The Adobe Flash Player is required to view this multimedia interactive. Get it here.

Attorneys question turbine report

Marshall Gorby/About 50 area residents toured a small wind farm in Bowling Green on Wednesday, Oct. 21. The tour was organized for the Champaign County Farm Bureau.

Wittenberg latest to close due to Level 2 snow emergency
4:05 p.m.
Girls Gone Wild coming back to Springfield
3:55 p.m.
Millions awarded to update area water, sewer systems
3:54 p.m.
Paid days off for county employees an issue for commissioners
1:13 p.m.
Grand jury indicts 21
12:05 p.m.
> More headlines

By Matt Sanctis, Staff Writer Updated 9:55 PM Friday, November 20, 2009

COLUMBUS — A state employee was questioned Friday, Nov. 20, about a report he prepared for the Buckeye Wind Project.

Champaign County Prosecutor Nick Selvaggio and Gil Weithman, city of Urbana law director, asked Nick Doss about methods he used to develop sections of a staff report concerning aviation and decommissioning of the Buckeye Wind Project.

The report includes recommendations that the state power siting board will use to evaluate the project.

Everpower Renewables, based in New York, is proposing to install about 70 wind turbines throughout the county.

Selvaggio and Weithman also questioned Doss, an environmental specialist with the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, about his knowledge of the area before he filed his section of the staff report. Doss responded that he had toured the project area and visited proposed turbine sites with GPS equipment.

Additionally, he did a windshield tour of Grimes and Weller fields, which included driving by the air fields for about five minutes, Doss said.

He said he had not talked to the airport manger or local pilots before filing his recommendations.

However, Doss talked with a state aviation official and evaluated charts and maps of the area that gave him enough information to make his recommendation, he said.

Noting this is the first large-scale wind project in Ohio, Selvaggio questioned whether Doss and other staff members had considered additional sources of information when compiling the report, or whether they relied on information in Everpower’s application to the state.

Doss said some sections of the staff report could be reviewed, although he noted PUCO staff members were not necessarily obligated to do so.

John Holland, program aviation manager for Careflight Air and Mobile, also testified Friday that if installed, the turbines could increase flight time and therefore also slow patient care.

He said the turbines would be an obstacle, and in some cases Careflight pilots would need to perform additional planning to avoid the turbines.

Attorneys representing the Buckeye Wind Project questioned whether equipment such as night vision goggles and search lights could help avoid obstacles, as well as whether pilots would be able to fly over the turbines to avoid them in some situations.

Share this article

ADD COMMENT

Comments feed

The wind companies simply want money. That's it. Period. Bottom line.

Bethany
8:13 AM, 1/1/2010

REPORT ABUSE

Wind-man is unable to defend industrial wind on its own merits, and unable to defend Everpower's proposal for 500-foot turbines in Champaign Co. In his frustration, he makes lame jokes about coal deposits. I know it's painful Wind-man, but in order to develop as a true environmentalist, you're going to have to lose some of your idealism about industrial wind. Everpower and its industrial turbines are not a part of saving the planet. I can sympathize with your frustration, but facts are facts.

the truth hurts
11:12 AM, 11/23/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Wind-man-

No worries, you didn't confuse all of us. I'm curious about the coal deposit. Where did you hear this?

There is some talk (and as far as I know speculation at this point) that Everpower could have mineral and water rights if this wind project goes through.

green and clean
10:50 AM, 11/23/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Sorry that I confused you all with the facts. By the way, I heard that a large coal deposit has been found under Champaign County.

wind-man
9:51 AM, 11/23/2009

REPORT ABUSE

people like "what the..." should not comment on this situation as they clearly know nothing about the complex topic of renewable energy. This issue is not Conversatives versus Liberals. This is about Thoughtful, Responsible, Environmentally-minded people versus Simple-minded People who want easy answers (wind!)and easy money (government $$$!!). Unless you have something meaningful to say, please shut your piehole.

So Very Tired of Idiots...
7:34 AM, 11/23/2009

REPORT ABUSE

There are 29 additional comments

SHOW ALL

We welcome your comments. Please remember this is a public forum and behave appropriately. Your comments must conform to our visitor's agreement.