Ex-officer’s termination case won’t be heard by high court

Vikki Adams’ attorney will file motion to reconsider.


A former Enon police officer’s appeal for a hearing in the Ohio Supreme Court on a wrongful termination suit was declined on jurisdictional grounds.

The justices’ 4-3 decision Wednesday to not hear the civil case was a move Vikki Adams’ attorney described as a “complete miscarriage of justice,” and one that Enon’s attorney was pleased with.

Adams’ Attorney Erica Ann Probst appealed to the supreme court after a Clark County common pleas judge and an appeals court similarly dismissed the case on jurisdiction.

Adams’ initial suit alleged the village owed her damages in excess of $25,000 due to a retaliatory termination for filing workers’ compensation claims after she fell in the police department’s parking lot in early 2009, according to court documents.

She later amended her complaint to include disability and age discrimination, which were considered moot by Common Pleas Judge Douglas Rastatter, due to his dismissal of the case.

In a wrinkle to the story, the appeals court deemed that Rastatter erred in declaring Adams’ amended claims of discrimination moot and that, as a matter of course, still needs to “rule on the merits of Adams’s motion.”

So those amended complaints will go back to Rastatter to decide if he will accept them or not.

In the meantime, the case may not yet leave the Ohio Supreme Court.

“I’m shocked at the determination that there was no jurisdiction … and I will be filing a motion to reconsider, and am meeting with the Ohio Unemployment Lawyer’s Association early next week to discuss their filing of an amicus brief,” Probst told the Springfield News-Sun.

“Enon is pleased with the decision from the Supreme Court, not only for itself but for all Ohio employers,” Village Attorney Lynette Dinkler said.

“This is a case where Enon has done nothing wrong and will continue to oppose … claims (Adams) attempts to assert, should the trial court allow either of the disability claims be amended into the complaint,” Dinkler said.

Justices Paul E. Pfeifer, Terrence O’Donnell, Sharon L. Kennedy and Judith L. French concurred with the village’s opposition to the court’s jurisdiction, while Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor and Justices Judith Ann Lanzinger and William M. O’Neill dissented.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Heather Heyer's parents preach love, action after daughter’s death: 'You just magnified her'
Heather Heyer's parents preach love, action after daughter’s death: 'You just magnified her'

The parents of Heather Heyer, the woman killed Saturday in a protest against white supremacy in Charlottesville, Virginia, remembered the 32-year-old as a big-hearted, outspoken woman who wanted equality for all. About 1,000 mourners gathered Wednesday for Heyer’s memorial in downtown Charlottesville, the same city where police said Heyer was...
Judge Judy lets dog loose in courtroom to prove who its owner is
Judge Judy lets dog loose in courtroom to prove who its owner is

An argument over ownership of a dog landed two parties in front of television judge Judy Sheindlin. In her own form of Solomon’s Law, rather than cut the dog in half, Sheindlin ordered the dog to be let loose in the courtroom so it could determine who was its owner. In the clip from the show posted Monday, Sheindlin orders a woman with the defendant...
Video: Florida police use 3 Tasers, baton, 4 handcuffs to arrest bar customer
Video: Florida police use 3 Tasers, baton, 4 handcuffs to arrest bar customer

Jacksonville Beach police in Florida used a Taser, a baton and four sets of handcuffs to arrest a man accused of punching a bouncer and walking out on his $235 bar tab on Sunday. >> Read more trending news Facebook video of the takedown outside Surfer the Bar is leading some beachgoers to question why the use of force was necessary in the first...
Target discontinues popular brands, but sees increase in sales
Target discontinues popular brands, but sees increase in sales

Target Corp. has announced several changes including store redesigns and discontinuing some of its popular clothing brands, and the changes seem to be working in the retailer’s favor. The chain store increased its comparable sales and traffic growth, according to its second quarter earnings report. Second quarter comparable sales increased about...
George H.W., George W. Bush condemn ‘racial bigotry’ in Charlottesville statement
George H.W., George W. Bush condemn ‘racial bigotry’ in Charlottesville statement

Two former presidents have joined the growing chorus of political voices directly condemning racial bigotry in the wake of a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville. >> Read more trending news  Former Presidents George H.W. and George W. Bush released a statement on Wednesday morning, addressing the past weekend&rsquo...
More Stories