The Adobe Flash Player is required to view this multimedia interactive. Get it here.

Reactions to roundabout mixed

Some downtown business owners say it has hurt business, others says it has had little impact.

Politicians, friends, family pay final tribute to Saxbe
9/5/10
Cheerleading gaining status as a sport
9/5/10
GOP riding election ‘wave’
9/5/10
Hit-and-run victim identified
9/5/10
What’s at stake in this fall’s election?
9/4/10
> More headlines

E-mail this page

By Matt Sanctis, Staff Writer 8:16 PM Saturday, January 2, 2010

URBANA — A roundabout designed to improve traffic flow through downtown Urbana seems to be doing the job, but area business owners are still not sure what to think of the project several months after it was installed.

In September, the roundabout was installed in Monument Square as part of the Scioto Street Enhancement Project, with the goal of improving traffic flow. Previously, lights at the intersection caused traffic to back up through the downtown, a situation which seems to have eased since the roundabout, according to city officials.

Reactions have been mixed for businesses nearby, however. While some said the project has cost them customers, others said it has had little impact on their business.

John Carmazzi, who owns Carmazzi’s Candy and Deli, 100 S. Main St., said the roundabout has been bad for business.

While he noted he has a loyal base of customers, some of the older clients in particular have been reluctant to walk through the square because traffic flows more quickly. “They’re just afraid to come downtown, especially some of my older clients,” he said.

In other cases, he said potential customers are passing through the square quickly and not stopping at local businesses.

While he said he hopes customers get used to it eventually, things are tough for now.

Others, such as Julie Fannin, said the roundabout hasn’t made much of a difference one way or another. Fannin, of Willman Furniture Co., 215 N. Main St., said the location of the business may make the roundabout less of an issue for her business. It sits outside the square.

“I don’t think it’s affected our business,” she said.

Chuck Jones, owner of Catfish Jones, said the roundabout has been successful in improving traffic flow. He has seen a slight drop in business since it was installed, he said, but some of those customers are already starting to return.

He said the roundabout may have been a good idea, but he was unsure about the timing since many businesses are already struggling with the economy.

At Cafe Paradiso, owner Pat Thackery said he’s been pleased with the roundabout so far. He said it hasn’t had much of an impact on his restaurant, and the city’s downtown seems to be cleaner and quieter without the stopped traffic.

“As far as I’m concerned, it’s cleaner and it’s smoother,” he said.

Share this article

ADD COMMENT

Comments feed

And old saying "If it ain't broke why fix it"
This town could have done without the roundabout.
There is other improvements this town really
could use. They seem to want to keep looking
like it's in the 1950's.

Wonderwoman
9:14 PM, 1/19/2010

REPORT ABUSE

Having safe crosswalks is much more important than quick traffic flow. It's just not safe to walk around the square anymore.

oliveoil
2:38 PM, 1/19/2010

REPORT ABUSE

I am amazed at how many people think the "New" Roundabout is confusing. First off, it has always been a roundabout, it recently lost the traffic signal which slowed traffic. The only thing changed was traffic lanes went to one instead of the old two. Simple traffic rules apply everywhere. Yield to traffic on left. Traffic in roundabout has rightaway. Now you don't have to sit in traffic for several minutes to get through roundabout like you did when traffic light slowed down traffic.

L Berry
9:58 AM, 1/18/2010

REPORT ABUSE

The roundabout is fine. Traffic moves so much better now. The problem with some downtown business is their product and service. People do need to understand basic traffic laws, but that is said no matter where you drive. Yeild does mean slw down for right of way traffic, and if it is clear move on through. Pretty simple.

BobKnob
11:26 AM, 1/5/2010

REPORT ABUSE

I live in the 300 block of Court Street one block north of the square.
Two things come to mind. First, traffic flow has improved, no question. And second it is very dangerous to attempt to walk through the square. Last night my wife witnessed a man who was struck by a vehicle while crossing in the cross walk. And I have had to stop and let cars and trucks go by while attempting to walk in the cross walk. Enforcement of existing laws would make this cross walk safer.

David Greenlee
1:01 PM, 1/4/2010

REPORT ABUSE

There are 14 additional comments

SHOW ALL

We welcome your comments. Please remember this is a public forum and behave appropriately. Your comments must conform to our visitor's agreement.