NEW DETAILS:

Baby found dead in vehicle in Procter & Gamble lot

The myth of ‘settled science’


I repeat: I’m not a global warming believer. I’m not a global warming denier. I’ve long believed that it cannot be good for humanity to be spewing tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. I also believe that those scientists who pretend to know exactly what this will cause in 20, 30 or 50 years are white-coated propagandists.

“The debate is settled,” asserted propagandist in chief Barack Obama in his latest State of the Union address. “Climate change is a fact.” Really? There is nothing more anti-scientific than the very idea that science is settled, static, impervious to challenge. Take a non-climate example. It was long assumed that mammograms help reduce breast cancer deaths. This fact was so settled that Obamacare requires every insurance plan to offer mammograms (for free, no less).

Now we learn from a massive randomized study — 90,000 women followed for 25 years — that mammograms may have no effect on breast cancer deaths.

Climate is less well understood than breast cancer. If climate science is settled, why do its predictions change? And how is it that the great physicist Freeman Dyson, who did some climate research in the late 1970s, thinks today’s climate-change Cassandras are hopelessly mistaken?

They deal with the fluid dynamics of the atmosphere and oceans, argues Dyson, ignoring vegetation and topsoil. Further, their predictions rest on models they fall in love with: “You sit in front of a computer screen for 10 years and you start to think of your model as being real.” Not surprisingly, these models have been “consistently and spectacularly wrong” in their predictions, write atmospheric scientists Richard McNider and John Christy — and always, amazingly, in the same direction.

Last Friday, Obama ostentatiously visited drought-stricken California. Surprise! He blamed climate change. Here even The New York Times gagged, pointing out that far from being supported by the evidence, “the most recent computer projections suggest that as the world warms, California should get wetter, not drier, in the winter.”

We’ve been here before. Hurricane Sandy was made the poster child for the alleged increased frequency and strength of “extreme weather events” like hurricanes.

Nonsense. Sandy wasn’t even a hurricane when it hit the U.S. Indeed, in all of 2012, only a single hurricane made U.S. landfall. And 2013 saw the fewest Atlantic hurricanes in 30 years.

None of this is dispositive. It doesn’t settle the issue. But that’s the point. It mocks the very notion of settled science, which is nothing but a crude attempt to silence critics and delegitimize debate.

Climate-change proponents have made their cause a matter of fealty and faith. For folks who pretend to be brave carriers of the scientific ethic, there’s more than a tinge of religion in their jeremiads. If you whore after other gods, the Bible tells us, “the Lord’s wrath be kindled against you, and he shut up the heaven, that there be no rain, and that the land yield not her fruit” (Deuteronomy 11).

Sounds like California. Except that today there’s a new god, the Earth Mother.

So if California burns, you send your high priest (in a carbon-belching Air Force One, but never mind) to the bone-dry land to offer up, on behalf of the repentant congregation, a $1 billion burnt offering called a “climate resilience fund.”

Ah, settled science in action.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Fall-like weather arrives in Miami Valley as Touchdown 7 football begins
Fall-like weather arrives in Miami Valley as Touchdown 7 football begins

Although August is yet to end, fall-like weather has made an arrival in the Miami Valley this week, just in time for Touchdown 7 football to begin.  The forecast will be cooler than normal, but still pleasant for both Thursday and Friday night games, according to Storm Center 7 Meteorologist McCall Vrydaghs.  Sports Director Mike Hartsock...
One of R. Kelly’s alleged ‘cult’ victims violated her nondisclosure agreement to speak out
One of R. Kelly’s alleged ‘cult’ victims violated her nondisclosure agreement to speak out

In July, R. Kelly was accused of keeping women against their will and forcing them to follow every one of his rules or face physical punishment. On Tuesday, one of his alleged victims spoke out to BuzzFeed News. Few of the women who were in the “cult” have come forward because they reportedly signed nondisclosure agreements in exchange...
Miami County man charged with animal cruelty against dog

A Miami County man is being charged with multiple counts related to animal cruelty after posting about it on Facebook. The man is identified as Joshua C. Oswald, 29, of Newton Township. Oswald had posted photos of a deceased dog on Facebook, according to the Miami County Sheriff’s Office.  Comments on the Facebook post suggested that...
Piglets that were saved from fire served for dinner at fire station
Piglets that were saved from fire served for dinner at fire station

Pigs that were rescued from certain death in a February barn fire ended up returning as sausages six months later to the firefighters who rescued them. A farm manager in Wiltshire, England, thought that giving the Pewsey fire department the free food was a way of saying thanks. "I gave those animals the best quality of life I could ever give until...
FedEx truck delivers marijuana to home during drug bust, police say
FedEx truck delivers marijuana to home during drug bust, police say

Police in Oklahoma made an arrest in a big drug trafficking bust Tuesday. Dustin Drank, 35, was arrested in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Police said they found 76 pounds of marijuana and $19,000 in “drug proceeds” at two residences in the area.   As the bust was happening, a FedEx truck delivered boxes to a house  that were also...
More Stories