Jury convicts man shot in rape-kidnapping


A man accused of raping and kidnapping a woman, only to be shot by when that woman took his gun, was convicted by a jury late Friday afternoon.

Duane Portman Sr., 44, was found guilty on single counts of aggravated robbery, abduction and six counts of rape.

Clark County Common Pleas Judge Douglas Rastatter sent Portman back to the county jail, where he will be detained until sentencing June 28.

Portman was shot in the face on Sunday, Sept. 2, at his business, Labelz 4 Less on East Main Street, by a woman who told police Portman held a gun to her head and raped her at the business.

The victim, who is an escort, told police she wrestled the gun from Portman and shot him before she drove to Good Samaritan Hospital in Dayton for help.

Detectives interviewed Portman after he initially told investigators he couldn’t remember who shot him or where he was when he was shot.

The Clark County Common Pleas jury had been deliberating for less than four hours Friday afternoon before informing the trial judge that a verdict had been reached.

Amy Smith, a county assistant prosecutor, said, Portman’s story that he was a victim didn’t match the forensic evidence.

The woman agreed to meet Portman at his place of business, but her intention was not to have sex, Smith said. The woman tried to leave when she felt uncomfortable and Portman pulled a gun.

“The problem with the defendant’s position has been is that there hasn’t been a position from the get-go.”

Portman came to police to explain his version of what happened once the woman came forward and alleged rape, Smith said.

A family member of Portman’s left the courtroom after the verdicts were announced, saying she “couldn’t hear the rest” as the bailiff opened the door.

A man who identified himself as Portman’s brother did not agree to be interviewed on camera, but said his brother “said everything that needed to be said” in court and that the jury did not listen.

The man also noted there was one black juror compared to 11 white jurors and he felt that impacted the verdict.

Smith said the jury was seated fairly, in accordance with legal procedure. “The jury is made up of members of the community. Who was seated is who was seated,” she said.

One of the jurors, a black man, said he knew some of the defendant’s family members and was removed from jury service for this case, Smith said.

The woman, in the back of the courtroom, wept after the verdict was delivered.

Smith said the woman expressed relief that the case was over and that Portman would not bother her anymore.



Next Up in Crime

Solar Eclipse 2017: Google Doodle marks sky show
Solar Eclipse 2017: Google Doodle marks sky show

A once-in-a-lifetime celestial event has been honored with its own Google Doodle. The animation features two extra-terrestrials playing their version of lunar volleyball. >> Read more trending news Their ball is the moon, and every volley blocks out the sun momentarily. Clicking on the animation, the search engine allows the user to learn more...
Teacher at elite private school accused of sex with 16-year-old student
Teacher at elite private school accused of sex with 16-year-old student

A teacher at an elite private school faces felony charges after the Los Angeles Police Department arrested her on suspicions of an illicit relationship with a 16-year-old male student. According to multiple media outlets, including the Los Angeles Times, Fox News and the Daily Mail, science teacher Aimee Palmitessa, 45, was arrested...
Michelle Carter case back in court to clarify sentence
Michelle Carter case back in court to clarify sentence

A hearing will be held Monday to clarify the sentence handed down in the texting-suicide trial. The state’s Office of the Commissioner of Probation is looking for clarification about Michelle Carter’s punishment after part of it was put on hold by the judge. The confusion centers around the court’s ability to stay only a portion...
What’s the next big thing for online retail? 3D shopping technology
What’s the next big thing for online retail? 3D shopping technology

Retail leaders say a 3D shopping platform that allows customers to feel like they’re in the store from the comfort of their computer is the next big revolution for online shopping. The 360 Mall 3D Shopping Platform, new technology created by Australian entrepreneur Alex Danieli, is an e-commerce solution garnering major attention from investors...
7 of the craziest, coolest places to stay in Hocking Hills
7 of the craziest, coolest places to stay in Hocking Hills

Ohio’s Hocking Hills region offers plenty of charming B&Bs, cozy inns and romantic cottages to choose from if you are looking to make a weekend out of your road trip. Here are a few options that are off the beaten path to grab a night’s rest in. Experience the magic and tranquility of camping in traditional Sioux Native American tipis,...
More Stories