You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

7 former NFL players reject latest concussion offer

In the wake of a landmark settlement between the NFL and former players, these seven are now saying it's not nearly good enough. 

The concussion lawsuit involving roughly 5,000 former players suffering from dementia and repeated head trauma has already seen multiple settlement offers rejected. 

​The New York Times reported in August the league offered to pay $765 million, but that was quickly rejected by a judge when she felt that amount couldn't pay for every potential cost for the estimated 18,000 retired players during the 65-year lifespan of the agreement.  

Last month, the NFL proposed a new, uncapped settlement.

Christopher Seeger, the co-lead attorney for the players, says this means, "retired players and their families can rely on the 100 percent guarantee the fund will pay all eligible claims over its 65-year duration." (via USA Today)

So why are these seven players still saying no deal?

For one thing, the proposed deal sets limits on compensation for chronic traumatic encephalopathy — the progressive brain disorder that has gained so much media attention. (Via Los Angeles Times)

Depression, explosive anger and short term memory loss are all symptoms of CTE, which is thought to be caused by the repeated head trauma of concussions. (Via Korngold, Farrell, and Fozdar, 2013)

A 2005 study surveyed approximately 2,500 former NFL players and found 65% had suffered a concussion at some point during their careers. Twenty four percent had suffered three or more. (ViaGuskiewicz et al., 2005

The result of these concussions has often been tragic. According to Ebony Magazine, autopsies after these players' suicides revealed they all suffered from CTE. 

In exchange for not having a cap on the settlement, the NFL also got the right to appeal as many payouts as it wants. (Via Getty Images)

The seven players also took offense to what they saw as outrageous attorney fees. In the proposals, attorney compensation hovered around one-third of the total settlement.  

According to Forbes, the attorneys representing the players do foot the bill for most or all of the litigation, with no guarantees of any settlement being made.

However, the site also says players are concerned their attorneys will "double dip" by taking an additional fee according to their retainer agreement. (Via Forbes)

Despite this, many experts caution other players from opting out of the agreement, as no individual settlements with the NFL are guaranteed. Many are taking an agreement they find too low simply out of the need for money to pay for current medical bills.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

H.S. Results for 1/18/17: Centerville girls win a thriller

Centerville’s Meghan Mattingly calmly sank the front end of a double bonus free throw opportunity with 0.4 seconds remaining in the second overtime Wednesday night, lifting Centerville to a heart-stopping 51-50 victory over Lebanon in Greater Western Ohio Conference girls basketball. Mattingly’s free throw, the last of her 9 points, allowed...
Jim Jabir back on court as a men’s coach in Denmark
Jim Jabir back on court as a men’s coach in Denmark

Four months after he stepped down as coach of the Dayton Flyers, citing health reasons, Jim Jabir has returned to coaching. Jabir is the interim coach for SISU Copenhagen, a men’s professional team in Denmark. He will coach his first home game with the team on Friday. Jabir coached Dayton for 13 seasons and has spent his entire career on the...
Baseball Hall of Fame slugger Willie McCovey pardoned by president
Baseball Hall of Fame slugger Willie McCovey pardoned by president

Baseball Hall of Famer and All-Star slugger Willie Covey was one of 64 people pardoned by President Barack Obama this week, decades after conviction on tax evasion charges.
Another Bengals player added to Pro Bowl
Another Bengals player added to Pro Bowl

For the second time in as many days the Cincinnati Bengals have had a player added to the AFC Pro Bowl roster with today’s announcement that left tackle Andrew Whitworth will replace Oakland’s Donald Penn. Defensive tackle Carlos Dunlap was added as a replacement for Houston’s Jadeveon Clowney on Tuesday. Whitworth, who was a first...
6 numbers explain why the Cincinnati Bengals had a losing season
6 numbers explain why the Cincinnati Bengals had a losing season

The NFL’s playoffs are ongoing… and the Bengals are still not part of them. A few numbers can help us understand how Cincinnati was left out in 2016 after making five straight trips to the postseason, and a couple more give hints about what they might do about it. Later this week we will look at whether 2016 left them closer to playoff...
More Stories