You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

breaking news

Classes resume at West Liberty with message from shooting victim

Trial starts for mother of murdered 2-year-old

The trial of a woman whose boyfriend pleaded guilty to murdering her 2-year-old son started Monday in Montgomery County Common Pleas Court with opening statements and testimony from a forensic pathologist.

Michelle Mooty, 23, of Dayton, was indicted by the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office on counts of permitting child abuse (causing death), complicity to commit felonious assault and endangering children.

Levi Barrett died Dec. 8, 2011. Joe Curtis Watson IV, the boyfriend, took Barrett to Good Samaritan Hospital, where medical personnel found numerous scars and extensive bruising all over Barrett’s body. Hospital personnel called Dayton police, whom arrested Watson and Mooty that day.

An autopsy revealed Barrett suffered deep contusions and bruising to internal organs and the coroner’s office ruled the death a homicide from blunt force trauma. Watson had told police the boy had fallen down a set of stairs.

Watson pleaded guilty to murder and three counts of endangering children and was sentenced in December to 15 years to life in prison.

During opening statements, assistant prosecutor Jon Marshall said evidence will show that Barrett “needed his mother to protect him” and that Mooty “chose not to do that.” Marshall also said this was “a trial of accountability and responsibility.”

Defense attorney Elizabeth Scott said that “hindsight is 20/20” and that no one had any idea of the level of abuse Watson inflicted upon the toddler.

The jury of seven women and five men plus two alternates watched as Montgomery County Coroner’s Office pathologist Brian Casto pointed out numerous bruises, scars and internal injuries all over Barrett’s body from 34 autopsy photos. Mooty did not look at the photos, keeping her eyes fixed on the defense table as Casto testified.

The trial in Judge Frances McGee’s courtroom is expected to last through Wednesday and possibly Thursday.

When he announced Watson’s sentence, prosecutor Mat Heck Jr. said, “We plan to hold the victim’s mother accountable for her actions as well, for permitting this abuse.”

A caseworker visited Mooty’s home in late November 2011 on a referral, according to Ann Stevens of the Montgomery County Jobs & Family Services. Details of the referral and home visits are not public records under Ohio law.

Mooty has three other children, including a toddler with Watson.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Crime

Central State lands Ohio funding to update Brown Library
Central State lands Ohio funding to update Brown Library

Central State University is moving forward with updates to its Hallie Q. Brown Memorial Library following the State Controlling Board’s approval on Monday of more than $388,000 in funding for phase two of the facility’s modernization project. RELATED: CSU president named a ‘most influential’ leader in higher education The controlling...
Clark County Municipal Court cases
Clark County Municipal Court cases

CASES CALLED MONDAY INCLUDED: Ashlee N. Adams, 22, of 1715 W. North St., theft, innocent, continued, bond $1,500; criminal trespass, innocent, continued. Anna C. Badger, 37, of 325 S. Shaffer Ave., theft, innocent, continued. Daniel L. Billingsley Sr., 25, of 449 E. Liberty St., possession of drugs, innocent, continued, public defender appointed, bond...
Billionaire wants Ohio crime victims rights protected

A California billionaire whose sister was murdered 34 years ago is bringing his mission to expand crime victims’ rights to Ohio. Henry T. Nicholas, III, co-founder of Broadcom Corp. and No. 247 on Forbes list of richest Americans , is funding an effort to put a constitutional amendment before Ohio voters that would guarantee rights to crime victims...
Police: Man tries to steal car left to warm, thwarted by manual transmission
Police: Man tries to steal car left to warm, thwarted by manual transmission

An Oregon man is in jail Tuesday after police said he tried to steal a car left to warm in a driveway and failed because he didn't know how to use the car's manual transmission. Washington County sheriff's deputies arrested Jakob Crume, 20, on suspicion of unlawful entry and use of a motor vehicle, among other charges. He was booked into Washington...
Super Bowl 2017: 6 stats from Falcons-Patriots matchup
Super Bowl 2017: 6 stats from Falcons-Patriots matchup

The Atlanta Falcons and New England Patriots will play in Super Bowl LI, which Vegas oddsmakers are already predicting to be among the highest scoring on record. Fueling those predictions are the results of Sunday’s 44-21 NFC Championship win by the Falcons over the Green Bay Packers at the Georgia Dome and the Patriots&rsquo...
More Stories