The budget deficit is not our biggest problem


“Our biggest problems over the next 10 years are not deficits,” President Obama told House Republicans last week, according to those who attended the meeting.

The president needs to deliver the same message to the public, loudly and clearly. The biggest problems we face are unemployment, stagnant wages, slow growth and widening inequality — not deficits. The major goal must be to get jobs and wages back, not balance the budget.

Rep. Paul Ryan’s budget plan is designed to lure the White House and Democrats, and the American public, into a debate over how to balance the federal budget in 10 years, not over whether it’s worth doing.

“This is an invitation,” Ryan explained when he unveiled the plan last week. “Show us how to balance the budget. If you don’t like the way we’re proposing to balance our budget, how do you propose to balance the budget?”

Until now, the president has seemed all too willing to engage in that debate. His ongoing talk of a “grand bargain” to reduce the budget deficit has played directly into Republican hands. As has his repeated use of the Republican analogy comparing the government’s finances to a household’s. “Just as families and businesses must tighten their belts to live within their means,” he said of his 2013 budget, “so must the federal government.”

Hopefully, he’s now shifting the debate.

The government’s finances are not at all like a household’s. In fact, it’s when American families can’t spend enough to keep the economy going, because too many of them are unemployed or underemployed and have run out of money, that government has to step in as spender of last resort — even if that means taking on more debt.

If government doesn’t fill the spending gap, an economy can collapse into deeper recession or depression, pushing unemployment far higher. Look at what austerity economics has done to Europe.

In addition, it’s perfectly fine for government to borrow and continue to borrow in order to invest in new roads or other infrastructure, or education, or basic research — when those investments pay off in higher rates of economic growth.

The notion that government spending “crowds out” private investment, keeping interest rates higher than otherwise, is obsolete in a global economy where capital sloshes across national borders, seeking the highest returns from anywhere.

Societies that invest in the productivity of their people attract global capital and create high-paying jobs. And since most big corporations are no longer dependent on the productivity of any one nation, the responsibility for making such investments increasingly falls to government.

Not that we should disregard the debt altogether, but the best way to deal with it is to do so gradually, through economic growth. That’s how we reduced the giant debt Franklin D. Roosevelt bequeathed America, and it’s how the Clinton administration (of which I am proud to have been a member) achieved a balanced budget in 1996.

Republicans want Americans to believe government budgets are like family budgets that must be balanced, because the analogy helps their ideological aim to “drown (the government) in the bathtub,” in the memorable words of their guru, Grover Norquist.

As long as there’s a debt and balance is the goal, shrinkage is the only option — if tax increases are ruled out.

At last the president wants to change the debate and focus on the real economic problem. In an interview last week with George Stephanopoulos that got less attention than it deserved, he said, “My goal is not to chase a balanced budget just for the sake of balance. My goal is how do we grow the economy, put people back to work, and if we do that we are going to be bringing in more revenue.”

Let the real contest begin.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Arnold Schwarzenegger donates $100,000 to ‘anti-hate organization’ after Charlottesville violence
Arnold Schwarzenegger donates $100,000 to ‘anti-hate organization’ after Charlottesville violence

Arnold Schwarzenegger is putting his money where his mouth is after seeing coverage of the violence at a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, Saturday. In a statement posted on a note on his Facebook page Sunday, the former governor of California said he had been “horrified by the images of Nazis and white supremacists marching...
MoviePass app lets subscribers go to the movies once a day for $10 a month
MoviePass app lets subscribers go to the movies once a day for $10 a month

Remember the days when going to the movies cost less than $10? Maybe you remember when it was less than $5. These days, a trip to the theater can cost a pretty penny. While the national average is $8.65, in many cities, like Los Angeles and New York, a ticket can cost up to or more than $15. But thanks to one app, $10 can now go a lot further...
Clark County students head back to school
Clark County students head back to school

Clark County students grabbed their backpacks and settled into classrooms Wednesday morning as districts opened their doors for the first day of school. Children at Horace Mann Elementary School in Springfield put away pencils, listened to class rules and answered short survey questions about themselves. MORE: The Dome open house brings in Springfield...
Giant 'hyper-hybrid' roller coaster will be tallest and fastest of its kind
Giant 'hyper-hybrid' roller coaster will be tallest and fastest of its kind

Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio, just announced that its adding another monstrous roller coaster to its already world-breaking collection.  Set to open in 2018, Steel Vengeance is promised to be the park’s “wildest ride Cedar Point has ever built,” according to a CP news release.  The coaster required a new classification...
Man shot, drives to hospital in bullet-riddled car
Man shot, drives to hospital in bullet-riddled car

A man drove himself to the hospital in a car with six bullet holes after a shooting near Tukwila. Washington State Patrol is investigating a shooting that happened shortly after 5 a.m. near Interstate 5. A KIRO 7 photographer was at Harborview Medical Center when the man drove up to the hospital in bullet-riddled car with a shattered back window. The...
More Stories