Sports Today: How disappointing will the Reds be before 2017 is over? 


The Cincinnati Reds are really working hard to erase all the positives they established in the first half of the season. 

OK, that’s probably overstating it a bit. Maybe. 

RELATED: Middletown’s Schwarber helps Cubs route Reds

As things stand, they still have proven they have solid-or-better players at all eight every-day positions with Jesse Winker still a wild card and Nick Senzel on the way. 

The overburdened bullpen has had some ups and downs, but there are key pieces in place (unless those need to join the rotation in the future). 

But the starting rotation has been a disaster of unimaginable proportions. 

That is not hyperbole. I literally could not have envisioned things being this bad before actually seeing it. 

Hopes were not high for the rotation entering spring training, but reality has fallen short of even the lowest expectations. 

It was reasonable to expect the Reds to have a rotation of Anthony DeSclafani, Homer Bailey, Brandon Finnegan, Scott Feldman and any one of a few youngsters who could hopefully show more good than bad. 

Feldman has been pretty much exactly as advertised — soaking up innings while pitching slightly better than any random replacement might be — and Bailey has been all over the place. 

OK, those things can be dealt with, but getting almost literally nothing from DeSclafani and Finnegan is half of a story that is very distressing for the future. 

There is no guarantee either of those guys will be healthy in the future insofar as they are A) Pitchers, but more importantly B) Reds pitchers. 

There could be a silver lining to their missing time in what would have likely been a lost season anyway…. but none of the youngsters in the spring training mix to be that fifth starter has done anything positive this season. 

Even with a bunch of extra innings up for grabs because of those injuries almost nothing has been accomplished as far as building a rotation for the future. 

Luis Castillo, who began the season in Double-A, is the obvious exception. He looks like a potential ace, but the number of questions lingering into this point in the season is still alarmingly high. 

So Lance McCallister was probably on to something last night when he opened his show on WLW talking about having to make some moves to fix this situation. 

And in that case, there is some good news because the Reds have assets to move if they decide to go that route. 

They have a surplus of outfielders, so they could try to move a Scott Schebler for another Feldman-type or maybe get bolder and trade Winker for someone who is more like Castillo. 

Since I looked at potential trade chips around the trade deadline, Eugenio Suarez has upped his game, passing Adam Duvall and Zack Cozart to trail only Joey Votto among the team’s leaders in WAR (wins above replacement). 

Does that make Suarez an even more enticing trade chip or convince the organization to make him a pillar of the future? 

There is probably no wrong answer to that question. 

So I guess I did screw around and find a positive by the time I was done with this little activity. 

A silver lining of sorts, though not the shiniest one. 

Since looking more in-depth into the Cubs’ rebuild last year, I have become more and more convinced trying to draft a major-league rotation is a fools’ errand. 

The floor is just too low for elite young pitching prospects. The likelihood a team ends up getting nothing for its investment is too high. 

RELATED: How does the Reds’ rebuild compare to the Cubs?

That they could acquire a talent like Castillo, who was already four years into his development, for a waiver-wire pickup on his fourth major-league team furthers this theory. 

I know the Reds are not going to suddenly turn into a team that can buy free-agent pitchers, but the idea of stockpiling young arms for use in the majors and potentially trade for more prospects has been a massive failure for the second time in the last 20 years. 

They went through a similar run of futility drafting pitchers from 1999-2007... 

Remember Eric Winston’s puzzling comments about the future of the NFL? 

Include former players Seth Joyner and Eric Davis (not that Eric Davis) to the list of people not impressed with the president of NFLPA’s perspective on this. 

Will be interesting to see if anything else comes from this...

RELATED: Of course NFL fans feel they have a stake in their favorite team

Meanwhile, the third preseason game is typically the most interesting anyway, but all indications are some key Bengals will be making their debuts Sunday

Which do you want to see the most?... 

Lastly, need another indicator college football season is here? 

Kirk Herbstreit took questions for 40 minutes yesterday about the 2017 season. 

Here are the five most interesting things he talked about

But first the high school football teams will take the field, including a slew of programs with new leaders. 

Here is what five local coaches told me about putting their stamp on a new program


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

5 things to know about Ohio State football in 2018
5 things to know about Ohio State football in 2018

With the Buckeyes’ winter workouts up and running, the 2018 Ohio State football season is more or less officially underway. Most of the recruiting class has signed, and everyone who is leaving early for the NFL draft has declared so.  Here is what you need to know about the Buckeyes with a new year dawning: Four defenders who started at...
5 Cincinnati Reds prospects make Baseball America’s top 100 
5 Cincinnati Reds prospects make Baseball America’s top 100 

While the present continues to be murky for the Cincinnati Reds, the future seems to be bright if it ever gets here.  Baseball America’s newest list of top 100 prospects includes five players from the organization.  Four of them are former Dayton Dragons while a fifth is expected to be in the Gem City this spring.  Topping the...
Davidson at Dayton: What you need to know about Tuesday’s game
Davidson at Dayton: What you need to know about Tuesday’s game

Who: Davidson (10-7, 5-1) at Dayton (9-10, 3-4) When: 7 p.m., Tuesday Where: UD Arena TV/Radio: CBS Sports Network; AM 1290, News 95.7 WHIO Darrell Davis, 6-5, Sr., G, 16.9 Josh Cunningham, 6-7, R-Jr., F, 16.2 Trey Landers, 6-5, So., G, 8.6 Jordan Davis, 6-2, Fr., G, 8.0 Jalen Crutcher, 6-1, Fr., G, 7.7 Peyton Aldridge, 6-8, Sr., F, 20.1...
Sports Today: Super Bowl set on super disappointing basketball weekend
Sports Today: Super Bowl set on super disappointing basketball weekend

The Super Bowl matchup is set.  Blake Bortles nearly granted us a big game with no one to root against, but Tom Brady and Bill Belickick would not be denied.  Then the Philadelphia Eagles crushed Minnesota in the nightcap, saving us from two weeks of stories about how it may or may not be fair the Vikings were getting to play a home...
Super Bowl LII: A look at the area players, former Bengals in the game
Super Bowl LII: A look at the area players, former Bengals in the game

When the New England Patriots face the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LII on Feb. 4, there will be a number of players with local connections. Some played for area high schools or colleges, others are former members of the Cincinnati Bengals, and one began his coaching career nearby. Here is a look at the local flavor in Super Bowl LII: NEW ENGLAND...
More Stories