You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Springfield leader wants lifetime warranty on hazardous waste cleanup


City Commissioner Kevin O’Neill wants a “lifetime warranty” that hazardous waste from the Tremont City Barrel Fill site in northern Clark County won’t affect Springfield’s drinking water.

After years of advocating for an extensive, $56 million cleanup plan, community activists are now backing a new version of a clean-up plan dubbed 9a that would cost an estimated $24 million.

RELATED: Activists question cleanup costs of Clark County hazardous waste

The barrel fill is an 8.5-acre section of a closed landfill that had been used for industrial waste barrels. It contains an estimated 1.5 million gallons of hazardous waste buried in the ground. If left in its current state, the site could be a risk to public health decades from now because the barrels could deteriorate and some of the chemicals leach into the groundwater, officials have said.

Community members and local leaders have long implored the U.S. EPA to remove all hazardous waste from the barrel fill — which they worry could seep into Springfield’s drinking water supply.

Clark County Health Commissioner Charles Patterson and People for Safe Water’s Marilyn Welker updated city commissioners on the site’s clean-up at Tuesday’s meeting.

MORE: Community wants Tremont Barrel Fill waste gone

The current U.S. EPA cleanup plan calls for digging up all of the barrels, taking out the ones with liquid waste and putting the barrels filled with solid waste back in place with the addition of a double liner and a leak detection system.

In recent months, Welker says the U.S. EPA made it clear to local legislators that it would move on to other projects if the community doesn’t cooperate with its less expensive plan.

“It was communicated to us very clearly,” Welker said. “Our assignment now is to push on 9a and to make those modifications go as far and as deep as we can. I don’t see that as, at this point, giving up the deepest and biggest concerns we have, which is that high quantity of very toxic materials.”

The change in direction comes in conflict with everything O’Neill has worked toward in the past 26 years, he said.

“It’s called a lifetime warranty,” O’Neill said. “It all has to go. We cannot afford any of it to be left because of what might happen … We didn’t cause this problem and we want it fixed. The city of Springfield is going to be the big loser if it does creep into our well system.”

DETAILS: Proposed changes to mining permit concerns Clark County residents

After reading a Springfield News-Sun story on the issue in early February, O’Neill was surprised by the number of people who were “ready to throw in the towel,” he said. He wants to hire professional legal counsel to examine the city and county’s position moving forward.

“We can’t lead them to believe that we’re willing to negotiate on that going away,” O’Neill said. “There are other ways to fix this. We haven’t even asked the community if they’re willing to fund it if necessary, and I think they would be … We have to have the courage and determination to hold their feet to the fire.”

People for Safe Water isn’t recommending something that’s a cop out, City Commissioner Karen Duncan said.

“It’s a very, very heartfelt, very difficult decision to make any kind of a compromise here,” she said. “There are things that we are absolutely going to not compromise on becasue those are the things we feel put our water at risk.”

MORE COVERAGE: First female Wittenberg science prof leaves $2.3M to university

Future generations will be revisiting this, O’Neill said. The commission owes it to the community to give cost estimates on what a clean-up may cost, whether it be between $10 million, $15 million or $20 million, he said. The city just spent more than $50 million on EPA-mandated updates to its wastewater treatment plant, which he said might not be needed if the water supply is contaminated.

Welker won’t stop until there are answers to how protective liners and other modifications will be in the future, she said.

The federal EPA was expected to move forward with a $56 million plan, Alternative 4a, to remove all hazardous waste from the barrel fill. However, in 2011, the federal agency issued its final decision, the $28 million Alternative 9a, which called for barrels containing industrial waste to be dug up and then reburied on-site in a lined landfill. Officials and local citizens have fought for years to have the clean-up plan reverted back to Alternative 4a. Since that time, a modified version of Alternative 9a was estimated to cost about $24 million.

RELATED: Springfield firefighters union upset with move to ‘lower the standard’ for hiring

People for Safe Water wants the site placed on the National Priorities List because its leaders say it will assure compliance, accountability and future monitoring. It’s also possible the federal agency could enforce action against the potentially responsible parties, Welker said.

A report completed in October by U.S. EPA consultant Tetra Tech recommended removal of nearly 1,000 barrels, described as “the worst of the worst.”

The activist group seeks permanent removal of certain barrels containing the most mobile and toxic chemicals. They’re meeting with Chicago-based project manager Jim Saric on March 23 — the first meeting since June 2016, Welker said.

While the most recent plan has been modified recently, more corrections are needed to ensure chemicals don’t seep into Springfield’s water supply, Patterson said. The ultimate goal is to get all of the hazardous waste off of the site, he said.

“We’re making progress toward that,” Patterson said. “I’m not going to sit here and promise the commission that that’s exactly where we’re going to end up, but we are making headway.”

The most important thing is for county and city officials to remain a united front, he said.

“We can’t let our guard down until this is done,” Patterson said.

FIVE NEWS-SUN MUST READS

Historic downtown Springfield site may become year-round marketplace

Overdose epidemic spreads, strains Springfield first responders

New Carlisle wants to evict family’s 100-pound pet pig

Special report: Healthy Springfield

Man appears to OD at Clark County Municipal Court



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

JobsOhio ad mistakenly claims John Glenn ‘orbited the moon’
JobsOhio ad mistakenly claims John Glenn ‘orbited the moon’

The state’s JobsOhio program bought a full-page advertisement in The Economist magazine that included a mistake stating former astronaut John Glenn orbited the moon According to Cleveland.com, the insert touting the state’s private economic development program mistakenly touted, “From the Wright brothers inventing powered flight...
Ohio sues to recoup $604K it spent on tainted Enon water cleanup
Ohio sues to recoup $604K it spent on tainted Enon water cleanup

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office has sued the owner of a manufacturing plant’s estate to recoup more than $604,000 it spent cleaning up contamination that got into the village of Enon’s drinking water source more than 20 years ago. The Ohio Environmental Protection Agency spent the money to oversee and supervise the cleanup of the...
Ohio Politics Today: Should medics stop responding to overdoses?; Senate releases health bill details
Ohio Politics Today: Should medics stop responding to overdoses?; Senate releases health bill details

Here’s a look at today’s top political stories from around Ohio and Washington. Frustration with the escalating opiate epidemic is growing, along with costs for localities and emergency medical services. Middletown City Council member Dan Picard asked during this week’s meeting if the city was bound by law to respond to overdoses...
Businesses may face penalties for prohibiting guns in private vehicles
Businesses may face penalties for prohibiting guns in private vehicles

Business groups are fighting an Ohio Senate proposal that will open them up to civil lawsuits by employees and others who bring handguns on to company property. “For us this isn’t a concealed carry issue as much as this is an employer rights issue,” said Chris Kershner, vice president, public policy & economic development for the...
Pizza may soon be delivered by robot in Ohio
Pizza may soon be delivered by robot in Ohio

If things pan out the pizza dude bringing you your hot slices could be a compact little robot that looks pretty much like a cooler on wheels. The Ohio Senate version of the state budget authorizes the use of a “personal delivery device” that is electrically powered and “intended to transport property on sidewalks and crosswalks.&rdquo...
More Stories