Anthem criticized here for cutting some non-emergency ER coverage

Anthem is being criticized for its new policy that will stop covering certain emergency department visits that the giant insurer says could have been better spent at a primary care office.

Under a new policy starting next year, the region’s largest insurer could deny claims for emergency visits determined to be for non-emergencies.

Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield currently has this program in place in Kentucky, Missouri and Georgia and is expanding it to Ohio, Indiana and New Hampshire starting in January.

LOCAL: New pet hospital opening in Dayton area

When patients are treated in ERs for cases like suture removals or seasonal allergies that could have been in primary care, it’s expensive and can raise the overall cost of health care. Anthem said it has seen a drop in unnecessary ER visits in Kentucky since it started its review there and has rejected only around 1 percent of all claims as avoidable, according to media reports.

But Ohio emergency department doctors are pushing back at Anthem, saying it can be hard for the average person to tell whether some symptoms can or can’t wait.

RELATED: Why the Premier-UHC dispute could hit region harder in 2018

Arm pain could be nothing much or it could be a sign of a heart attack. A rash could be something that could wait or it might mean endocarditis from an opioid injection.

The fear of getting stuck with the bill if they’re wrong could make some patients afraid to get the emergency care they need, argues the Ohio Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians.

“I don’t think we should be putting that onus on the patient and having these restrictions in place,” said Dr. Purva Grover, Ohio president of the physicians group.

She said ER doctors treat patients every day who have the same symptoms, but one ends up having to be admitted or need more care, while another might be able to go home.

RELATED: Dayton Children’s plans urgent care center in Huber Heights

Purva said emergency doctors “want to be good stewards of our resources and want to do the right thing for the patient” but the group hasn’t seen any specific data that would show there’s a rising number of patients using the ER for non-emergencies.

Premier Health, which operates four hospitals in the region including Miami Valley Hospital, said in a statement that it is expanding services in 2018 that include telehealth options and four new urgent care centers.

“That said, we do share many emergency physicians’ concerns that local residents, when under duress in certain circumstances, might dwell too long on where to receive care – or bypass needed emergency care altogether – due to concerns about whether their insurance carrier will cover the cost of those services,” a Premier spokesman said.

A 2013 report in the Journal of the American Medical Association found about 6.3 percent of visits had primary care treatable diagnosis. But the report also found the chief symptom complaints that were diagnosed as primary care treatable overlapped 89 percent with the chief symptom complaints that of all emergency department visits.

Mike Baldyga, spokesman for the American College of Emergency Physicians, said as far his association is aware of, Anthem is the only insurance company with this type of program.

“Our concern is that if it’s seen as successful, other insurers will follow,” he said.

Anthem spokesman Jeff Blunt said in a statement that it has seen an increase in ER visits for non-emergencies and the cost of an ER visit can be 10 times the cost of a visit to a non-emergent care provider.

RELATED: Med tech growing part of Dayton start-up scene

“Emergency rooms treat life and limb threatening situations, and if a member feels he or she has an emergency they should always call 911 or go to the ER. But for non-emergency ailments, ERs are an expensive and time-consuming place to receive care,” he said.

Blunt said primary care physicians should always be the first medical professional patients see with any non-emergencies, and there are urgent cares, telemedicine, retail clinics and Anthem’s free 24-7 nurse lines for after-hours situations.

He said Anthem will cover non-emergencies if a member was directed to the emergency room by another medical provider, if services were provided to a child under the age 14, if there isn’t an urgent care or retail clinic within 15 miles, or if the visit occurs between 8 p.m. Saturday and 8 a.m. Monday or on a major holiday.

LOCAL: Amazon grows, downtown explodes among top local 2017 business stories

Purva said using final diagnoses instead of symptoms to decide whether to cover emergency room care violates the current standard for determining whether an ER visit is justified for insurance coverage, which is whether a “prudent layperson” or a person with average health knowledge would believe their health is in serious jeopardy.

Anthem said it will use the prudent layperson standard when reviewing claims before it would deny coverage.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in News

Winter Weather Advisory issued for tonight; possible morning slick spots from overnight freezing rain
Winter Weather Advisory issued for tonight; possible morning slick spots from overnight freezing rain

Winter Weather Advisory for ALL from 8 p.m. Tuesday to 8 p.m. Wednesday Rain and freezing rain possible Tuesday morning Snow accumulates Tuesday night to Wednesday TUESDAY: Some snow showers have made their way up from the south with temperatures being at or below freezing for the morning, said Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Kirstie Zontini...
Spring 2018: 5 things to know about the vernal equinox
Spring 2018: 5 things to know about the vernal equinox

Spring is finally here with the arrival of the vernal equinox, as determined by people who base their seasons on the Earth’s position relative to the sun and stars. Here are five things to know: 1. What is it? During the vernal equinox, the sun shines directly on the equator, and the northern and southern hemispheres get exactly the same...
Air Force top civilian leader to appear at Wright-Patt
Air Force top civilian leader to appear at Wright-Patt

Secretary of the Air Force Heather Wilson will speak to the graduating class of the Air Force Institute of Technology on Thursday. The trip will mark the Air Force secretary’s second trek to Wright-Patterson since last year when she was part of a gathering of key Air Force leaders at Corona Top. She will speak to 241 graduates of AFIT’s...
Many students misbehaved this St. Patrick's Day, university president says
Many students misbehaved this St. Patrick's Day, university president says

University of Dayton students who ignored orders and acted out against police during St. Patrick’s Day activities Saturday were called out in a letter sent this morning from University President Eric F. Spina to the student body. “Today I am deeply disappointed in the behavior of many of you. I witnessed groups of students assault police...
Opinion: Let’s hope Bannon never comes back from Europe

One of the things that motivated my old friend Andrew Breitbart was his righteous indignation at being called a racist. That’s a running theme in his book, “Righteous Indignation.” “Andrew Breitbart despised racism,” his friend Ben Shapiro told me. “He took pride in rejecting racism and fighting it tooth and nail...
More Stories