breaking news

Springfield trucking company: Widening I-70 will make corridor safer

Autopsy records from Pike County killings can be withheld, court rules


The Ohio Supreme Court ruled Thursday that autopsy records in the 2016 Pike County murders may be withheld from the public until the homicide investigation is closed.

5 things to know about Pike County murders

The 4-3 ruling comes in a case filed by the Cincinnati Enquirer and Columbus Dispatch against the Pike County Coroner’s office. The newspapers were seeking release of unredacted records in the case of eight members of the Rhoden and Gilley families who were murdered in April 2106.

Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor, writing the majority opinion, said the coroner records fell under an exemption in the public records law that allowed governments to withhold confidential law enforcement investigatory records. In separate dissents, Justices Sharon Kennedy and Patrick Fischer said that lawmakers clearly made autopsy reports public records and the exemption does not apply.

The autopsies were conducted by Hamiltion County on behalf of Pike County, which received the final reports in July 2016. Within days, both papers requested the records from Pike County Coroner David Kessler, who denied the requests. After lawsuits were filed, redacted copies were released.

PAST COVERAGE

3 recent developments in Pike County murders case

Pike County murders: Searches prompt more questions

Who are the Wagners? Investigators want to know



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Job outlook is promising for Good Samaritan employees, official says
Job outlook is promising for Good Samaritan employees, official says

After Wednesday’s announcement that Good Samaritan Hospital will shut its doors for good at the end of the year, many in the Miami Valley are wondering what will happen to the facility’s 1,600 employees. The hospital’s parent company, Premier Health, said its goal is to offer jobs to all those employees at its other facilities in...
Dale Earnhardt Jr. crashes into tree after helping car stuck in snow
Dale Earnhardt Jr. crashes into tree after helping car stuck in snow

It could be said that former NASCAR driver Dale Earnhardt Jr. has some of the best driving skills ever, having made a living out of going more than 200 miles an hour on some of our country’s toughest racetracks. Yet, with snow involved, Earnhardt got into some trouble while trying to help other people stuck in the weather. >> Read more...
Ann Curry speaks out about Matt Lauer sexual harassment allegations in new interview
Ann Curry speaks out about Matt Lauer sexual harassment allegations in new interview

Ann Curry has remained tight-lipped since the news broke of Matt Lauer’s alleged sexual misconduct, but she spoke about the scandal on “CBS This Morning.” The 61-year-old journalist and producer appeared on the program Wednesday to discuss her new PBS docuseries “We’ll Meet Again” and she was asked to speak...
Woman accused of killing father, encasing body in concrete for weeks
Woman accused of killing father, encasing body in concrete for weeks

In William Mussack’s final text conversation with his son on Dec. 7, the Colorado man relayed a chilling fear: he believed his daughter may have poisoned his food.  “William described the feeling of being drugged and falling asleep in a recliner chair for 15 hours,” an arrest affidavit obtained by KDVR in Denver read. &ldquo...
Lawmakers take steps to remove Ohio Supreme Court justice from bench
Lawmakers take steps to remove Ohio Supreme Court justice from bench

Ohio Supreme Court Justice Bill O’Neill, a Democrat, is stepping off the bench Jan. 26 but Republican lawmakers are hot on his heels, calling for him to appear before the Ohio General Assembly to explain why he is campaigning for governor while also serving as a justice. Judicial conduct rules mandate that judges resign when the become candidates...
More Stories