The Adobe Flash Player is required to view this multimedia interactive. Get it here.

Poultry, hog industries  brace for animal activism

Cage-free production would undercut food safety, producer says

Pete Dull talks with Dustin Simon, a visitor to his farm near Brookville, in a barn that houses sows inside of gestation crates. The Humane Society of the United States is trying to change the way pork and egg producers house animals on their farms. Staff photo by Jim Witmer

Jim Witmer Pete Dull talks with Dustin Simon, a visitor to his farm near Brookville, in a barn that houses sows inside of gestation crates. The Humane Society of the United States is trying to change the way pork and egg producers house animals on their farms. Staff photo by Jim Witmer

ENLARGE PHOTO

Humane Society, farmers spar over livestock cages

E-mail this page

By Ben Sutherly, Staff Writer Updated 2:47 PM Sunday, May 3, 2009

Third-generation egg producer Tim Weaver has a 1950s-era egg carton labeled “Purina Cage Eggs.”

“They are always clean — the hens never touch the ground,” it proclaims.

Half a century later, the caged-hen production method, which Weaver said provides the highest degree of food safety and hen care, faces an unprecedented challenge in Ohio from the Humane Society of the United States.

HSUS wants to phase out not only battery cages for Ohio’s 27.3 million egg-laying hens, but also gestation crates for its pregnant pigs, and crates for veal calves in favor of group housing.

Farm animals should be able to stand up, sit down, turn around and extend their limbs at all times, said Paul Shapiro, senior director of HSUS’ factory farming campaign. He noted Smithfield Foods, the nation’s largest hog producer, committed in 2007 to phase out gestation crates.

If farm groups won’t work with HSUS to craft legislation, it likely will put a ballot initiative before Ohio voters next year.

California voters handily approved a similar ballot measure in 2008 that mandates freer movement for egg-laying hens, pregnant pigs and veal calves by 2015.

Ohio’s egg production, valued at $483 million in 2007, ranks second only to Iowa’s. Darke and Mercer counties, both within an hour’s drive of Dayton, ranked second and third in egg production among all U.S. counties in 2007.

But that could change if battery cages are phased out. Weaver, whose Versailles-based Weaver Bros. Inc. processes more than 2 billion eggs each year from 7.5 million chickens, said eliminating cages would threaten the survival of his business, which employs 300 people.

“I don’t have access to the capital it would take to get the number of hens it would take to stay in business,” Weaver said.

In recent years, he’s thinned his flocks in existing buildings by 25 percent to give hens more cage space in accordance with voluntary industry guidelines. He spent at least $12 million to add additional high-rise henhouses and equipment to replace that lost production, he said.

“It’s an emotional, misguided attempt by a special-interest group to impact the direction of agriculture in our country,” Weaver said. He’s concerned cage-free production would undercut animal welfare and food safety, and even threaten national security by forcing meat and egg production overseas.

Pete Dull, whose family produces more than 10,000 hogs each year at their farm near Brookville, also opposes group housing for pregnant pigs, saying his family abandoned the practice more than 30 years ago. The mother pigs, or sows, produce larger litters and have a longer useful life when kept in gestation crates, he said.

“The way we’re taking care of sows now is much better than (HSUS) wants,” Dull said.

Share this article

ADD COMMENT

Comments feed

Modern farming actually protects animals from extreme temperatures, the elements of weather, diseases, etc. I have solid factual information from studies conducted by scientists regarding poultry. Caged hens actually have a lower mortality rate, higher production levels, lower feed costs, lower mite number & decreased cannibalism. I am happy to provide these results or any information anyone would like to see. atiemeyer@goodegg.com

Amanda Tiemeyer
2:07 PM, 5/7/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Factory Farms.You can not call them farms at all.They CONFINEthem day after day.They Never go outside how would you like that?I live beside a factory that is spreadig the manure from a pond with millons and millons gallons of manure.They call it a pond ha ha.I think I no how the cows fill My family can not go outside because it Stinks.Hard to tell what is in the manure.Just think if you plant in manure you eat manure.Please HSUS HELP >Agriculture you should get your manure together.

Mary
10:46 PM, 5/4/2009

REPORT ABUSE

I raise livestock. I eat meat. I've seen how animals in pasture-based systems live and how they live in the factory farms. The HSUS is not trying to abolish the factory farms. It's just asking the "farmers" to allow their animals to move, to spread their wings. Maybe these factory farmers should spend less money on lobbying and trying to fight the Humane Society and more on giving their animals a little space.

anne
3:16 PM, 5/4/2009

REPORT ABUSE

It's hard to imagine the cruelty animals endure on the "modern" farms....unable to turn around, stretch their legs - let alone walk, or ever feel sunshine and rain on their backs! I'd vote for the old fashioned farms where the animals eat fresh grass in the fields like the farm I grew up on. Have you noticed there are no animals left outside these days? They are all locked inside the super farms. You can't even play road side poker anymore.

Stand up for animals
6:02 PM, 5/3/2009

REPORT ABUSE

Steve I agree with you the HSUS is sticking their nose were it doesn't belong. I have worked in these building and the animals are cared for better than if they are allowed to run free.

Done with pork you need to take your vegetation diet and shove it. Everyone knows that the US is a meat and veggie county. HSUS is bitting off more than they can chew. Farmers work well and cooperate with standards when they are changed and have never done anything wrong to ruin the land.

Macdee
2:44 PM, 5/3/2009

REPORT ABUSE

There are 14 additional comments

SHOW ALL

We welcome your comments. Please remember this is a public forum and behave appropriately. Your comments must conform to our visitor's agreement.