Springfield teen guilty of killing brother: Crime scene a ‘horror movie’

The teenager who was 16 when prosecutors say he killed his younger brother has pleaded guilty to murder.

Nicholas Starling, who was accused of stabbing and beating his 14-year-old brother with a baseball bat to death in October 2016, was sentenced last week to 15 years to life in prison, according to court documents.

The violent slaying of Harley Starling resembled something out of a horror movie and is the worst child-on-child crime Clark County Prosecutor Andy Wilson has ever prosecuted, he said.

RELATED: Springfield teen accused of killing brother ruled competent

“It was up close, it was personal, if you think about it,” Wilson said. “He took that bat and you know he was feeling the shock of that bat as he hit his brother in the head with it. And to finish him off he walks into the kitchen and grabs a knife and plunges that knife into his brother’s throat.”

Jim Marshall, Clark County public defender and Nicholas’ attorney, didn’t return a call from the Springfield News-Sun seeking comment Tuesday.

Harley was found dead in his bed by his grandmother at his Superior Avenue home on the morning of Oct. 31, 9-1-1 audio recordings indicate.

Detectives and prosecutors quickly connected the murder to Nicholas Starling, Wilson said, but they still can’t find a direct motive.

DETAILS: Springfield nursing home cited 31 times on health inspections

“The question was always why would he do something like that,” Wilson said. “We will never get the answer to that. Clearly, this is a very disturbed young man and we hope that the parole board, when he eventually does come up for parole, looks very seriously at what he’s done.”

Springfield Police Division Detective Ron Jordan testified in an earlier court hearing that Nicholas Starling said he and his brother had been in a previous argument over Halloween candy.

MORE: Candlelight vigil honors slain Springfield teen

The two might have been fighting over Halloween candy, Wilson said, but investigators couldn’t directly link the fight to the killing.

“We never could figure out why he did what he did,” he said.

The older brother’s tough upbringing might have played a role, Wilson said. The teen’s father was murdered two years before and his mother was in and out of the boys’ lives, Wilson said.

Another possible reason was the teen’s interest, Wilson said.

“He seemed to be researching the occult, the Insane Clown Posse,” Wilson said. “He was very into some satanic worship and that kind of stuff. We were never able to prove a direct link between why he did what he did and his interests, but it piles on for how disturbed this kid is.”

But that doesn’t excuse him from the consequences of the violent murder, Wilson said, and Nicholas Starling wasn’t criminally insane at the time of the slaying.

TRENDING STORY: Family: Attempted robbery led to shooting of Springfield teen

“Anyone who could do something like this is ill,” he said. “You have to be a sick person to do what he did but that doesn’t mean you are criminally insane. It is very clear from the evidence that when he murdered his brother he was certainly able to appreciate the wrongness of his actions.”

Nicholas took steps to cover up what he did, Wilson said, including hiding the bat and knife and trying to make it look like a suicide.

Reader Comments

Next Up in Crime

Teen daughter raising money to buy wheelchair for paralyzed mother 
Teen daughter raising money to buy wheelchair for paralyzed mother 

A teen daughter is trying to raise money to help her paraplegic mother get an upright wheelchair.  >> Read more trending news  Kariyana Fields has been working and saving money each week to buy a standing electric wheelchair, which costs about $8,500 and is not covered under insurance, WWL reported.  Kariyana has written letters...
2018 Ohio governor’s race most expensive ever
2018 Ohio governor’s race most expensive ever

The 2018 race for governor between Republican Mike DeWine and Democrat Richard Cordray set a new record for most expensive governor’s race in Ohio history: $43.5 million raised between the two campaigns. That easily outstrips the previous record of $30.4 million set in 2010. In 2017-18, DeWine, who is currently attorney general, raised $24...
Children greet trash collector with cookies, Mountain Dew; he surprises them with toy garbage trucks
Children greet trash collector with cookies, Mountain Dew; he surprises them with toy garbage trucks

Children at a Utah day care greet the garbage man each Thursday with cookies and Mountain Dew.  >> Read more trending news  Recently, trash collector Jeff Okeson had a surprise for them -- smaller, wooden toy trucks for them to keep.  "You know why I did this?" Okeson told the children, KUTV reported. "(I did...
Colin Kroll, CEO of HQ Trivia, Vine co-founder dead of alleged drug overdose, police say
Colin Kroll, CEO of HQ Trivia, Vine co-founder dead of alleged drug overdose, police say

Colin Kroll, the CEO and co-founder of HQ Trivia, an app and trivia game, has died of an alleged drug overdose. He was 35. The Daily Beast reported that a senior New York Police Department official said Kroll was found dead in his apartment late Saturday from an apparent overdose. Officials said police arrived at his apartment after his girlfriend...
Man proposes to dog-lover girlfriend with 16 pups
Man proposes to dog-lover girlfriend with 16 pups

A man took his girlfriend’s love of dogs to new heights when he proposed to her after a hike in Los Angeles. CBS News reported that Maurice Goldstein dated Laura Stampler for more than four years. Goldstein invited Stampler out for a hike in Runyon Canyon while in town for Thanksgiving. As they continued to hike, Stampler noticed rose petals...
More Stories