Ohio bill lays out which police body cam footage should be public


As more police officers respond to crime scenes wearing body cameras, an intense debate has erupted over how much of the footage is public record and where that line should be drawn.

In Ohio, State Rep. Niraj Antani, R-Miamisburg, is pushing a bill that attempts to define which videos are public and when police can withhold them from release.

Body camera video is generally a public record, according to the bill, except if it’s taken in a private home or business, involves the victim of a sex crime or is part of a confidential ongoing investigation.

Related: Lawmaker proposes keeping some police body cam video private Ohio Fraternal Order of Police lobbyist Mike Weinman said the police union sees no major issues with the bill and is happy to see that personal conversations among officers that aren’t related to police work will not be considered a public record.

ACLU of Ohio lobbyist Gary Daniels said the civil liberties group is also backing Antani’s proposal, saying it strikes the right balance of keeping government open, holding police accountable and protecting personal privacy.

“We think this proposed bill balances all of that quite well,” he said.

Ohio News Media Association Executive Director Dennis Hetzel said the association will review Antani’s proposal but “the bill does a better job than some other states in preserving the basic presumption of openness that should attach to these records so there is accountability and transparency while dealing with the legitimate privacy concerns that these devices create.”

Columbus Mayor Andrew Ginther appeared with Antani at a press conference Monday in support of the bill. By the end of 2018, 1,300 Columbus police officers will be outfitted with cameras. Other Ohio cities are testing or using body-worn cameras, though some cities have yet to take that step.

Groups have pushed for body cameras as a means for making police officers more accountable. But while the cameras are becoming more universal, the question of which footage is releasable from those cameras is far from resolved.

Related: Body camera footage shows shooting of Ohio news photographer by deputy In a separate issue, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled in December that police dash-cam videos are public records but that portions of the footage may be withheld from disclosure while investigations are ongoing.

Ohio’s open records law presumes that government documents, including photos, videos, audio recordings, databases, spreadsheets, shall be disclosed to the public upon request, unless they fall under an exemption. Over the years, lawmakers have shielded more records from public disclosure by adding exemptions.

Antani’s bill, which will be introduced in the Ohio House this week, exempts from disclosure body cam footage that captures:

  • Dead bodies or grievously injured bodies, unless the death or injury was caused by an officer or the decedent’s executor consents to its release;
  • Dead or grievously injured first responders, unless the decedent’s executor or injured person consents to its release;
  • An act of severe violence against a person or first responder. The exemption would not apply if the violence was done by a peace officer or the injured person’s consent is obtained.
  • Nude bodies, unless consent is obtained.
  • Identifying information about alleged victims of sex offenses, stalking or domestic violence.
  • Personal information about someone who is not arrested, ticketed, charged or issued a warning by police.
  • Obscene material.

Antani said the exceptions in his bill will help protect privacy rights while also providing transparency and accountability.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Flu outbreak forces an entire school district in Oklahoma to cancel classes for rest of week
Flu outbreak forces an entire school district in Oklahoma to cancel classes for rest of week

An entire Oklahoma school district canceled classes Wednesday through Friday after schools reported excessive flu absences among much of the staff. >> Read more trending news  Morris Public Schools said Monday's absences were at 20 percent, and Tuesday's were at more than 30 percent. Basketball teams will continue competition in the...
Washington State University quarterback Tyler Hilinski found dead with apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound
Washington State University quarterback Tyler Hilinski found dead with apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound

Police in Pullman, Washington, say officers have found Washington State University quarterback Tyler Hilinkski dead Tuesday in an apartment with an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.  At about 4:30 p.m., officers responded to an apartment to check on the welfare of a football player who did not show up for practice earlier in the day...
OPINION: Let’s not use euphemisms for conduct unbecoming a president

Now that Donald Trump has been president for almost a year, it’s time the media call his behavior what it is rather than try to normalize it. Here are the six most misleading media euphemisms for conduct unbecoming a president. 1. Calling Trump’s tweets “presidential “statements” or “press releases.” Wrong...
Haitians under protected status call on administration to process work permits
Haitians under protected status call on administration to process work permits

Thousands of Haitians living in Central Florida said they're just days away from being forced out of their jobs. Many of those worried are workers at Disney World. They were granted Temporary Protected Status after an earthquake devastated their country in 2010. They’re now finding out their jobs are in limbo, because their work authorizations...
Changes promised in wake of racially insensitive basketball jerseys incident
Changes promised in wake of racially insensitive basketball jerseys incident

Changes are being promised for Kings Schools in the wake of last week’s racist incident that drew national attention, but Tuesday evening district officials said details about those changes will come later. That was the message from Kings’ leader and school board members, who took the resignation of their board vice president in the wake...
More Stories