You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Tea party wasting energy hunting extinct species

FROM THE RIGHT: POLITICS


“We’ve got to get the Rockefeller Republicans out of the party,” a fellow told me in Minnesota recently. Or was it Arizona? Or Wilkes-Barre, Pa.? Actually, I think it was all three. I hear it all the time as I travel around the country.

For those of you who don’t know, Rockefeller Republicans — named after the former New York governor, Nelson Rockefeller — were the liberal, mostly Northeastern wing of the Republican Party.

Rockefeller Republicans are basically extinct, at least among GOP officeholders. Sure, a handful of descendants with some Rockefellerian DNA are hiding in the woods of New York, Maine and Pennsylvania. But even they are on the endangered species list.

And yet, there’s this idea that they control the party. Even Pat Buchanan, who knows this history better than most, recently wrote that the current battle between the GOP establishment and forces allied with Ted Cruz is a replay of the old fight between Barry Goldwater and Rockefeller.

There are certainly some similarities, but the differences are more relevant and profound. Pick any three defining issues of conservatism — say, smaller government, low taxes and opposition to abortion, or a strong national defense, entitlement reform and gun rights — and you’ll be hard-pressed to find the Republican “establishment” on one side and the tea party faithful on the other.

Even on policies that are splitting Republicans these days — say, foreign policy or immigration — the rift does not neatly divide the establishment and the “real conservatives.”

Such a statement will no doubt infuriate conservatives who believe the establishment is insufficiently committed to conservative principles. And that is a fair complaint. But that criticism is about efficacy and passion, not policy or philosophy. And this is an important distinction that has been airbrushed out of the picture by groups like Heritage Action and FreedomWorks. The current GOP establishment is more conservative than it has ever been.

In the recent conservative donnybrook over the government shutdown, insurgents insisted they were in an ideological struggle with the establishment. But there was precious little ideology involved. Instead, it was a fight over tactics and power. The Republican Party almost unanimously opposed Obamacare, and Republicans who’ve been in office far longer than Cruz & Co. have voted more than three dozen times to get rid of it. And yet, the latecomers to the battle talk as if the veterans in the trenches were collaborators the whole time.

I have enormous sympathy for their frustration, because I share it.

But the real source of that frustration is not the insufficient conservatism of the establishment; it’s the insufficient power and popularity of conservatism coupled with the very real failures of the GOP to reverse conservatism’s fortunes over the last two decades.

That’s reason enough to be mad at the establishment. But replacing the leadership with even more ardent, passionate and uncompromising conservatives is far from a guaranteed formula for making the GOP more popular or powerful. To do that, the GOP needs to persuade voters to become a little more conservative, not to hector already-conservative politicians to become even more pure.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Trump tax plan: What is the AMT, tax repatriation, the death tax?
Trump tax plan: What is the AMT, tax repatriation, the death tax?

President Donald Trump on Wednesday announced a proposal to drastically cut taxes for corporations and simplify the tax filing system for individuals. Companies would see a business tax rate of 15 percent, down from 35 percent, and individuals would benefit from a doubling of the standard deduction and a simplified form to fill out on tax day each...
Delta passenger uses restroom before takeoff, gets bumped from flight
Delta passenger uses restroom before takeoff, gets bumped from flight

A Delta Air Lines passenger was asked to exit the plane after he urgently had to use the lavatory when the plane was getting ready for takeoff, and a fellow passenger recorded the incident on video, according to an account in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. According to an article by columnist Jim Stingl, the flight was getting ready to depart...
Change likely to continue at Urbana University amid new leadership
Change likely to continue at Urbana University amid new leadership

Some students at Urbana University have questions about the changes at the campus but said they also hope it will bring more funding to the school. Urbana’s president resigned Tuesday after two years with the school as the university potentially shifts to a branch campus of Franklin University in Columbus. Franklin acquired the smaller campus...
Creepy or useful? Amazon’s new Echo Look selfie camera wants to help you get dressed
Creepy or useful? Amazon’s new Echo Look selfie camera wants to help you get dressed

When the Amazon Echo had its first big debut in 2015, it was introduced as a speaker with a voice assistant inside. Now, the newest device in the Echo family is focused on making sure you leave the house looking your absolute best. On Wednesday, Amazon revealed the Echo Look — priced at $200 — as a “hands-free camera and style...
Check your change jar for rare penny worth up to $85,000 
Check your change jar for rare penny worth up to $85,000 

A rare coin, the 1943 copper wheat penny, also known as the Wheat Cent, is worth a pretty penny these days, selling for up to $85,000 at auction. That’s according to the online coin value service CoinTrackers, which said the pennies are so valuable because so few were made and they were released by mistake. The Wheat Cent is made mostly from...
More Stories