Supreme Court hears debate on executing mentally disabled


The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments this week over how much leeway states have in determining which inmates are fit for the death penalty.

The case in question involves Freddie Lee Hall, a Florida death row inmate convicted of murder, but is raising questions about the state's policy on executing people with mental disabilities. (Via USA Today)

In 2002, the Supreme Court barred states from using the death penalty on the mentally disabled, but allowed the states to determine their own standards for mental disability. (Via CNN)

Florida does not execute inmates who score below 70 on an IQ test. The state says, although he has scored as low as 60, most of Hall's scores have come in the low 70s. So, despite the opinions of psychologists who have examined Hall and deemed him mentally disabled, Florida plans to move ahead with his execution.

Florida is one of four states that use a strict IQ standard without allowing for a margin of error. Writing forThe Atlantic, Andrew Cohen says, "These states aren't just outliers in constitutional law—they are outliers in science and medicine, too" for ignoring the opinions of experts and psychologists.

The overall number of executions nationwide each year has steadily dropped in recent years. Last year there were 39. Thirty-two states still use the death penalty. Between 1984 and 2001, states executed 44 people with mental disabilities. (Via Wikimedia Commons / California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation)

The U.S. is one of the last few Western nations with the death penalty. Many European countries, Russia, Canada and Mexico have all banned prisoner executions.
 

More on Newsy



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Kroger appoints new division president
Kroger appoints new division president

The Kroger Co. has appointed a new ruler division president. Liz Ferneding has been appointed as the new ruler division president, effective July 31. She succeeds Paul Bowen, who replaced in May. The ruler division is headquartered in Seymour, Indiana, with 48 stores operating in Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio...
Walmart cashier’s act of kindness helps foster parent in time of need
Walmart cashier’s act of kindness helps foster parent in time of need

A trip to Walmart is usually not the highlight of a long day, but a cashier at a box store in Oklahoma may have just changed that perception. Nick Tate, 20, works at the Newcastle Walmart. One Friday night, he may have helped change the life of a foster mom. >> Read more trending news He said that she had two little girls and a baby. She was...
Man, woman accused of taking purses from self-storage business
Man, woman accused of taking purses from self-storage business

A man and woman are facing charges after being accused of breaking into a storage unit and taking nearly 50 purses on Wednesday morning. Jason R. Moak, 36, and Jessica L. Truman, 30, were arrested and charged with breaking and entering and possession of criminal tools. Moak is also facing a falsification charge. The pair plead not guilty to all charges...
GOP cheerleader divorces Dem state attorney husband over lack of Trump support
GOP cheerleader divorces Dem state attorney husband over lack of Trump support

Personal and financial details of the divorce settlement between former Miami Dolphins cheerleader Lynn Aronberg and Palm Beach County State Attorney Dave Aronberg were released in an unusual press statement Thursday. The statement notes that, “according to a source familiar with the negotiations, the former Lynn Lewis, who spun her...
Man accused of stealing from security company on first day at work, police say
Man accused of stealing from security company on first day at work, police say

It was his first day on the job, but police said a newly hired security guard made off with $100,000. Fairfield police said that Larry Brooks, 19, was caught on camera taking the money, News 12 New Jersey reported. Brooks was a security officer at Garda Security, a company that provides cash vaults and armored car services, WNBC reported. Police said...
More Stories