Top French court nixes ruling on faulty breast implants


France's highest court overturned Wednesday an appeals court ruling that would have required some 1,700 women in multiple countries to pay back compensation they received over rupture-prone breast implants.

The decision by the Court of Cassation means the years long case involving German products-testing company TUV Rheinland must be retried. The company initially was ordered to pay damages of 5.7 million euros (currently $6.5 million) to the women.

TUV Rheinland said in a statement that the company was not at fault and had "performed its mission ... diligently and in total compliance with the applicable regulations." It said it was "serene" about the ruling.

While 1,700 women are directly affected by the decision, the French high court's ruling could have fallout for thousands more seeking damages from TUV Rheinland in other lawsuits.

The legal drama involves tens of thousands of women from Europe and South America who received the faulty implants, which were made with industrial-grade silicone instead of medical silicone. The scandal helped lead to tougher European medical device regulations.

The manufacturer of the implants, French company Poly Implant Prothese, or PIP, was convicted of fraud. But the bankrupt manufacturer couldn't pay damages to the women with often painful, leaky implants. They sought compensation from TUV Rheinland instead, arguing it should have never certified the product in the first place.

The ruling issued Wednesday overturned a 2015 decision from an appeals court in Aix-en-Provence that the German company was not liable for the faulty implants and the women had to pay back the damages.

The Court of Cassation concluded otherwise, ruling that "vigilance" is "an obligation." Evidence of potential problems with a medical device means a company like TUV Rheinland "must take all needed measures," including conducting surprise visits to manufacturers.

TUV Rheinland lawyer Cecile Derycke said the company has paid 5.7 million euros ($6.5 million) overall to the women involved in the French court case, many of them living in Colombia but also around Europe and elsewhere.

Derycke argued that TUV Rheinland was unfairly held responsible for PIP's wrongdoing.

A lawyer representing women with the implants, Olivier Aumaitre, warned before the ruling that if no one were held responsible for the defective implants, Europe's consumer product certification system was meaningless.

"We're in a new phase of the process," Aumaitre said after the decision. "Until now, there was a period of doubt." He said the high court clarified what the appeals court had ignored.


Reader Comments


Next Up in Health

Christmas 2018: 20 darling couples gifts that your daughter-in-law will actually like
Christmas 2018: 20 darling couples gifts that your daughter-in-law will actually like

When your adult child gets married, you double the holiday fun if you're lucky. But you also multiply the gift-giving quandaries.  After all, you've had a whole lifetime to get to know your child's gift preferences. Working another person into the equation can be an occasion for advice-column-level misunderstandings, burst budgets and a new family...
Ohio small businesses may get more access to employee health data
Ohio small businesses may get more access to employee health data

A proposed Ohio law could help small businesses shop for affordable health insurance by letting them see details on expensive health insurance claims, though critics say it would violate employee medical privacy. For employees with a claim that’s $30,000 or more, Senate Bill 227 will allow insurers to provide companies the amount paid toward...
The best handmade gifts we discovered at Urban Handmade
The best handmade gifts we discovered at Urban Handmade

Urban Handmade in Yellow Springs carries work from more than 70 artists and makers specializing in jewelry, accessories, home decor, clothing, handbags, paper goods, bath and body, original art and more.  Their slogan is "power to the artists" and based on the contents of their shop they believe it.  The downtown Yellow Springs...
What is Kwanzaa? 7 enlightening facts about the holiday
What is Kwanzaa? 7 enlightening facts about the holiday

In 2018, Kwanzaa celebrates its 52nd anniversary but compared to its more popular counterparts, it is relatively unknown.  Here are a few facts to help anyone that is curious and considering celebrating this holiday. Karenga, born Ron Everett, created the holiday during a particularly tumultuous time in American history. Karenga was a member of...
Meet the University of Dayton graduate who is in charge of the Grammy Museum
Meet the University of Dayton graduate who is in charge of the Grammy Museum

Michael Sticka’s love of the arts and dedication to community, two significant attributes instilled in him while growing up in Xenia and memorably co-founding imaginatively whimsical Zoot Theatre Company, is serving him well in his duties as Executive Director of the Recording Academy’s Grammy Museum, one of the most prestigious cultural...
More Stories