depicted a white photographer showing his camera to a group of Timorese men.

"The native person fascinated by Western technology" was a recurring theme, Mason told National Geographic. "It really creates this us-and-them dichotomy between the civilized and the uncivilized."

Goldberg and Mason also found that National Geographic was racist in what it omitted from its coverage. A 1962 story on South Africa quoted no black South Africans, nor did it mention the massacre of 69 black people by police in Sharpeville 2 1/2 years earlier.

"That absence is as important as what is in there," Mason said in Goldberg's piece. "The only black people are doing exotic dances . . . servants or workers. It's bizarre, actually, to consider what the editors, writers, and photographers had to consciously not see."

Until the 1970s, National Geographic did little to challenge stereotypes in white American culture, Mason found.

"National Geographic wasn't teaching as much as reinforcing messages they already received and doing so in a magazine that had tremendous authority," he said. "National Geographic comes into existence at the height of colonialism, and the world was divided into the colonizers and the colonized. That was a color line, and National Geographic was reflecting that view of the world."

As for the bare-breasted island women the magazine regularly featured in glossy, full-color photos: "I think the editors understood this was frankly a selling point to its male readers," Mason told NPR.

Goldberg said the magazine has improved in recent years - in part by putting cameras in the hands of the people who were often on the other side of the lens. In one project in 2015, for example, the magazine gave cameras to young Haitians and asked them to shoot pictures of their world. That would have been "unthinkable" in National Geographic's past, Mason said.

Goldberg said she wants to continue on that course by hiring more diverse journalists at the magazine.

"The coverage wasn't right before because it was told from an elite, white American point of view, and I think it speaks to exactly why we needed a diversity of storytellers," Goldberg told the Associated Press. "So we need photographers who are African-American and Native American because they are going to capture a different truth and maybe a more accurate story."

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in News

12-year-old boy missing after getting on wrong school bus
12-year-old boy missing after getting on wrong school bus

A 12-year-old boy disappeared after getting on the wrong school bus on his way home from middle school in metro Atlanta.    >> Read more trending news  Anthony Randolph III disappeared Wednesday after boarding the wrong bus at Redan Middle School in DeKlab County, police said. Investigators said the boy got off the bus two miles...
Legendary rocker Bruce Springsteen extends successful Broadway run through December
Legendary rocker Bruce Springsteen extends successful Broadway run through December

Legendary rocker Bruce Springsteen is doing so well on Broadway, he’s staying for the rest of the year. >> Read more trending news  The veteran musician’s mega-successful one-man show, “Springsteen on Broadway,” has already been extended twice. Now, The Boss has decided to add 81 more shows between July 10 and Dec...
Soaps and paint pollute air as much as car emissions, study shows
Soaps and paint pollute air as much as car emissions, study shows

For many years, motor vehicle emissions were the primary source of air pollution in urban areas. But with increased regulations and better engines, that has changed. While industry professionals and government leaders worked to address pollution from cars, little notice was given to the effects of other commonly used consumer products. Now...
Missing Iowa family of 4 found dead in Mexico
Missing Iowa family of 4 found dead in Mexico

A Creston, Iowa, family of four that was previously reported missing in Mexico has been found dead. KCCI reported that 41-year-old Kevin Sharp, his wife, 38-year-old Amy Sharp, and their children, 12-year-old Sterling and 7-year-old Adrianna were found dead on a tourist condo complex in Tulum, Mexico, a tourist area. The Associated Press reported...
Martin Luther King Jr.: How the world heard the news of his assassination
Martin Luther King Jr.: How the world heard the news of his assassination

April 4 will mark the 50th anniversary of the day Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in Memphis, Tennessee. King, the leader of the non-violent movement for civil rights in the 1960s, had come to Memphis the day before to help sanitation workers rally for better wages and safer working conditions. That evening, as King stood on a balcony at...
More Stories