breaking news

Family values Ohio lawmaker led double life as gay man, reports say

Did life on Earth really come from Mars?


A new scientific theory made headlines Thursday — and they’re some headlines.

“Earth life ‘may have come from Mars’” (Via BBC)

“Life On Earth, From Mars? Why We Might All Be Alien Invaders” (Via International Business Times)

And “All humans may be ‘Martians’?” (Via National Post)

The story comes from biochemist Dr. Steven Benner, who gave a talk Thursday at the Goldschmidt Conference in Florence, Italy. (Via Foundation for Applied Molecular EvolutionGeochemical Society)

Benner argues several materials necessary for life to form wouldn’t have been available on Earth 3 billion years ago when life first arose — but there would have been plenty of them on Mars.

But is this just another wild theory meant to generate publicity? Well, that depends on who you ask. (Via Vanity Fair)

Benner has his supporters, such as prominent biologist Richard Dawkins, who said the idea is “not totally silly.” That’s some high praise.

And NBC science writer Alan Boyle said: “One thing’s for sure: Benner is not a kook. He was one of the first chemists to voice skepticism about the claims for arsenic-based life, which stirred up such a fuss in 2010.”

Even Benner’s critics say he does great work and that his ideas are plausible.

More than 100 meteorites found on Earth have been traced to Mars, most likely thrown into space by an asteroid strike. (Via NASA)

 And it’s long been thought certain hardy microbes could actually survive for a while in the vacuum of space. (Via National Science Foundation)

 So the critics admit much of what Benner says is possible, but they do take issue with the sensationalist press release.

 Scientific American’s Caleb Scharf points out Benner’s explanation for how life arose is just one of many possible theories — and most others don’t require material from Mars.

 Astrobiologist David Grinspoon says so much about the origin of life is still up in the air, it’s just as likely Earth was seeded by life from Venus as from Mars.

 So at this point, the answer to the question “Are we all Martians?” is a not-so-sensational “maybe” — although it does make for a good headline.

See more at Newsy.com


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Beavercreek sports center looking for new sponsor for naming rights
Beavercreek sports center looking for new sponsor for naming rights

A Beavercreek youth sports center is looking for a new sponsor after it mutually ended a partnership with a local heating and air conditioning business. McAfee Heating & Air Conditioning has ended its partnership with the sports center at 1321 Research Park Drive in Beavercreek. The 55,000 square-foot facility which opened June 30 last year was called...
Which grocery stores are open Thanksgiving?
Which grocery stores are open Thanksgiving?

Do you ever get that sinking feeling that you forgot something? Despite the fact you’ve employed redundancy measures that would make NASA jealous, you can almost guarantee that you’ve missed some small item needed for your Thanksgiving feast.  Don’t worry. Several grocery store chains across the country will be open on Thanksgiving...
Beyonce leads Adele, Taylor Swift as richest woman in music
Beyonce leads Adele, Taylor Swift as richest woman in music

Beyonce has replaced Taylor Swift on Forbes’ annual list of the world’s richest women in music. Despite Swift’s record-breaking year, Beyonce is still reaping the benefits of a wildly successful 2016, according to figures pulled by Forbes for its World's Highest-Paid Women In Music list. The publication looked at pretax income...
Penguins sign five 'prospects' to 1-day contracts for Make-A-Wish
Penguins sign five 'prospects' to 1-day contracts for Make-A-Wish

The Pittsburgh Penguins signed five new prospects Tuesday morning to one-day contracts. General Manager Jim Rutherford made the announcement at the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex in Cranberry. “It’s good to have a group of guys here to help the Penguins have a little more consistency,” Rutherford said. “It’s my honor to welcome...
Local girl performing in Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade
Local girl performing in Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade

An 11-year-old Springboro girl should be singing and dancing in front of the Macy’s department store in New York City on Thursday during the 91st Annual Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. “This is a once in a lifetime opportunity,” Lily Nevers said Tuesday during a break from rehearsals in New York for a performance of Irving Berlin&rsquo...
More Stories